Thane court convicts three in 2017 theft case, acquits them of MCOCA charges
Thane, Jul 22 (PTI) A special court in Thane district convicted three persons in a 2017 theft case while acquitting them of charges under the stringent Maharashtra Control of Organised Crime Act (MCOCA).
Special Judge (MCOCA) V. G. Mohite sentenced Rahul Machhindra Shinde (44) and Datta Umrao Shinde (35) to five years of rigorous imprisonment after finding them guilty of charges under section 380 (theft in a dwelling house) of the Indian Penal Code (IPC).
The other accused, Amit alias Pravin Premchand Bagrecha (44), was convicted under section 411 (dishonestly receiving stolen property) of the IPC, and sentenced to 25 days of rigorous imprisonment.
A copy of the order dated July 18 was made available on Tuesday.
The court acquitted the three accused of charges under the MCOCA. Rahul and Datta Shinde were also acquitted of charges under Sections 395 (dacoity) and 397 (dacoity with attempt to cause death or grievous hurt) of the IPC.
Judge Mohite observed that the prosecution failed to prove the mandatory requirement of 'use of violence or threat of violence or intimidation or coercion" essential for an offence to qualify as 'organised crime" under Section 2(1)(e) of the MCOCA.
According to the prosecution, on March 3, 2017, a police team were on night patrolling duty when they received a call about thieves in the Chandresh Park area in Dombivli town. Police chased five men, apprehending Datta Shinde, who was found with a stolen TV and a weapon. The remaining four managed to escape.
The police later apprehended the other two accused and recovered the stolen golden ornaments.
While the accused were initially charged with dacoity and dacoity with attempt to cause grievous hurt, the court found that the ingredients for these offences were not met.
The judge observed, 'None of the accused voluntarily caused or attempted to cause hurt or wrongful restraint or fear of instant death or instant hurt to anybody while committing said theft in the house." PTI COR ARU
view comments
First Published:
July 22, 2025, 12:30 IST
Disclaimer: Comments reflect users' views, not News18's. Please keep discussions respectful and constructive. Abusive, defamatory, or illegal comments will be removed. News18 may disable any comment at its discretion. By posting, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
26 minutes ago
- Time of India
12 trapped in Dhanbad mine after cave-in, say locals, MP
Incident site in Dhanbad DHANBAD/RANCHI: At least 12 miners are feared trapped in a caved-in illegal coal mine in Jamunia, around 40 km from Dhanbad district headquarters, with some feared dead, villagers and politicians said Wednesday. Police, administration and Bharat Coking Coal Ltd, however, said that so far they had not found any sign of mine collapse. The alleged incident snowballed into political brick-batting as both the governing and opposition parties attacked each other over the illegal mining menace in the coal belt, and in the state at large. "Twelve labourers are trapped while some others who managed to escape are undergoing treatment in private hospitals. Families of the trapped workers are being offered Rs 10 lakh as compensation. This is a racket where labourers are brought from other districts and used for illegal mining. After the mishap, the entry point was filled with mud to conceal the incident," Giridih MP Chandra Prakash Chaudhary claimed. On the other hand, Jamshedpur West MLA Saryu Roy on Tuesday wrote on X, "At a place called Jamunia in Baghmara, Dhanbad, a tunnel used for illegal mining collapsed, resulting in the death of nine workers. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Cat Keeps Hugging Friend Before Going To The Vet – The Vet Paled When He Saw Them Tips and Tricks Undo The illegal mining mafia is engaged in disposing of the bodies of the deceased. I have informed #SSP#Dhanbad about this." Talking to media, he held the local administration accountable. Dhanbad deputy commissioner Aditya Ranjan told PTI, "We have rushed an NDRF team to the spot suggested but so far no sign of any such incident has been found." Dhanbad SSP Prabhat Kumar said that he had directed SDPO Baghmara to conduct a probe. Kumar, too, told PTI that "no trace of any such incident was found". He added: "Additionally, no one from any side, including family members, turned up. So far, no formal complaint has been lodged from any side." Regional nodal security officer of Bharat Coking's block-2 project, Rajiv Ranjan, also said there was no information of any such incident in the block-2 project's closed underground mine. Health, food & civil supplies and disaster management minister and Congress MLA Irfan Ansari, meanwhile, accused Bharat Coking of patronising illegal mining and demanded appropriate compensation. The state Congress attacked the Centre. "Security of mines is entirely managed by institutions like CCL and BCCL through CISF, which is directly under the Centre," said spokesperson Sonal Shanti. BJP hit back demanding a CBI probe. "It's state-sponsored deaths. The state govt and local administration are aware of illegal mining but choose to remain mum," said spokesperson Pratul Shahdeo.
