logo
Seeman climbs a tree, and Tamil Nadu starts tapping into the toddy debate again

Seeman climbs a tree, and Tamil Nadu starts tapping into the toddy debate again

Time of India23-06-2025
The head of the Naam Tamizhar Katchi (We Tamils Party) caused a stir recently by climbing a palmyra tree and tapping toddy from its inflorescence. In doing so, he defied Section 4(d) of the Tamil Nadu Prohibition Act, 1937, which bans tapping from any toddy-producing tree, and invited prosecution under Section 4(e), which carries a penalty of up to three months in prison and a fine of ₹1,000.
Tapping toddy from the palmyra or coconut tree and fermenting it into liquor has been an age-old tradition across South India. Ancient Tamil poet Thiruvalluvar, who composed 1,330 couplets on various subjects, even devoted a chapter to verses on "abstinence from toddy". His advice was not just moral but practical, warning of the damage liquor can do to the brain. Yet, despite this counsel tendered 2,000 years ago, toddy consumption continues unchecked in rural areas.
Toddy came into the spotlight 90 years ago when the Government of India Act, 1935, came into effect and elections were held. The Congress came to power in eight provincial assemblies. In Madras Presidency, C Rajagopalachari was elected Premier, and one of his first actions was to implement prohibition in the province, in line with the Congress promise.
Asked about the loss of revenue, Rajaji responded by introducing India's first sales tax legislation, imposing a 1% tax on all goods sold and purchased to offset the shortfall.
by Taboola
by Taboola
Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links
Promoted Links
Promoted Links
You May Like
1 Bite Daily On An Empty Stomach Can Transform Your Health
Gundry MD
Learn More
Undo
However, after the Congress resigned from the provincial govts, the British did not waste any time. They lifted prohibition in 1944 and allowed the free sale of liquor to replenish the treasury through abkari contracts.
After Independence, prohibition was reintroduced in 1948, driven by Mahatma Gandhi's insistence on promoting total abstinence from alcohol. The Constitution, which came into force in 1950, included Article 47, which stated that "the state shall endeavour to bring about prohibition of the consumption, except for medicinal purposes, of intoxicating drinks and of drugs which are injurious to health".
Madras Province remained dry for nearly two decades under Congress rule. When DMK came to power under chief minister C N Annadurai, prohibition continued. After that, TN's liquor policy became a back-and-forth struggle, with each govt deciding whether the state would be dry based on its own stance on the issue.
In 1971, when M Karunanidhi became chief minister, prohibition was lifted. Just two years later, it was reintroduced.
In 1977, M G Ramachandran (MGR) became chief minister and relaxed prohibition, but liquor consumption was only allowed with a permit. By 1980, liquor was back on the scene, available even in sachets.
When J Jayalalithaa assumed office in 1991, she reimposed prohibition. In 2003, the state govt took control of the procurement and retail sale of Indian Made Foreign Liquor (IMFL), establishing a monopoly. The Prohibition Act and related rules were amended, giving the govt exclusive rights over liquor sales in TN.
It was ironic that the rules allowing the state to monopolise IMFL sales were created under the same Prohibition Act of 1937, effectively mocking the constitutional directive under Article 47.
While toddy is a fermented juice tapped from coconut and palmyra trees, its unfermented form is known as padhaneer. The Prohibition Act defines padhaneer as "juice drawn from a coconut, palmyra, date, or any other kind of palm tree into receptacles treated to prevent any fermentation and not fermented".
Over time, the argument that toddy is a healthier, more natural alcoholic drink than IMFL began to gain traction. In the 1960s, a political party called the Toddy Seekers Kazhagam contested elections, though unsuccessfully, demanding the right to tap toddy.
Since the Tamil Nadu govt established the Tamil Nadu State Marketing Corporation (Tasmac) for the retail vending of IMFL, a renewed toddy movement has begun, framing the debate as one between swadeshi (indigenous) and videshi (foreign) alcohol.
The head of the movement even threw an open challenge, offering ₹1 crore to anyone who could prove toddy was harmful to health.
Tasmac emerged as the state's biggest source of revenue, generating ₹50,000 crore annually. As a result, the govt was unwilling to consider pleas for opening toddy shops or permitting the tapping of toddy from coconut and palmyra trees.
