Simple reason Aussies refusing to downsize for city

News.com.au

04-06-2025

Australians are clinging to their laundries, spare rooms and car spots — even if it means ditching city life — in a defiant rejection of the downsizing dream.
New research from Compare the Market reveals just 18.8 per cent of Australians would sacrifice space to live closer to the CBD, while a staggering 71.3 per cent either won't downsize or have no desire to live in the city at all.
But while most of the nation is holding onto space, property experts say buyers are increasingly flipping the script.
Compare the Market's general manager of money Stephen Zeller said Australians were drawing clear lines around which home features they would and wouldn't compromise on — and it wasn't what you might expect.
'Knowing which home amenities you definitely want and which you're willing to compromise on can help you narrow down which properties are right for you,' Mr Zeller said.
'Using comparison tools can also help you find a competitive interest rate on offer.'
Laundries topped the list of non-negotiables, with 50 per cent of Australians saying they would not give them up — followed by car park spaces, 38.9 per cent, garages, 34.7 per cent, and spare rooms, 30 per cent.
Buyers were most willing to ditch pools, 57.9 per cent, garden sheds, 42.1 per cent, and backyards, 35.8 per cent, to get closer to the city.
Melbourne based buyers advocate Cate Bakos said the national data came as a surprise, because her clients are increasingly choosing location over space.
'That actually surprised me — because I'm seeing the opposite,' Ms Bakos said.
'People are much more willing to give up space to be close to cafes, culture and lifestyle.
'They want to be where the action is.'
Ms Bakos said many buyers had moved away from car ownership entirely, opting for public transport, ride-share services and car share schemes.
'They'd rather save that cost and use the money elsewhere,' she said.
'The focus has shifted to experiences, lifestyle and social connectivity.'
But the buyers agent said one feature remains a deal-breaker for many buyers:
'Move-in readiness. Buyers are not interested in renovators right now,' Ms Bakos said.
'The builder shortage and renovation costs have turned people off.
'A turnkey home is gold.'
Ms Bakos added that confidence was being driven by major infrastructure upgrades, particularly Melbourne's $15bn Metro Tunnel, set to reshape commuting when it opens later this year.
'It's the kind of change buyers will feel in their daily commute,' she said.
'It builds confidence and convenience.'
'The Suburban Rail Loop might be the long game, but right now, the Metro Tunnel is what people are excited about.'
McGrath Wynnum-Manly principal Gaby McEwan said buyers, particularly in Brisbane were still chasing space, but not for land size alone.
'It's not necessarily about acreage. It's about a change in pace,' Ms McEwan said.
'They want a backyard, a garden, a safer community and access to the water.'
Ms McEwan said a growing number of young families were selling up in Brisbane inner-city pockets like Newstead and West End to secure lifestyle homes in seaside suburbs such as Wynnum and Manly.
'They're not just trading sideways,' she said.
'In some cases, they're paying more for a smaller block, just to live near the water.
'The Esplanade used to be quiet. Now it's buzzing. People discovered it during lockdowns and never left.'
The McGrath Wynnum-Manly principal said even basic homes are being snapped up by buyers keen to get into the suburb.
'We recently sold one for $925,000, it was full of asbestos and hadn't been touched in decades,' Ms McEwan said.
'But it was on a great street, and the buyers were happy to renovate just to get in.'
Ms McEwan said a wave of locals who grew up in the area were now returning after years of inner-city living.
'They've seen the value of their units go up, and now they're either selling or holding and buying again here,' she said.
'It's a smart move, and once they're back, they never want to leave.'
State-by-state: Who's least willing to compromise?
Victorians were the most attached to their laundries, with 53.2 per cent unwilling to give them up.
Queenslanders were more open to ditching the backyard, 38.5 per cent, and only 10.9 per cent were willing to lose a laundry.
New South Wales came in close to the national average, but Sydneysiders showed slightly greater willingness to downsize for location.
South Australians were most attached to having a garage, with 42.9 per cent unwilling to let it go.