Mike Dailly: UK must recognise Palestine as a state
It's against this humanitarian crisis that France will become the first G7 country to recognise Palestine as a state.
Last week, President Emmanuel Macron advised the president of the Palestinian Authority, Mahmoud Abbas that he would announce formal recognition at the United Nation's (UN) General Assembly in September.
Such recognition may be largely symbolic but it adds diplomatic pressure for UN membership and statehood. Palestine has been seeking full UN membership since 2011 but has been blocked by the United States (US).
Last April, a resolution for UN membership for Palestine was vetoed by the US. The 15-member Security Council had 12 votes in favour, two abstentions and one vote against.
A state has certain defining features under international law, including a permanent population, a determinate territory, "effective" government and the capacity to enter into relations with other states.
Israeli Defence Minister Israel Katz described the move by France as "a disgrace and a surrender to terrorism". He said Israel would not permit the establishment of a "Palestinian entity that would harm our security, endanger our existence".
US Secretary of State Marco Rubio said that the US "strongly rejects" Macron's plan because it was a "reckless decision" that "only serves Hamas propaganda and sets back peace."
At the same time as Macron's announcement, ceasefire talks were halted as the US and Israel withdrew their negotiating teams from Qatar.
In contrast, France and Saudi Arabia are hosting an international conference at the UN in New York - today and tomorrow - seeking peaceful solutions and renewed efforts for a 'two-state solution'. The US has opted out of attendance.
A two-state solution would see an independent Palestinian state established alongside the state of Israel, giving both peoples their own territory.
Palestinians want an independent state in the occupied West Bank, annexed east Jerusalem and Gaza, land that have been occupied by Israel since the 1967 Six-Day War.
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu opposes Palestinian statehood and says it would reward militants after the 7 October attacks by Hamas in 2023.
President Macron said, "France will seek to make a decisive contribution to peace in the Middle East and will mobilise all of its international partners who wish to take part".
While the US continues to insist it supports a two-state solution and peace in the Middle East, in reality, it appears to be a key driver of stalemate in the region.
The need for food, water and medicine in Gaza is now beyond an emergency.
Jordan and the UAE have a proposal, supported by the UK, to drop aid into Gaza, but aid agencies say this will do little to mitigate the hunger of Gazans as the crisis is now beyond critical.
Pressure is on Prime Minister Starmer to follow President Macron and for the UK to recognise Palestine as a state. Around 221 MPs have signed a motion urging him to do so. Let's hope he does so this week.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
ITV News
8 minutes ago
- ITV News
Starmer shares UK-led peace plan as Trump acknowledges 'starvation' in Gaza
Prime Minister Keir Starmer shared details of a UK-led peace plan for the Middle East with US President Donald Trump on Monday, during their meeting in Scotland. The prime minister is preparing to host an emergency cabinet meeting on the crisis on Tuesday. Starmer started work on a plan with France and Germany over the weekend, after an emergency call with the two countries' leaders, Emmanuel Macron and Friedrich Merz. In a readout of his meeting with the US president, Downing Street said the two leaders reiterated calls for an immediate ceasefire to pave the way for peace. 'The Prime Minister welcomed the President's efforts to secure this and shared the plans he is working on with other European leaders to bring about a lasting peace,' a No 10 spokesperson said. Starmer described the situation in Gaza as an 'absolute catastrophe' as he appeared alongside Trump at his Turnberry golf course ahead of their talks. 'It's a humanitarian crisis, it's an absolute catastrophe,' the prime minister said.'Nobody wants to see that. "I think people in Britain are revolted at seeing what they're seeing on their screens, so we've got to get to that ceasefire.' The US president was asked if he agreed with Netanyahu's comments on Sunday in which the Israeli leader said, "There is no policy of starvation in Gaza and there is no starvation in Gaza." "I don't know," Trump replied Monday. "I mean, based on television, I would say not particularly because those children look very hungry." Israel announced at the weekend that it would suspend fighting in three areas of Gaza for 10 hours a day and open secure routes for aid delivery, while the UK confirmed it was taking part in plans led by Jordan to airdrop aid into the territory. But aid agencies operating in Gaza said the new measures were not enough to counter worsening starvation and that nothing on the ground had changed. Martin Penner, a spokesperson for the UN food agency, said all 55 of its aid trucks that entered on Sunday were unloaded by crowds before reaching their destination. Speaking at his Ayrshire golf course, Trump said the US would set up new food centres in Gaza "without fences", after the current US-led arrangement had led to multiple killings of Palestinians. 'We're going to set up food centres, and we're going to do it in conjunction with some very good people,' he said."I want him to make sure they get the food," Trump said. "I want to make sure they get the food."Hinting at sticking points in negotiations over a peace deal, Trump said Palestinian militant group Hamas had become 'very difficult to deal with' in recent weeks, suggesting this was because they only held a small remaining number of Israeli hostages. Starmer has likened the plan he is working on with France and Germany to the coalition of the willing, the international effort to support Ukraine towards a lasting Prime Minister's official spokesman said the plan would build 'on the collaboration to date that paves the way to a long-term solution on security in the region'. The Prime Minister is meanwhile facing calls from a growing number of MPs to recognise a Palestinian state have an 'inalienable right to statehood', and it is a 'question of when, not if' the UK will agree to recognition, No 10 than 250 cross-party MPs have now signed a letter calling for ministers to take the step, up from 221 on Friday.