In 2007, during Karunanidhi's tenure as chief minister, a public interest litigation was filed, claiming that it was unconstitutional for the state to sell IMFL while prohibiting the tapping and consumption of toddy.
A division bench of the Madras High Court dismissed the case and held that "a citizen has no fundamental right to trade or business in liquor as a privilege" (2007). Though petitioners claimed that toddy was a natural drink, the court observed that it could be adulterated with chemicals to increase its potency and rejected the argument.
To respond to demands from coconut and palm workers who lost livelihoods, the Karunanidhi govt appointed a committee chaired by Justice K P Sivasubramaniam.
It included several govt officials and a police officer. However, the committee's report was not unanimous. Justice Sivasubramaniam said total prohibition was ideal but added that in the absence of such prohibition, there was no harm in allowing the production and consumption of toddy.
Govt officials on the committee dissented. Using this dissent, the Karunanidhi govt appointed another official committee to review the report and submit fresh recommendations.
In his report, Justice Sivasubramaniam remarked on the irony of his appointment, wondering how a teetotaller like him was chosen to head a committee on toddy tapping. Though he was in the minority, he clearly stated that while total prohibition was not being enforced, the state could permit toddy tapping. However, he remained a staunch supporter of prohibition. He declared that he would never allow toddy tapping in his own coconut grove as he believed the decision to lift prohibition brought ruin to thousands of families.
He also noted that the Kongu region of western Tamil Nadu, a stronghold for the prohibition movement during the pre-independence era, was now at the forefront of demands to allow toddy tapping.
Today, as most political parties have distanced themselves from the issue,
Seeman
has reopened the debate. In a dramatic gesture, he climbed a palmyra tree fitted with wooden planks, tapped the juice, and drank it in defiance of the law.
Though the BJP's manifesto includes a promise to permit toddy tapping, the party quickly distanced itself from Seeman's actions. A police official said they were examining whether to initiate prosecution against the NTK leader. Several DMK allies questioned how Seeman could campaign for total prohibition while making an exception for toddy and extolling its virtues.
(The writer is a retired judge of Madras high court)
The head of the Naam Tamizhar Katchi (We Tamils Party) caused a stir recently by climbing a palmyra tree and tapping toddy from its inflorescence.
In doing so, he defied Section 4(d) of the Tamil Nadu Prohibition Act, 1937, which bans tapping from any toddy-producing tree, and invited prosecution under Section 4(e), which carries a penalty of up to three months in prison and a fine of ₹1,000.
Tapping toddy from the palmyra or coconut tree and fermenting it into liquor has been an age-old tradition across South India. Ancient Tamil poet Thiruvalluvar, who composed 1,330 couplets on various subjects, even devoted a chapter to verses on "abstinence from toddy".
His advice was not just moral but practical, warning of the damage liquor can do to the brain. Yet, despite this counsel tendered 2,000 years ago, toddy consumption continues unchecked in rural areas.
Toddy came into the spotlight 90 years ago when the Government of India Act, 1935, came into effect and elections were held. The Congress came to power in eight provincial assemblies. In Madras Presidency, C Rajagopalachari was elected Premier, and one of his first actions was to implement prohibition in the province, in line with the Congress promise.
Asked about the loss of revenue, Rajaji responded by introducing India's first sales tax legislation, imposing a 1% tax on all goods sold and purchased to offset the shortfall. However, after the Congress resigned from the provincial govts, the British did not waste any time. They lifted prohibition in 1944 and allowed the free sale of liquor to replenish the treasury through abkari contracts.
After Independence, prohibition was reintroduced in 1948, driven by Mahatma Gandhi's insistence on promoting total abstinence from alcohol.
The Constitution, which came into force in 1950, included Article 47, which stated that "the state shall endeavour to bring about prohibition of the consumption, except for medicinal purposes, of intoxicating drinks and of drugs which are injurious to health".
Madras Province remained dry for nearly two decades under Congress rule. When DMK came to power under chief minister C N Annadurai, prohibition continued.
