Was Akash Deep's delivery that uprooted Joe Root a no-ball? Here's what you should know
New Delhi: On the fourth day of the second Test being played between India and England, Akash Deep bowled England batsman Joe Root for just 6 runs in the second innings and sent him to the pavilion. This wicket was considered the turning point of the match, but now a controversy has arisen over it. Commentator Alison Mitchell believes that this ball was a back-foot no-ball and should have been declared invalid. Commentator Alison Mitchell's claim
Alison Mitchell, who was commentating on BBC Test Match Special (BBC TMS), commented long after the bowling that Akash Deep's ball, which got Root out, could have been a no-ball. He said, 'At the time of ball release, Akash Deep's back foot was about two inches outside the line of the return crease. The ball should not have been considered valid, but it was not caught.' What does the back-foot no-ball rule say?
According to MCC rule 21.5 of cricket, for a valid delivery, the bowler's back foot must be within the line of the return crease determined by his bowling style and must not even touch the line. If the bowler's back foot goes outside the return crease, it is considered a 'back-foot no-ball', even if the front foot is in the correct position. Is this the first time it has happened?
Back-foot no-ball incidents are rarely seen in cricket, as most umpires focus only on the front-foot. However, it is clear in the rule that the back foot should also be within the crease. Interestingly, sometimes the front foot goes outside the return crease, like Ravichandran Ashwin once did in the IPL while bowling against Rajasthan Royals, but it was legal under the rule. Did the umpires commit error?
In this case, the umpires considered the ball legal and Joe Root was given out. But if Mitchell's claim is true, it was a technical lapse, which should have been stopped by the on-field or third umpire. In such a situation, the question arises whether enough attention is being paid to back-foot no-balls? Will it affect the result of the match?
Even if it was a technical lapse, until the umpires take any action, the wicket will be considered valid. England still need 536 runs to win and they are at 72/3. In such a situation, this controversy may become a topic of discussion, but at the moment it does not seem to have a direct impact on the result.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hindustan Times
22 minutes ago
- Hindustan Times
Shubman Gill ‘made Bazball lick dust': India captain's historic Edgbaston high joins Gabba, Cape Town folklore
Shubman Gill and Co. bounced back in emphatic fashion to completely outclass England at Edgbaston to level the series 1-1. The Indian team made a statement at Edgbaston after losing the first Test: they were not going to be pushovers and thrashed England at their fortress by a mammoth 336-run to stamp their authority. The Bazball was of no effectiveness when India set a massive 608-run target in the fourth innings, and England were all out for 271, courtesy a six-fer by Akash Deep, which dismantled the English batting line-up known for their counter-attacking approach. Shubman Gill led India to a historic win at Edgbaston.(AP) Shubman Gill put on a show for the ages, dismantling England's bowling with twin gems — a marathon 269 in the first innings and a fluent 161 in the second. His poise, shot selection, and dominance across both knocks anchored India's batting and underlined his rise as a world-class Test batter. On the bowling front, Mohammed Siraj and Akash Deep stepped up in Jasprit Bumrah's absence. Siraj's six-wicket burst in the first innings set the tone, and Akash matched it with a fiery six-for in the second, flattening England's resistance and sealing India's emphatic win. Former India cricketer Aakash Chopra discussed India's emphatic performance and pointed out the stellar efforts of Gill, Siraj, and Akash Deep in scripting history. "It was both record-breaking and record-making. History has been created at the Edgbaston ground. Captain (Shubman) Gill had laid the foundation, with a mountain of runs. More than 1000 runs, the first time ever in the history of Indian Test cricket, and then if it was Miyan Magic (Mohammed Siraj) in the first innings, it was Akash Deep in the second innings," Chopra said on his YouTube channel. England's outing in the second Test at Edgbaston ended in disappointment, as they slumped to a heavy 336-run defeat at the hands of a commanding Indian team. Despite moments of flair that reflected their trademark 'Bazball' style, the hosts failed to sustain pressure across sessions. Individual efforts stood out, but collectively, they were comprehensively outclassed by an Indian side that excelled with both bat and ball to level the series in emphatic fashion. 'We're conquering frontiers': Aakash Chopra Chopra pointed out India's recent record of breaching overseas fortresses in red-ball cricket with iconic wins in Cape Town, Perth, Brisbane and now Birmingham. "We had never won at Edgbaston to date, but we have done that now. If we see the last few overseas wins, we have created history every time. We had never won in Cape Town, the Optus Stadium in Perth, and the Gabba, but we have won there now. We are conquering frontiers we hadn't conquered thus far. We made Bazball lick dust. This win needs to be celebrated. We have outplayed the opposing team in every department," he added. Meanwhile, skipper Shubman has confirmed that leading pacer Jasprit Bumrah will return to the playing XI for the Lord's Test, where they will look to take a 2-1 lead in the Anderson-Tendulkar Trophy.
