Deep in the 185-page Lattouf judgment is a forensic critique of the ABC's top brass
Four of the key figures in Lattouf's removal– Buttrose, the then managing director David Anderson, former content chief Chris Oliver-Taylor and Sydney radio manager Steve Ahern – have since departed the ABC.
But 18 months ago, they were among senior managers in a 'a state of panic' after an 'orchestrated campaign by pro-Israel lobbyists to have Ms Lattouf taken off air', the federal court judge said.
Rangiah traced every text, email and internal discussion between multiple layers of ABC management in December 2023 and compared them with the evidence they gave in the seven-day trial, lifting the veil on decision-making at the public broadcaster. Some individuals came out better than others.
Buttrose, Rangiah said, 'made clear her displeasure' at Lattouf's appointment at the outset, forwarding email complaints from pro-Israel lobbyists to Oliver-Taylor. She demanded to know why an 'activist' had been engaged in the first place, putting pressure on Oliver-Taylor to act, Rangiah found.
He said when Buttrose asked David Anderson: 'Why can't she come down with flu or Covid or a stomach upset?' the chair was expressing her 'desire for Ms Lattouf to be taken off air immediately under the pretence of illness'. In the witness box, Buttrose claimed the expression was 'just a face-saving idea'. When it came to her performance under cross-examination, Rangiah was not impressed.
Sign up for Guardian Australia's breaking news email
'Ms Buttrose's evidence under cross-examination was somewhat theatrical and difficult to follow at times,' he said. 'She had a strong belief that Ms Lattouf was an activist who should have never been engaged by the ABC and she wanted Ms Lattouf gone as soon as possible.'
But while Buttrose's forwarding of complaints about Lattouf placed pressure on Oliver-Taylor, Rangiah said that the chair did 'not materially contribute' to the decision to take the journalist off air, finding that this was Oliver-Taylor's decision alone.
In his assessment of Oliver-Taylor, Rangiah found some of his evidence about whether Lattouf was given a direction not to post about Gaza was 'quite implausible', ultimately finding that he does 'not accept' this evidence and Lattouf was not given a direction.
At issue was whether Lattouf had been given a direction by her manager, Elizabeth Green, not to post on social media or just a suggestion to keep a low profile. Oliver-Taylor claimed in court that there was no difference between asking someone to do something and 'directing' them.
When it came to the former managing director, Rangiah found Anderson 'materially contributed' to Oliver-Taylor's decision to remove Lattouf by 'expressing his opinion that Ms Lattouf had anti-Semitic views' after inspecting her social media accounts.
Lower down the chain, Rangiah was critical of evidence given by Ahern, as well as radio chief Ben Latimer and editorial adviser Simon Melkman – the latter two for 'their lack of recollection' about what was said at a Teams meeting before Lattouf was taken off air.
'The evidence of Mr Latimer, Mr Ahern and Mr Melkman under cross-examination left me with substantial doubts as to the reliability and credibility of their evidence on controversial matters,' Rangiah said.
Sign up to Breaking News Australia
Get the most important news as it breaks
after newsletter promotion
'I reject their evidence asserting that Mr Oliver-Taylor was not informed in the Teams Meeting that Ms Green had not given Ms Lattouf a direction and had only given her advice.'
The judge was definitive in his assessment of what caused the 'panic' on the executive floor and why emails were flying between them.
'Ms Buttrose and Mr Anderson received multiple letters and emails complaining about Ms Lattouf, which sought to pressure the ABC to not employ her and/or terminate her employment for reasons including her political opinion and/or race and/or national extraction,' he found.
'He [Anderson] considered that it was of critical importance for the ABC to have a high degree of actual and perceived impartiality in relation to the Israel/Gaza war.
'The complaints, as they developed over the ensuing days, were evidently a coordinated campaign to pressure the ABC into taking Ms Lattouf off air or ceasing to employ her.'
Of Lattouf's direct manager, Green, Rangiah was highly complimentary, finding 'no doubt about the reliability and accuracy' of her evidence.
'I accept Ms Green to be a reliable witness and accept her account of all her discussions with Mr Ahern,' he said.