After that, TN's liquor policy became a back-and-forth struggle, with each govt deciding whether the state would be dry based on its own stance on the issue.
In 1971, when M Karunanidhi became chief minister, prohibition was lifted. Just two years later, it was reintroduced. In 1977, M G Ramachandran (MGR) became chief minister and relaxed prohibition, but liquor consumption was only allowed with a permit. By 1980, liquor was back on the scene, available even in sachets.
When J Jayalalithaa assumed office in 1991, she reimposed prohibition. In 2003, the state govt took control of the procurement and retail sale of Indian Made Foreign Liquor (IMFL), establishing a monopoly. The Prohibition Act and related rules were amended, giving the govt exclusive rights over liquor sales in TN. It was ironic that the rules allowing the state to monopolise IMFL sales were created under the same Prohibition Act of 1937, effectively mocking the constitutional directive under Article 47.
While toddy is a fermented juice tapped from coconut and palmyra trees, its unfermented form is known as padhaneer. The Prohibition Act defines padhaneer as "juice drawn from a coconut, palmyra, date, or any other kind of palm tree into receptacles treated to prevent any fermentation and not fermented".
Over time, the argument that toddy is a healthier, more natural alcoholic drink than IMFL began to gain traction.
In the 1960s, a political party called the Toddy Seekers Kazhagam contested elections, though unsuccessfully, demanding the right to tap toddy.
Since the Tamil Nadu govt established the Tamil Nadu State Marketing Corporation (Tasmac) for the retail vending of IMFL, a renewed toddy movement has begun, framing the debate as one between swadeshi (indigenous) and videshi (foreign) alcohol. The head of the movement even threw an open challenge, offering ₹1 crore to anyone who could prove toddy was harmful to health.
Tasmac emerged as the state's biggest source of revenue, generating ₹50,000 crore annually. As a result, the govt was unwilling to consider pleas for opening toddy shops or permitting the tapping of toddy from coconut and palmyra trees.
In 2007, during Karunanidhi's tenure as chief minister, a public interest litigation was filed, claiming that it was unconstitutional for the state to sell IMFL while prohibiting the tapping and consumption of toddy.
A division bench of the Madras High Court dismissed the case and held that "a citizen has no fundamental right to trade or business in liquor as a privilege" (2007). Though petitioners claimed that toddy was a natural drink, the court observed that it could be adulterated with chemicals to increase its potency and rejected the argument.
To respond to demands from coconut and palm workers who lost livelihoods, the Karunanidhi govt appointed a committee chaired by Justice K P Sivasubramaniam.
It included several govt officials and a police officer. However, the committee's report was not unanimous. Justice Sivasubramaniam said total prohibition was ideal but added that in the absence of such prohibition, there was no harm in allowing the production and consumption of toddy.
Govt officials on the committee dissented. Using this dissent, the Karunanidhi govt appointed another official committee to review the report and submit fresh recommendations.
In his report, Justice Sivasubramaniam remarked on the irony of his appointment, wondering how a teetotaller like him was chosen to head a committee on toddy tapping. Though he was in the minority, he clearly stated that while total prohibition was not being enforced, the state could permit toddy tapping. However, he remained a staunch supporter of prohibition. He declared that he would never allow toddy tapping in his own coconut grove as he believed the decision to lift prohibition brought ruin to thousands of families.
He also noted that the Kongu region of western Tamil Nadu, a stronghold for the prohibition movement during the pre-independence era, was now at the forefront of demands to allow toddy tapping.
Today, as most political parties have distanced themselves from the issue, Seeman has reopened the debate. In a dramatic gesture, he climbed a palmyra tree fitted with wooden planks, tapped the juice, and drank it in defiance of the law. Though the BJP's manifesto includes a promise to permit toddy tapping, the party quickly distanced itself from Seeman's actions. A police official said they were examining whether to initiate prosecution against the NTK leader.
Several DMK allies questioned how Seeman could campaign for total prohibition while making an exception for toddy and extolling its virtues.
(The writer is a retired judge of Madras high court)
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

