West Bengal Assembly passes Bill on ‘transparency' in medical costs in private facilities
Also Read | Experts call for regulation and standardisation of private healthcare in India
The West Bengal Clinical Establishments (Registration, Regulation, and Transparency) (Amendment) Bill, 2025 was tabled on Monday by the Minister of State for Health and Family Welfare Chandrima Bhattacharya.
The Bill amends the West Bengal Clinical Establishments Act, 2017 with the objective to regulate the licensing process of clinical establishments, increase transparency in their functioning, ensure strict adherence to fixed rates and package rates, and mandate electronic medical record-keeping.
No hidden charges
The Bill states that 'every clinical establishment must strictly follow fixed rates and charges including the package rates for investigation, bed charges, operation theatre procedures'.
Under the amended Bill, privately owned medical facilities will also have to provide proper estimates for treatments not covered under fixed or package rates to the patient and their kin during initiation and through the course of treatment. Hospitals have also been mandated to communicate updated charges and the amount due to the patient and their kin every 24 hours. The amended Bill also prohibits final hospital bills from exceeding the estimates by a percentage specified by the State Health Department.
Increased surveillance
Additionally, the Bill mandates detailed medical record-keeping of patients in the hospital's electronic software via e-prescriptions, and detailed discharge summaries.
'Clinical establishments will maintain such records and other data in the software as may be notified by the State government from time to time and all such records shall be furnished to the State Government electronically and physically, on demand by the Government,' the Bill states.
The Opposition raised concerns over women's safety, and confidentiality.
During the debate, the Leader of the Opposition (LoP) in the State Assembly Suvendu Adhikari questioned the lack of specific steps or guidelines in the Bill to improve safety for women doctors, nurses, patients, and guards.
'If e-prescription is introduced, will the confidentiality of the patient's personal information be protected?' Mr. Adhikari said.
The Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) legislator also raised questions over the 'practicality' of the new charges being communicated to the patient within 24 hours. 'Sometimes it takes more than 24 hours for a patient's health test report to come. So, this specific time frame is not realistic,' Mr. Adhikari said.
Minister Chandrima Bhattacharya responded to the LoP's allegations, saying that, going forward, private hospitals would be obliged to inform patients about the cost of treatment in a timely manner, and that the Bill had been introduced to regulate the private healthcare sector.
Notably, the West Bengal Clinical Establishment Regulatory Commission, conceptualised and announced by Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee in 2017, also oversees treatment infrastructure in private clinical establishments across the State.
The President of the Association of Hospitals of Eastern India, Rupak Baruah, said that the Bill was a good initiative to bridge misunderstandings between common people and hospitals, but added that 'medical treatment is a dynamic process that does not always adhere to a fixed system'.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hans India
2 hours ago
- Hans India
CM opens AP's 1st Digital Nerve Centre
Kuppam (Chittoor dist): Andhra Pradesh on Thursday took a significant leap in healthcare innovation with Chief Minister N Chandrababu Naidu inaugurating the state's first Digital Nerve Centre (DiNC) at the Kuppam Area Hospital. This initiative, a collaborative effort with Tata Trusts and the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation, aims at integrating all health services under a single digital platform, beginning in Kuppam and slated for statewide expansion. The DiNC is designed to seamlessly connect hospitals, primary health centres (PHCs), and village clinics, ensuring that a patient's complete medical history is accessible digitally from anywhere, at any time. This integration is expected to facilitate quicker diagnoses, enhance coordination among medical professionals, and streamline follow-up care. From lab results to prescriptions, all vital health information will be digitized, empowering doctors to make more informed and efficient decisions. "This is not just a model for Andhra Pradesh, but for the world," stated the Chief Minister after the inauguration. He emphasised that the project transcends mere digitalisation, focusing instead on leveraging technology to profoundly improve people's lives. Highlighting the state's annual healthcare expenditure of approximately Rs 19,000 crore, the CM underscored the potential of artificial intelligence and advanced data systems to reduce costs while simultaneously delivering superior healthcare services. Currently, the newly launched centre links 13 PHCs and 92 village health centres within the Kuppam region. This connectivity enables real-time health tracking and ensures rapid response during medical emergencies. During the launch, Chief Minister Naidu and Health Minister Satya Kumar Yadav also engaged with local health workers to assess the system's practical implementation and effectiveness on the ground. Looking ahead, the government plans to roll out the DiNC system across the remaining part of the Chittoor district in its next phase, followed by a full-scale implementation throughout Andhra Pradesh. The strategy also includes deploying mobile medical units for regular blood tests and more rigorous monitoring of maternal health, with a strong emphasis on preventive care. A significant strength of the DiNC system lies in its inclusivity, bringing frontline healthcare workers, including Auxiliary Nurse Midwives (ANMs) and Anganwadi staff, into the digital loop. This ensures that even remote and rural communities benefit from enhanced health services. Special Chief Secretary MT Krishna Babu, Commissioner of Health and Family Welfare Veerapandian, Collector Sumit Kumar, DM&HO Dr DT Sudha Rani, and other senior officials also attended the programme.