'In summary, Ms Green made it explicitly clear she had not given any direction to Ms Lattouf and had merely provided advice.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Guardian
an hour ago
- The Guardian
Creative Australia apologises to Khaled Sabsabi for ‘hurt and pain' after Venice Biennale reinstatement
The acting chair of Creative Australia has apologised to Khaled Sabsabi and his curator Michael Dagostino for the 'hurt and pain' caused by the decision to rescind their Venice Biennale commission, and said their artworks had been 'mischaracterised'. Wesley Enoch, who took over from a retiring Robert Morgan three months after the then chair told a Senate estimates hearing he would not be resigning over the controversy, apologised to Sabsabi and Dagostino live on air on Thursday, telling ABC RN the artist's work was not about the glorification of terrorism, as suggested in parliament in February. 'Those who mischaracterise the work aren't being honest to the intention of the work or the practice that this artist has, who is an incredibly peace-loving artist in the way that they construct their images,' he said. 'To Khaled and Michael – I've done it in person, but to say it here very publicly, I want to apologise to them for the hurt and pain they've gone through in this process.' An independent external review by Blackhall & Pearl into Creative Australia's actions in cancelling Sabsabi's commission found there was no single or predominant failure of process, governance or decision that had occurred, but there were 'a series of missteps, assumptions and missed opportunities that meant neither the leadership of Creative Australia, nor the board, were well placed to respond to, and manage in a considered way, any criticism or controversy that might emerge in relation to the selection decision'. The report did not go as far as to list among its nine recommendations the reinstatement of Sabsabi and Dagostino. The arts minister, Tony Burke, said on Wednesday he had told Creative Australia's chief executive Adrian Collette last week that he would support whatever decision the organisation made in the wake of the report's release. But the Greens senator Sarah Hanson-Young said although the decision to reinstate Sabsabi and Dagostino was the right one, it was 'a terrible day for the board and CEO of Creative Australia who have disgraced themselves throughout this ordeal'. 'It is clear that the leadership of Creative Australia needs a clean out in order to rebuild trust within the artistic community and the Australian public,' she said in a statement. Sign up for Guardian Australia's breaking news email Also calling for Creative Australia and Burke to 'explain themselves' over the backflip was the Liberal MP and shadow minister for the arts, Julian Leeser, who told ABC RN on Thursday that there was 'nothing in the report [that] suggested that they needed to remake that decision'. 'One of the reasons that [Creative Australia] made their decision back in February to withdraw this is because they were concerned about issues in relation to the broader Australian community,' he said. 'I believe those issues continue to remain, and I believe that Creative Australia should not have unmade their decision that they previously made back in February to withdraw Mr Sabsabi from this exhibition,' he said, adding that Burke needed to explain 'how at this time, with this antisemitism crisis that Australia has faced, where we're a multicultural country, why this particular artist who has this particular history is being chosen to represent our country at this time and receive taxpayer funding to do so'. Sign up to Breaking News Australia Get the most important news as it breaks after newsletter promotion Sabsabi and Dagostino welcomed the reversal of the decision on Wednesday, saying 'it offers a sense of resolution and allows us to move forward with optimism and hope after a period of significant personal and collective hardship'. Philanthropist and prominent arts advocate Simon Mordant resigned as Australia's International Ambassador for the 2026 Venice Biennale after the announcement of Sabsabi and Dagostino's removal. The resignation ended 30 years of active involvement in the Biennale, including two previous terms as commissioner and leader of the fundraising drive for the new Australian Pavilion in Venice. On Wednesday Mordant confirmed that the pair's reinstatement had led to his re-acceptance of the role, and described Creative Australia's decision as 'a watershed moment for the Australian arts community, whereby we can work towards eliminating any form of racism including antisemitism across the arts industries'. 'I am confident that the work presented will reflect the highest artistic standards and align with the values I have always upheld – integrity, inclusion, and respect,' he said, going on to reaffirm his position on upholding ethical boundaries in artistic representation. 'I would never knowingly support an artist or art that glorifies terrorism, racism or antisemitism or went against my values,' he said. The chief executive of the National Association for the Visual Arts (NAVA) Penelope Benton, who was highly critical of Creative Australia's initial decision to cancel the commission, said despite the 'messy turn of events', Creative Australia's willingness to admit it had got it wrong would go a long way to renewing trust in the transparency and integrity of Australia's principal arts funding body. 'Artistic freedom and independent decision-making are fundamental to the role of a national arts body,' she said.
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
The Project's Georgie Tunny announces surprising new TV gig after show's axing
The Project's Georgie Tunny has announced her new gig following Channel Ten 's shock decision to axe the long-running news program. The 34-year-old revealed on Thursday she will be joining Ten's new current affairs program 10 News+. 'I've always been a fan of news delivered differently and am excited to be staying with the 10 family,' she told 'Can't wait to see where this new chapter leads!' 10 News+, hosted by recently poached Seven journalists Denham Hitchcock and Amelia Brace, made its debut on Monday night. It has received mixed reviews from viewers, with many sharing their thoughts on X. Several compared 10 News+ to A Current Affair with one posting: 'This is like ACA. Going to people's houses to talk and them avoiding the cameras.' 'You replaced The Project with a Temu ACA not seeing @theprojecttv is incredibly depressing. 10news+ sucks!' complained another viewer. Someone else said: 'This is proper @Channel7 style commercial JUNK. It's like watching a cross between Fox News and Anchorman. Why the silly 'news' voices!?' One more person tuning in at home asked: 'Anyone else bored so far?' while someone else said, 'please no more long investigation reports it's 6pm'. 'Oh dear. I thought I would give 10 News Plus a go.I feel like we have regressed 20 years! An inauthentic painfully choreographed attempt at current affairs!' one said. 'Dribble. Won't last the year' a viewer said with another adding, 'Felt like it was a Comedy Company parody from the 80s. The fist pump at the end? Yikes.' Not everyone was so negative with one fan writing: 'Loving @10NewsPlus - strong launch story. Is this the new Schapelle Corby story we all need to know about. 10 news should be very proud.' The first episode included an investigation on drug-smuggling Melbourne mum Debbie Voulgaris and a sit-down chat with Prime Minister Anthony Albanese. The Project aired its final episode last Friday night. It was announced last month that it would be pulled from the schedule after 16 years and more than 4,500 episodes. The Project hosts Waleed Aly, Sarah Harris and Hamish Macdonald are set to exit the network, while comedian Taunton will continue his guest appearances on other Ten shows.
