NHS keeps patients away because they are an inconvenience, new boss admits ahead of shake-up
Patients are an 'inconvenience' to the NHS, which has 'built mechanisms to keep them away', said the new boss of the health service.
Sir Jim Mackey, who was made chief executive of the NHS on 1 April, spoke of the 8am daily phone scramble for a GP appointment as one example of the difficulties patients face in seeking help.
'We've made it really hard, and we've probably all been on the end of it,' he told The Telegraph.
'You've got a relative in hospital, so you're ringing a number on a ward that no one ever answers. The ward clerk only works nine to five or they're busy doing other stuff; the GP practice scramble every morning.
'It feels like we've built mechanisms to keep the public away because it's an inconvenience,' he said.
And he warned that failing to listen to public frustrations could mean the end of a national health service.
Failings in maternity services, he said, were cultural and 'thinking we know best when mothers know best, listening to them and families and building the service around them'.
He said: 'The big worry is, if we don't grab that, and we don't deal with it with pace, we'll lose the population. If we lose the population, we've lost the NHS. For me, it's straightforward. The two things are completely dependent on each other.'
Sir Jim, who earlier this month said the NHS should 'tear up' the way it offers hospital outpatient appointments, said cutting back millions of routine follow-ups would be a priority, since the NHS spent more on hospital outpatients than on the whole of the GP system.
'Outpatients is glaringly obvious. Of 130 million outpatients a year, about 85 million or so are follow-ups,' he told the paper, adding that it felt wrong that the NHS diverted so many resources to follow-ups at the expense of patients waiting for diagnosis and treatment.
Moving care out of hospitals into local neighbourhood centres was crucial, to tackle waste and make care more convenient, Sir Jim said.
Shifting treatment from hospitals to the community will be a key aim of the government's major 10-year health plan, which health secretary Wes Streeting is set to unveil next week.
Mr Streeting has also pledged to 'end the postcode lottery' of care, focusing more on working-class communities.
Trials will be set up of 'patient power payments', under which hospitals receive the full payment for treatment only if the patient is satisfied, The Telegraph reports.
Sir Jim, who from 2003 to 2023 was chief executive of Northumbria Healthcare NHS foundation trust – the most highly rated trust in the health service, said that in that role he tried to read every email and spoke to every family that approached him.
He described the 8am race for a GP appointment as 'that heart-sink moment, someone's got to sit by the phone, they've got to ring forever, don't get through and then have to do it all again tomorrow'.
He said: 'It feels like we've built mechanisms to keep the public away because it's an inconvenience.
'We've got to somehow reorient it; think about how do we find people who need us, how do we stop thinking 'it's going to be a pain in the arse if you turn up because I'm quite busy' and instead think about how do we find out what you need and get it sorted.'
But he said the NHS performs best when money is tight. 'There's got to be some tension in it, otherwise we'll waste money.
'There is a strong argument that we have wasted a lot of money in the last few years, we haven't spent it as wisely as we could have done.'
The NHS needed to be 'de-layered' because it was expensive and slowed down decision-making, he insisted, warning that the NHS has too many 'fossilised' ways of working.
And he said: 'We've got too many people dying in hospital when they want to die at home.'
He told how the system 'failed' his elderly mother, with inconsistent care over seven days, a lack of weekend services and a 'disjoint' between services.
He praised the staff involved, but said 'a hell of a lot of learning' was needed.
'My dad died in a hospital where the local folklore was terrible about the hospital, but the hospital was deaf to it and didn't know what was actually being said,' he recalled.