From Karnataka to Hyderabad, an elephant named Lakshmi will lead today's Muharram procession in Old City
From Karnataka to Hyderabad, an elephant named Lakshmi will lead today's Muharram procession in Old City

Indian Express

time30 minutes ago

  • Indian Express

From Karnataka to Hyderabad, an elephant named Lakshmi will lead today's Muharram procession in Old City

After travelling over 500 kilometres, when Lakshmi the elephant reached Hyderabad's Old City, a long queue of onlookers, mostly children carrying bananas, waited eagerly. Lakshmi had come from Sri Karibasaveshwara Mutt in Horapete, Karnataka's Tumkur district, to participate in Ashura, the 10th day of the month of Muharram. Muharram is a period of mourning that commemorates the death of Imam Hussein ibn Ali, the grandson of the Prophet, in the Battle of Karbala. Every year in Hyderabad, a procession led by an elephant on which an Alam is mounted leaves Bibi-ka-Alawa, the ashoorkhana in Dabeerpura, and reaches Ilahi Masjid accompanied by mourners. The Alam – a long plaque made of gold and studded with diamonds – from the Ashoorkhana, a place of worship, is believed to be blessed. This year, 32-year-old Lakshmi will carry the Alam during the procession. 'We are grateful that Lakshmi is part of the procession this year. Here, anyone is welcome,' Mirza Riyaz Ul Hassan Effendi, who travelled with the elephant from Tumkur to Hyderabad, told The Indian Express. Effendi is the AIMIM's MLC entrusted by the Congress-ruled state government to accompany the elephant. Lakhsmi is in the custody of the state of Telangana during its five-day stay in Hyderabad. Its mahout Syed Salim said, 'It is a very friendly elephant and enjoys the company of children. They, too, love giving it food.' Lakshmi eats 250 kg a day – mostly fruits, sugarcane, boiled lentils and rice. 'It's feasting time for Lakshmi now,' Salim said. Not long ago, during the time of the Nizams of Hyderabad, the procession was led by elephants from Hyderabad. 'Those elephants were the Nizam's. Till the last Nizam of Hyderabad, Mir Osman Ali Khan, the tradition of the Nizam's elephant leading the procession with the Alam mounted on them continued,' said Mohammed Mirza Asgar Hadi, a young onlooker interested in the Alam's history. In the Bibi-ka-Alawa, there are photographs of Osman Ali Khan with the Alam-carrying elephants. 'In recent years, the state government and AIMIM took the lead in getting the elephants for the procession,' Hadi said. It is not the first time an elephant from Karnataka has come to Hyderabad for Muharram. In 2023, an elephant named Madhuri from the neighbouring state led the procession. In 2024, it was Rupawati, an elephant from Davanagere. Lakshmi will remain with the Telangana state government for four more days. 'It will be bathed, fed and looked after very well,' said Salim, the mahout. 'Here in Hyderabad, the procession is a community affair,' Hadi said. Among those who gave bananas to Lakshmi was Divya, a 45-year-old who takes the blessings of elephants in the procession every year. 'It is auspicious,' Divya said.

Horoscope Tomorrow, July 06, 2025, read predictions for all sun signs
Horoscope Tomorrow, July 06, 2025, read predictions for all sun signs