Mint
28 minutes ago
- Mint
Stokes lauds incredible Akash Deep, says India outplayed England in every department
Birmingham, Jul 7 (PTI) England captain Ben Stokes conceded that India well and truly turned the tables on his team in every department of the game with pacer Akash Deep's "incredible" skill-set making the decisive difference in the second Test here. Playing his first game of the series, Akash Deep picked up a match haul of 10 wickets to fashion a famous 336-run win for India, who had never won on this ground prior to Sunday. The five-match showdown is now locked 1-1 with the third Test at Lord's from July 10. "I thought Akash exposed that crack last night and this morning. His ability to use and change his angles consistently and still be so accurate. He was zoning in on that crack. That one Harry Brook got this morning you can't do anything about that," Stokes said in the post-match press conference. The hallmark of his effort was relentlessly attacking the stumps from a good length and using the angles effectively. He was able to generate the most amount of seam movement in the match. He got one length ball to hit the crack and nip back sharply to thud in to Harry Brooks' pads. The England batter could not do anything about that peach. "Standing at the other end when Jamie Smith got a couple of those early on. It was seaming a foot off it. Incredible skillful to hone in on that zone while still changing his angles on the crease. I thought it was good," said Stokes. Task today was batting out 80 overs ========================= Resuming the day at 72 for three, England could only bat 52.1 overs on day five in the improbable chase of 608. The Stokes led side doesn't believe in draws but the captain said in as many words the target was out of reach. "...300 and something is obviously a big margin (for the defeat). We knew what task we had ahead of us going into when we first went out to bat. That changed when you lose three wickets last night and lose two early wickets," he said. "The task today was batting out the 80 overs. The result we always try to push towards, and look for, was us as a batting unit, to go out and bat the 80 overs was to go and play the way we play and focus on the fact that we knew we had to bat 80 overs." "...India pushed to get 600 for some obvious reasons," he said referring to India's delayed declaration on day four. Asked to pick two important moments of the game, Stokes said, "There were two moments in the game. Having them 200 for five and then not quite being able to blast them open, like we know that we can. "They ended up getting a big first innings total, obviously after us having a good start, having them five down for not too many on the board. "Then obviously being 80 for five in reply to the first innings, it's obviously going to be tough to get back into a position where you look to push on and be on the winning side at the end of the game." Did Indian pacers bowl better than England quicks? ================================ Stokes acknowledged the superiority of India's pace attack. "We nicked a few more than India did. It's one of those, where we went past the bat a few times, had a few nicks go in the game. We nicked them and India caught them. It can be such a frustrating game some times and be out there to watch this stuff unfold in front of you. "That's why you love it, being part of the emotions of this game. That is part of what makes Test cricket a game people love watching, a little bit of luck here and there and you are the team on top. "They played better as an all round unit, batting and bowling this week. We were in that position last week," Stokes added.
Mint
39 minutes ago
- Mint
‘Bowling England out Akash Deep' song goes viral after Edgbaston win; Internet reacts: ‘Put this as caller tune'
After the historic Edgbaston win, a song paying tribute to Indian cricketer Akash Deep's exemplary performance went viral on social media. A flurry of reactions flooded online as India marked record-breaking 336-run victory over England for the first time in a Test match at the venue. The caption to the viral post states, ''Akash Deep, Akash Deep, Akash Deep, Akash Deep, bowling England out Akash Deeep' Our friend with his 🎸 also loves !' A user wrote, 'Pain in voice,jyada deep de diya.' Another user stated, 'Should i put this as my caller tune?' A third user remarked, 'I'm sure you'll guess the original song.' A fourth comment read, '@ look what u did.' A fifth user replied, 'Too Deep.' Edgbaston win is special for India as the cricket team made record-breaking 336-run victory over England for the first time in a Test match at the venue. Following India's historic win, celebrated Indian cricketer Sachin Tendulkar, ICC Chairman Jay Shah and Former India captain Virat Kohli congratulated young team India. Edgbaston win is special as India not only marked their first-ever Test win at Birmingham's Edgbaston but also levelled up the five-match series 1-1. The achievement is noteworthy for another reason as the massive 336 score victory is the highest margin by which India has defeated any team away from home. Following India's historic win, celebrated Indian cricketer Sachin Tendulkar, ICC Chairman Jay Shah and Former India captain Virat Kohli congratulated young team India. Hailing, Shubham Gill, KL Rahul, Ravindra Jadeja and Rishabh Pant for their exceptional performance, Sachin Tendulkar wrote, "A 𝘚𝘩𝘶𝘣lime innings from the 𝘮𝘢𝘯 of the moment! Congratulations, @ShubmanGill, on powering India to a brilliant Test victory! @RishabhPant17,@klrahul, and @imjadeja batted very well, especially in the 2nd innings." The 52-year old legendary cricketer added, 'India's approach was to take England out of this game and force them to play differently, making sure that there would only be 1 winner. What impressed me most about the bowlers was the length they bowled. Needless to say, Akash Deep was the standout bowler, and in my opinion, he bowled the ball of the series to Joe Root. P.S.: Enjoyed the catch taken by Mohammad 'Jonty' Siraj.' Praising Indian cricket team, Jay Shah said, 'An outstanding Test match showcasing the depth and resilience of Indian cricket.' Jay Shah acknowledged Akash Deep's 10-wicket haul breakthrough performance and stated, "@ShubmanGill's 269 & 161 were innings of rare quality, while Akashdeep's 10-wicket haul marked a breakthrough performance. Valuable contributions from @imjadeja and @RishabhPant17 added to a well-earned team win. Looking forward to the next contest at Lord's." Congratulating Shubman Gill and Team India in a post on X, Virat Kohli stated, 'Great victory for India at Edgbaston. Fearless and kept pushing England to the wall. Brilliantly led by Shubhman with the bat and in the field and impactful performances from everyone. Special mention to Siraj and Akash for the way they bowled on this pitch.' BCCI also commended the electrifying showdown at the Home of Cricket, which marks India's finest overseas Test performances.