'I wasn't long into the NHS, it was a long time ago now, and I felt really powerless.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Powys County Times
26 minutes ago
- Powys County Times
Government's new health strategy ‘no more than hiding the crisps', Tories say
The Government's 10-year health strategy to tackle demand on the NHS centres on 'hiding the crisps', a shadow minister has said. Under new proposals, retailers could be made to set targets to increase their sales of less fattening products. Shadow work and pensions secretary Helen Whately said setting mandatory targets for supermarkets was 'nanny state'. 'They had 14 years in opposition to think about what they wanted to do about the NHS, they've had a year in government, and the number one thing in it seems to be hide the crisps,' she told Sky News' Sunday Morning With Trevor Phillips. 'It's obviously the nanny state, but it's also not what people want for the NHS. 'People want to hear how they're going to get to see their GP. 'Telling people what to buy, I think, is not up to government. I believe in personal responsibility.' Health Secretary Wes Streeting told the same programme the Government will work with supermarkets to help 'nudge people in the right direction'. 'By taking the approach we're taking with supermarkets, they will decide through the combination of where they put their products, how they do price promotions, the reformulation, what products they choose to put on the shelves,' he said. 'They will work with us to make sure that we nudge people in the right direction without any of us even noticing, in the same way that we've nudged the country in the other direction since the 1990s.' Rejecting suggestions that the idea was too controlling, he said it was different to 'traditional nanny statism, where we regulate more heavily on price, on marketing, on what's sold'. Labour's 10-year health plan is set to be published next week. Other changes could include money for hospitals being linked to patient ratings. According to the Times, part of the proposals will see patients contacted a few weeks after their hospital treatment for feedback. Based on their responses, money could be diverted to a local 'improvement fund'. Another proposal could see NHS users awarded points for upping their step count and eating healthily. Points can then be traded for vouchers, with discounts at supermarkets and coffee shops, according to The Sun. Hundreds of bodies responsible for overseeing and running parts of the NHS in England are likely to be scrapped as part of the changes. Mr Streeting has said the current system is too complex and needs reform.
The Independent
32 minutes ago
- The Independent
Revealed: Woman who wrongly had part of spine removed among hundreds of NHS surgical blunders
A woman who mistakenly had part of her spine removed is among hundreds of patients who have been the victim of NHS surgical blunders this year. New figures show there were more than 400 serious surgical mistakes carried out on patients over the past year — including the incorrect organ being removed, the wrong body part being operated on or surgical instruments being left inside a patient's body. In some cases, entire operations were carried out on the wrong patient. The Royal College of Surgeons has now warned that the NHS needs to understand what has led to the rise in incidents to stop these mistakes being repeated. Among the victims is Gill, who was advised to have surgery on her right cervical rib after struggling with excruciating pain. But the surgeon performed the wrong operation and ended up removing portions of her vertebrae, leaving her with permanent damage to her spinal cord. 'I woke up the following morning and couldn't feel my arms and my legs and just thought 'oh my gosh what is wrong with me',' she told The Independent. The part-time-cook was warned by doctors she might not be able to walk again and was left struggling to work and was unable to continue her active lifestyle, which included dancing. Her movements are limited and she struggles with the function of her right hand. 'The emotions were just horrendous, because when you are told you will never walk again, it's very daunting,' she added. Through Been let Down lawyers Bond Turner, Gill was able to achieve a settlement for her pain and suffering and loss of amenity, loss of earnings, past and future loss of earnings; future housing adaptation costs and household expenses; past and future care; equipment; and rehabilitation. According to NHS provisional data, between April 2024 and March 2025, there were 403 similar incidents known as 'never events'– serious and largely preventable surgical mistakes. The year before, in 2023/24, there were 370 cases, while in 2022/23 there were 384. In 2021/22, 407 cases were recorded and in 2020/21 there were 364 — meaning more than 1,900 cases were reported over the past five years. The most common type of surgical error, making up more than 45 per cent of all reported 'never events' in the last year, was 'wrong site surgery'. This includes procedures performed on the wrong patient or at the wrong site, such as operating on the wrong knee, eye, or limb. Provisional data revealed that, out of the 185 'wrong site surgery' incidents, surgeons operated on the wrong body part in 46 cases. In 36 cases the wrong skin lesion was removed, while in