Time of India
5 hours ago
- Time of India
Govt starts biweekly checks to streamline surrogacy and ART centres
New Delhi: Amid rising concerns over illegal and commercial surrogacy, the health department has launched bi-weekly inspections of assisted reproductive technology (ART) and surrogacy clinics. These inspections mark the first implementation of oversight measures following the enforcement of Surrogacy (Regulation) Act 2021 and Assisted Reproductive Technology (Regulation) Act 2021 in 2022. Health officials report that unlawful and commercial surrogacy complaints typically accompany in vitro fertilisation (IVF) complaints regarding gamete mixing. The surge in international surrogacy seekers prompted the 2021 ban on commercial surrogacy. Yet, issues like the exploitation of vulnerable women, child trafficking and abandonment through surrogacy persist. Surrogacy clinics are medical establishments offering surrogacy-related services, where a woman gestates a baby for prospective parents. These establishments provide multiple services, including IVF for embryo creation, genetic consultation and continuous assistance for surrogates and intended parents. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like One of the Most Successful Investors of All Time, Warren Buffett, Recommends: 5 Books for Turning... Blinkist: Warren Buffett's Reading List Click Here Undo You Can Also Check: Delhi AQI | Weather in Delhi | Bank Holidays in Delhi | Public Holidays in Delhi Since 2022, Delhi registered 50 surrogacy clinics and issued 160 essentiality certificates to couples seeking surrogacy procedures. Neighbouring regions report lower figures, with Haryana having 18 registered surrogacy clinics and Uttar Pradesh reporting no registered facility according to the national ART and surrogacy registry portal. Currently, Delhi houses 113 registered ART clinics. The national portal shows Haryana with 62 registered establishments while Uttar Pradesh has no registered clinic. The portal data indicates 25 registered ART banks in Delhi and 15 in Haryana. Uttar Pradesh again doesn't have any such bank to date. ART clinics provide treatments and procedures while ART banks gather, evaluate and preserve gametes (sperm and eggs) and embryos. The clinics concentrate on medical ART applications while banks supply the necessary biological materials for these procedures. The state programme officer of the ART and surrogacy division, Dr Satyajit Kumar, said an inspection plan was prepared and two teams with five members each were authorised for inspection, starting July. Action will be taken if anybody is found violating the laws. Officials indicated that consistent and thorough inspections were vital for sustaining ethical, legal and transparent operations at these centres. These assessments serve several essential functions, primarily verifying compliance and ensuring centres operate according to the 2021 Acts. This includes checking registration standards, records, staff qualifications and patient rights protection. Unexpected inspections encourage facilities to maintain high standards continuously, rather than solely during planned evaluations, said officials. "These inspections deter unlawful activities, including unregistered ART procedures, unethical surrogacy arrangements, sex selection and commercial surrogacy. Prompt detection prevents such violations from escalating," said Dr Kumar. "The inspection process protects all stakeholders' interests, including intended parents, donors, surrogates and children born through these procedures, by ensuring centres adhere to established medical, ethical and legal protocols," he pointed out. Transparent inspection and reporting systems also strengthen public confidence in ART and surrogacy services, reinforcing institutional credibility and upholding the healthcare system's integrity, he added.
Time of India
3 days ago
- Time of India
UDF sets up commission to study issues in Kerala's health sector
Thiruvananthapuram: Opposition Congress-led UDF on Monday set up a five-member commission to study the issues being faced by the state health sector, two days after a senior doctor made shocking revelations about the shortcomings at the Government Medical College here. The Commission, led by Congress leader and public health expert Dr S S Lal, would study the "complex and serious problems" that have arisen in the state's health sector and suggest solutions with a long-term perspective, Opposition Leader V D Satheesan said in a statement here. He alleged that the "administrative failure" under consecutive governments led by Chief Minister Pinarayi Vijayan was the reason for the issues in the state health sector. Lal, the chairman of the proposed panel, is a global health expert who has led public health programmes in several countries across five continents, the statement said. "The first report will be submitted within three months and the complete report within six months," the LoP said. The report will be prepared by collecting detailed evidence from the general public, government hospital employees, experts from public health and other related institutions, he said. The commission report would be a precursor to the alternative health policy that the UDF plans to propose in the coming days, Satheesan further said. The report would be used to lay the foundation stone for the Kerala Health Vision 2050 that the UDF is planning to formulate in the health sector, that LoP added. The UDF announced the formation of the Health Commission in the wake of open criticism by Dr Haris Chirakkal, Head of the Urology Department, about a shortage of surgical equipment and delays in procedures at the state-run Thiruvananthapuram Medical College Hospital . The controversy erupted on Saturday after Dr Chirakkal posted on Facebook, saying the greatest helplessness of a department head in a government hospital was the lack of essential medical equipment. He revealed that many scheduled surgeries had been postponed due to the shortage, and that repeated assurances from authorities had failed to resolve the issue. While patients suffering from severe pain waited for timely treatment, officials showed little interest in addressing the situation, he alleged. He also said he had been under immense mental stress, unable to fulfil his responsibilities to patients who depend on government hospitals. Following his comments, Director of Medical Education Dr Vishwanathan K told the media that Dr Chirakkal's statements were "misleading and an emotional outburst".