Time of India

timean hour ago

  • Time of India

Horoscope Tomorrow, July 06, 2025, read predictions for all sun signs

Embrace everything that life has to offer! Tomorrow's horoscope unfolds the agenda set forth by the universe for each sign of the zodiac. Whether its relationship matters, job changes, or simply the reflection and realization moments, let celestial guidance take the lead. Be mindful; trust your instinct, and walk through the day confidently. Aries (Mar 21-Apr 20) Tomorrow holds the promise of unexpected insight for you. Pay attention to small signs around you as they may reveal important truths. Your mind will be sharp, helping you solve problems easily. This day will give you a chance to learn something new that can change your outlook. Stay calm and focused, and you will feel more confident by evening. Trust your instincts and remain open to surprises coming your way. Lucky Tip for Tomorrow: Stay patient; clarity will follow soon. Taurus (Apr 21-May 20) Trust that new opportunities are on the horizon for you tomorrow. Be ready to accept changes and keep your heart open. Your hard work will start showing results, and you may find support from unexpected people. It is a good day to start planning for the future with positivity. Avoid getting stuck in old habits; instead, try something new with confidence. Your calm and steady nature will help you make wise choices. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like 5 Books Warren Buffett Wants You to Read In 2025 Blinkist: Warren Buffett's Reading List Undo Believe in yourself, and the universe will reward you. Lucky Tip for Tomorrow: Embrace change with a hopeful heart. Gemini (May 21-Jun 21) Tomorrow is your day to clear your mind and welcome fresh energy. You will find it easier to communicate and share your thoughts clearly. Focus on what you can control, and do not stress over what you cannot change. New ideas will come to you quickly, so keep a notebook handy. This will help you capture bright moments of inspiration. Trust that every step you take is part of your growth. Lucky Tip for Tomorrow: Speak your truth with kindness. Cancer (Jun 22-Jul 22) Your intuition will guide you toward the right decision tomorrow. Listen carefully to your feelings and the quiet voice inside you. You may face situations that need patience and understanding. Trust yourself, as your heart knows what is best. Relationships with loved ones can improve if you show care and attention. Do not hesitate to slow down and reflect before acting. This will bring you peace and confidence in every choice you make. The stars encourage you to follow your inner light. Lucky Tip for Tomorrow: Trust your heart's quiet wisdom. Leo (Jul 23-Aug 23) A fresh start awaits—approach it with an open-heart tomorrow. You will feel more energetic and ready to face new challenges. Leave behind any doubts and focus on your goals with confidence. This is a good time to connect with others and share your ideas. Your natural charm will attract positive attention. Take small steps forward but keep your eyes on the bigger picture. Remember, every ending brings a new beginning, so welcome it with joy and hope. Lucky Tip for Tomorrow: Begin anew with courage and joy. Virgo (Aug 24-Sep 23) Small steps tomorrow could lead to big breakthroughs. Focus on your tasks patiently, and do not rush. Your careful planning and attention to detail will bring success. It is a good day to organize your thoughts and make simple changes that improve your routine. Trust your practical nature to guide you through any challenge. Even small progress will build your confidence and open new paths. Keep a positive attitude, and good news will come your way soon. Lucky Tip for Tomorrow: Take one step at a time carefully. Libra (Sep 24-Oct 23) Pay attention to subtle signs—they carry important messages for you tomorrow. Small details may seem simple, but they hold clues to bigger changes in your life. Your mind will be alert, helping you understand situations more clearly. Take time to observe what others say and do; this will guide you well. Avoid rushing into decisions—listen carefully to your inner voice. Balance will come when you trust these quiet signals. Stay calm and open, as tomorrow brings wisdom through gentle hints. Lucky Tip for Tomorrow: Notice small signs; they reveal truths. Scorpio (Oct 24-Nov 22) Let patience shape your actions tomorrow. You may face moments that test your calm, but staying patient will bring better results. Avoid jumping to conclusions or forcing situations. Take time to think before you act, and trust the process. Your deep intuition will help you see things clearly if you allow space for reflection. Relationships may need gentle care, so show understanding. With patience, your efforts will turn into success and peace. Remember, good things come to those who wait wisely. Lucky Tip for Tomorrow: Be patient; success will follow soon. Sagittarius (Nov 23-Dec 21) Tomorrow is a day for healing and renewal. You will feel a strong urge to let go of old worries and start fresh. Spend time with loved ones or in nature to refresh your spirit. Your energy will be gentle yet powerful, helping you forgive and move on. It is a good day to focus on self-care and balance. Trust that this healing will open new doors for happiness. Embrace the calm and allow your heart to find peace and strength. Lucky Tip for Tomorrow: Heal gently; new beginnings await you. Capricorn (Dec 22-Jan 21) Clarity will come when you quiet your mind tomorrow. You may feel overwhelmed with many thoughts, but a little stillness will bring clear answers. Avoid rushing decisions and take moments to breathe deeply. Meditation or a quiet walk can help you find peace. Your practical nature will guide you to solutions once you focus calmly. Trust your inner wisdom and do not let stress cloud your judgement. The clearer your mind, the easier it will be to plan your next steps. Lucky Tip for Tomorrow: Quiet your mind; clarity will shine. Aquarius (Jan 22-Feb 19) A meaningful connection could blossom unexpectedly for you tomorrow. Be open to meeting new people or deepening current relationships. Your friendly nature will attract positive energy, and honest conversations will bring warmth. This connection may inspire you or help you see things differently. Trust your instincts when meeting others and express your true self freely. This day encourages you to embrace social moments with joy and curiosity. A surprise friendship or opportunity is near, so stay ready. Lucky Tip for Tomorrow: Welcome new bonds with open heart. Pisces (Feb 20-Mar 20) You may feel pushed out of your comfort zone, but this will help you discover new strengths. Stay flexible and open-minded as situations shift around you. Your natural creativity will help you find solutions where others see problems. Trust that each change brings lessons and growth. Let go of fear and welcome fresh beginnings with hope. This attitude will lead to personal progress and deeper happiness in your life. Lucky Tip for Tomorrow: Change brings growth; stay positive always. Discover everything about astrology at the Times of India , including daily horoscopes for Aries , Taurus , Gemini , Cancer , Leo , Virgo , Libra , Scorpio , Sagittarius , Capricorn , Aquarius , and Pisces .