nine cases patients received a surgery intended for someone else. In just over a quarter of incidents, a surgical instrument, swab or part of a needle was left inside the patient. About 50 patients have received the wrong implant or prosthesis, including the wrong hip or knee replacement. Other mishaps included a transfusion of the wrong blood, medication given incorrectly and overdoses of insulin. At most hospitals these 'never events' only happen once or twice a year, but NHS data reveals that, at the worst offending hospitals, these incidents can happen more than 10 times a year. Over the past year there were 10 incidents at Royal Free London NHS Foundation Trust, 11 at University Hospital Southampton and 13 at University Hospitals Birmingham NHS Foundation Trust. All these trusts have been contacted for comment. Paul Grundy, chief medical officer at University Hospital Southampton, said: 'We take any incidents of this nature extremely seriously and are sorry that they occurred. 'No patients suffered serious harm in any of these cases, however the Trust is committed to delivering the very best standards of care and is always transparent in the reporting of mistakes, encouraging staff to report incidents if they occur. 'On the rare occasion that we get things wrong, we carry out a thorough investigation, ensuring learnings are shared to help us improve the quality and safety of the clinical care we deliver and to minimise the risk of recurrence.' The Royal College of Surgeons said hospitals need to take steps to understand what has led to the rise in incidents to stop these mistakes being repeated. A spokesperson said: 'Surgical teams take the safety of patients very seriously, using the World Health Organisation's (WHO) pre and post-operative check lists to help prevent mistakes. 'When mistakes do happen, it is traumatic for both the patients and staff involved. 'NHS hospitals need to consider these figures carefully and take steps to understand what has led to the rise in incidents. 'They must learn from mistakes, in an open way, involving all theatre staff in changes to policies and procedures that can stop mistakes being repeated.' These incidents are recorded through a mandatory reporting system to NHS England and investigations are carried out by the Care Quality Commission (CQC). In the past decade the NHS has changed how the data is measured. Prior to 2014/15, they have only included incidents where a patient was directly harmed. But this was changed to include incidents with the potential to harm a patient – leading to a rise in the number of cases recorded. In 2017/18, the NHS made a minor change to the sub-categories it used to split never-events into different types of cases. An NHS spokesperson said: 'NHS staff work exceptionally hard to keep patients safe and incidents like these are extremely rare, but when they do occur NHS trusts are mandated to investigate what has happened and take effective steps to learn from them and make improvements.'
The Herald Scotland
35 minutes ago
- The Herald Scotland
Government's new health strategy ‘no more than hiding the crisps', Tories say
Shadow work and pensions secretary Helen Whately said setting mandatory targets for supermarkets was 'nanny state'. 'They had 14 years in opposition to think about what they wanted to do about the NHS, they've had a year in government, and the number one thing in it seems to be hide the crisps,' she told Sky News' Sunday Morning With Trevor Phillips. Mr Streeting said the Government wants to 'nudge people in the right direction' (Lucy North/PA) 'It's obviously the nanny state, but it's also not what people want for the NHS. 'People want to hear how they're going to get to see their GP. 'Telling people what to buy, I think, is not up to government. I believe in personal responsibility.' Health Secretary Wes Streeting told the same programme the Government will work with supermarkets to help 'nudge people in the right direction'. 'By taking the approach we're taking with supermarkets, they will decide through the combination of where they put their products, how they do price promotions, the reformulation, what products they choose to put on the shelves,' he said. 'They will work with us to make sure that we nudge people in the right direction without any of us even noticing, in the same way that we've nudged the country in the other direction since the 1990s.' Rejecting suggestions that the idea was too controlling, he said it was different to 'traditional nanny statism, where we regulate more heavily on price, on marketing, on what's sold'. Labour's 10-year health plan is set to be published next week. Other changes could include money for hospitals being linked to patient ratings. According to the Times, part of the proposals will see patients contacted a few weeks after their hospital treatment for feedback. Based on their responses, money could be diverted to a local 'improvement fund'. Another proposal could see NHS users awarded points for upping their step count and eating healthily. Points can then be traded for vouchers, with discounts at supermarkets and coffee shops, according to The Sun. Hundreds of bodies responsible for overseeing and running parts of the NHS in England are likely to be scrapped as part of the changes. Mr Streeting has said the current system is too complex and needs reform.