Daily Mail
2 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Victoria's government not ruling out compensation to Indigenous Australians for 'genocide'
A landmark truth-telling inquiry's push to compensate Indigenous Victorians for historical injustices has not been ruled out by the Victorian premier. After a four-year truth-telling inquiry, The Yoorrook Justice Commission, delivered its final report to the Victoria state parliament on Tuesday. The Australian-first Indigenous truth-telling body calls on the Victorian government to provide redress for injustices. Among the proposals is a statewide redress scheme, including financial compensation for Indigenous Victorians. The report also suggests recognising Indigenous groups as sovereign nations, exempting them from taxes and rates, and granting them access to revenue from natural resources and Crown land. The report also called for the state government to offer a formal apology and to acknowledge its responsibility for the wrongs of its predecessors. The apology would also see the state acknowledge that Aboriginal soldiers who served during the world wars were excluded from a scheme which gave veterans land when they returned home. Some controversial recommendations included a significant overhaul of the education system, which would exclude Indigenous children from attendance requirements, suspension and expulsion, as well as avenues for more appropriate cultural training. The Yoorrook Justice Commission submitted its final report to parliament, which included 100 recommendations aimed at making amends for the injustice that 'occurred during and as a result of the colonial invasion' The report also pushed for the Treaty to be pursued and permanent funding streams to be instituted to help future generations of Indigenous people. It also called for a permanent First Peoples' Assembly - a move which would create a Victorian version of the Voice. During a press conference on Wednesday, Premier Jacinta Allan refused to rule out any of the recommendations. 'I'm just not going to rule things in or out through a press conference,' Allan said. 'I think we can understand the need... for government to take time to consider the recommendations.' The report has given the Victorian government a two-year window to respond to its findings. Yoorrook held 67 days of public hearings, gathering the testimony of Stolen Generations survivors, elders, historians, experts and non-Indigenous advocates. It found there were at least 50 massacres across Victoria by the end of the 1860s, with eight colonists killed compared to 978 First Nations people. The mass killings combined with disease, sexual violence, exclusion, eradication of language, cultural erasure, environmental degradation, child removal, absorption and assimilation brought about the 'near-complete physical destruction' of Aboriginal people in Victoria. The 'decimation' of the population by 1901 was the result of 'a coordinated plan of different actions aimed at the destruction of the essential foundations of the life of national groups'. 'This was genocide,' one of the documents read. Ms Allan said the findings made for 'tough reading' because they 'tell the truth' about how the state was colonised. The recommendations will inform treaty talks between the state government and the First Peoples' Assembly of Victoria, with enabling legislation expected to be introduced later in 2025. The report received a mixed response, with some critics labelling the extensive list of recommendations as a 'disaster'. '[The list] read like demands that would send the state broke if they agreed to all of them,' one Indigenous critic told the Herald Sun. 'At a time when we are negotiating treaty and getting the Victorian people on board it's just a disaster.' Others supported the report claiming it was time for the state to start 'making things right'. Ms Allan encouraged Victorians to look at the report. 'I'm focused on getting better outcomes, because when you improve outcomes for Indigenous kids in schools, Indigenous kids in family settings, Indigenous men and women getting access to the health care that they need, that's better for all of us.' First Peoples' Assembly member Nerita Waight warned Ms Allan not to let Yoorrook's work go ignored, as politicians have done with previous major Aboriginal-related inquiries. 'The truth has been told and now the government has an obligation to act,' the Victorian Aboriginal Legal Service chief executive said. Yoorrook Justice Commission chairperson Professor Eleanor Bourke said the final report outlined recommendations that would be advanced through a treaty process while others needed to 'begin now' with urgent action and 'reforms. 'These recommendations take the voices, lived experience and evidence of First Peoples into the places where decisions are made and where change must happen,' Ms Bourke said. 'To Premier Allan and the Victorian Government, I urge you all to implement the Yoorrook for Transformation recommendations with courage and commitment.' Independent Senator Lidia Thorpe called on the federal government to press on with national truth and treaty processes. 'Genocide has not just occurred in Victoria, but has been perpetrated against all First Peoples of this continent,' she said. Prime Minister Anthony Albanese promised to set up a 'Makarrata Commission to oversee a national process for treaty and truth-telling' in 2021.