Enhanced security to control crowd during Suna Besha in Puri
Enhanced security to control crowd during Suna Besha in Puri

Time of India

time2 hours ago

  • Time of India

Enhanced security to control crowd during Suna Besha in Puri

1 2 Bhubaneswar: The state govt has put in place extensive arrangements to ensure the smooth conduct of "Suna Besha" (golden appearance) ceremony on Sunday. During this significant Rath Yatra festival, the divine siblings — gods Jagannath, Balabhadra, and goddess Subhadra — will be adorned in gold ornaments while seated on their chariots before the Jagannath Temple. Given the expected massive weekend turnout, police authorities have enhanced security, crowd management and traffic control measures. Police face a crucial challenge following the tragic deaths of three devotees in a stampede near the Gundicha Temple last Sunday (June 29), the third day of Rath Yatra. The security deployment includes a staggering 205 police platoons to maintain order, with five platoons specifically assigned to safeguard the deities' gold ornaments on the chariots. DGP Y B Khurania stated, "We request devotees to follow our advisories and maintain discipline and order during the darshan period. Like Rath Yatra and Bahuda, we will use drones and AI-powered cameras to control crowds and regulate traffic. Adequate parking lots have been created in and around Puri." While the precise weight of gold adorning the deities remains unverified by temple authorities, sources indicate about 40 to 50 kg of gold ornaments are traditionally used annually for the Suna Besha ceremony. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Global Indices Are on the Move — Time to Trade! IC Markets Learn More Undo According to a 1978 inventory, the Jagannath temple's Ratna Bhandar (treasury) contains 128 kg gold and 221 kg silver. Besides, about 30 kg gold donated by devotees have been deposited in banks, sources in the temple stated. The Suna Besha tradition linked to the Jagannath Temple is believed to have commenced during King Kapilendra Deb's reign in 1460. Following his victory over another ruler, he transported substantial gold to Puri on 16 elephants, offering it to the Jagannath Temple. This annual celebration continues on Asadha Sukla Ekadasi Tithi. "The deities will wear gold crowns and ornaments on their hands and feet. Lord Jagannath holds a golden chakra in his right hand and silver conch in his left. Lord Balabhadra carries a golden plough in his left hand and gold mace in his right. Devi Subhadra wears different ornaments," a temple official said. Various servitor groups, including Palia Puspalak, Bhitarchha Mohapatra, Taluchha Mohapatra, Daitapatis, Khuntia and Mekap Sevaks, are responsible for adorning the deities on the chariots.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store