NDTV
27 minutes ago
- NDTV
Kidneys Removed During Uterus Surgery; Probe Agency ED Case Against Fake Doctor
New Delhi: The Enforcement Directorate (ED) has filed a prosecution complaint under the provisions of the Prevention of Money Laundering Act (PMLA) before a special court in Patna against a quack and his assistant in a case of alleged "organ removal and financial fraud". The economic intelligence agency initiated the investigation based on an FIR registered by a police station in Bihar's Muzaffarpur for offences under various sections of IPC, 1860 and the Transplantation of Human Organs Act, 1994, an ED statement said. The ED Patna zonal office filed a prosecution complaint on June 17 under the provisions of the PMLA before the special court (PMLA) at Patna against Pawan Kumar and Ravindra Kumar alias R K Singh in the case of alleged illegal organ removal and financial fraud, the agency said. The special court took cognisance of the prosecution's complaint on July 17. The ED investigation revealed that one Sunita Devi, accompanied by her mother Tetari Devi, visited Shubhkant Clinic in Muzaffarpur for the treatment of her uterus. Pawan Kumar, the operator of Shubhkant Clinic, allegedly in connivance with Ravindra Kumar alias R K Singh, a quack, advised surgery for her supposedly damaged uterus and "demanded Rs 20,000", the statement said. During the operation, both of Sunita Devi's kidneys were allegedly removed along with her uterus, contrary to the claim that only the uterus and tumours were removed. Post-surgery, Sunita Devi's health deteriorated, and she stopped urinating. Subsequent medical examinations confirmed the removal of both kidneys, leading to her death. Additionally, an extorted amount of Rs 40,000 was allegedly taken from Sunita Devi's family members at another hospital, totalling Rs 60,000, which is considered Proceeds of Crime (POC), the ED said. The ED investigation further revealed that Pawan Kumar and Ravindra Kumar allegedly conspired to commit the crime, generating POC amounting to Rs 60,000, which was utilised for their personal benefits, the statement said. In the police case, Pawan Kumar has been convicted by a special court (SC/ST Act), Patna, while Ravindra Kumar is currently facing trial, it said.
The Hindu
an hour ago
- The Hindu
Bittersweet homecoming for Jalgaon man acquitted in 2006 Mumbai train blasts case
Asif Khan, one of the 12 accused acquitted by the Bombay High Court in the 2006 Mumbai train blasts case on July 21, walked out of Pune's Yerwada jail the next day around 10.30 p.m. after spending 19 long years behind bars. The reunion at his home in Maharashtra's Jalgaon on Wednesday morning was an emotional one, marked by tears, hugs, and a sense of disbelief. His mother, Husna Bano Bashir Khan, 70, couldn't contain her emotions as she spoke about her son's ordeal. 'Asif was always innocent; he lost 19 years of his life. This delayed justice can never compensate for that,' she said. On July 11, 2006, a series of seven bomb blasts occurred in the first-class compartments of seven suburban local trains in Mumbai between 6:23 p.m. and 6:29 p.m., resulting in the tragic loss of 187 lives and leaving 824 people injured. Mr. Asif was 33 years old when he was arrested in connection with the blasts, leaving behind his wife, Nishat, and three children, who were aged six, four, and two at the time. Then he was working in a construction company as a civil engineer in Mumbai's Kandivali area. 'After securing a diploma in civil engineering, he was working in Jalgaon for a year with a small company. In 2000, he got the job in Mumbai. Three years into the job, he found a rented home in Mira Road and moved there with his wife and children for a better life,' recalled his mother. The investigation into the blasts led to the registration of seven separate FIRs across different police stations in Mumbai, which were later consolidated and handed over to the Anti-Terrorism Squad (ATS) for investigation. The ATS identified 13 people as the accused and they were tried alongside 15 absconding accused. Two of the accused died during the trial. A chargesheet was filed and the matter proceeded as a special case before the Special Court in Mumbai designated under the Maharashtra Control of Organised Crime Act, 1999, and the National Investigation Agency Act, 2008. Ms. Husna said her husband, a tractor mechanic, passed away 15 years ago due to prostate cancer, with the grief of his son's imprisonment weighing heavily on him. As Mr. Asif was the only earning member when he was arrested and his younger brother was still in college, the family had to borrow money from relatives to survive. Ms. Nishat stitched clothes to earn a living, the mother said. 'In denial and disbelief' Recalling the day her son was arrested and the struggles the family faced, she said, 'I am still in denial and disbelief to see him in front of my eyes. I am not able to process this happiness; what if it goes away? I am seeing my son after almost two decades. Nineteen years is a long time; our lives have changed, the atmosphere of the village has changed, people passed away in the family, including his walid (father). He hoped he would see Asif before dying,' she said. His mother added, 'I have not cooked anything special for him yet; I am in the process of allowing myself to believe my son is with us. We don't want to be too happy at the same time as we are too scared to lose anyone... It feels like a dream to see my son walk around the house again.' Just two days before the judgment acquitting Mr. Asif, his family had welcomed a newborn: a girl, who was born to his elder son. They considered the child a symbol of good luck, Ms. Husna said, but the infant passed away due to jaundice on Wednesday evening, bringing a wave of fresh sorrow to the family. Mr. Asif and his childhood friend, Parvej Khan, 50, who was working in an advertising company in Mumbai's Mumbra region, were named in a case for being alleged members of the Students' Islamic Movement of India (SIMI). Mr. Asif was also named in the September 2006 Malegaon blasts case. He was later acquitted of all charges. On July 13, 2020, Mr. Parvej and Mr. Asif were acquitted in the SIMI case by the Aurangabad Bench of the Bombay High Court, but Mr. Asif remained in prison in the train blasts case, Mr. Parvej said. For Mr. Parvej, life still feels like a start from scratch as he struggles to find work. 'I am working as a commission agent for properties now but this is also very challenging as people do not want to interact with me much. I have lost all my friends who studied with me in a convent school in Jalgaon. Only two to three friends called me, but that too for the sake of courtesy; everybody maintains a distance from me and my family,' he said.