BBC News
9 minutes ago
- BBC News
Reconsider Gaza family case, court tells Foreign Office
A Palestinian family who are trying to get the UK government to help them flee Gaza have won a critical ruling in their legal Monday, the High Court said that the foreign secretary had to "think again" about whether officials could help get the family ruling said the family of six were at "constant risk of injury or death" living in a tent in Deir al-Balah, central Gaza. They first applied to come to the UK, where they have a British relative, in January 2024. A government spokesman said it was considering the judgment carefully. The case sparked headlines in February when it became the centre of a misunderstood row at Prime Minister's Questions (PMQs).Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch and Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer clashed over mistaken and muddled claims that the family had exploited a scheme for Ukrainian their case was in fact dealt with on its own merits and not under the rules for resettling Ukrainians. The father, known only as "BEL", and his two young adult children had been fired at by Israeli forces at an aid distribution link to the UK is through the father's brother, referred to in court as "BSJ". He legally settled in the UK after Hamas came to power in Gaza in 2007 and became a British court heard that Hamas had so discriminated against the family, who had worked for its political opponents, that it had killed a the October 2023 war began, BSJ began asking if his brother and his family could come to the Home Office granted the family permission to come to the UK in January this year, telling them they must first pass biometric checks at the British consulate in the Foreign Office has refused to ask Israel to let the family leave Gaza because it only does so in exceptional cases involving couples or a parent and child separated by the against the government, Mr Justice Chamberlain said while the law did not require the government to assist the family to reach the UK, the foreign secretary should look again, considering the legally exceptional nature of the Barratt, the family's lawyer, said: "We hope that the Foreign Office will consider the judgment carefully and act quickly to reconsider their approach to this case and the policy more widely so that our clients and others in a similar position can be assisted to leave Gaza." Back in February, the family's case became a political row when Badenoch said during PMQs that it had been "completely wrong" for a judge to grant Palestinians the right to live in the UK after they originally applied through a scheme designed for fired back that the government would close the loophole. "It should be Parliament that makes the rules on immigration," he said at the time. But the publicly-available appeal judgment shows the family were not given permission to arrive under the scheme for Ukrainian they had initially used that immigration form, in error, they won their case under general human rights considerations which allow families from all backgrounds to make an exceptional request for Lady Chief Justice, Dame Sue Carr, later said the way both leaders had presented the case in Parliament had been "unacceptable", given their duty to respect the role of judges in upholding the law.
South Wales Argus
15 minutes ago
- South Wales Argus
France calls on EU to pressure Israel to move on Palestinian two-state solution
Jean-Noel Barrot, the French foreign minister, told reporters at the United Nations that while there is international consensus that the time for a political solution to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict is now, world powers need to back up their words with actions. 'The European Commission, on behalf of the EU, has to express its expectations and show the means that we can incentivise the Israeli government to hear this appeal,' he said. Mr Barrot spoke on the first day of a high-level UN meeting on a two-state solution to the decades-old Israeli-Palestinian conflict, which is being co-chaired by France and Saudi Arabia. The unoccupied US delegation seat at the United Nations General Assembly on Monday (Richard Drew/AP) The conference, which was postponed from June and downgraded to the ministerial level, is taking place in New York as international condemnation of Israel's handling of the war in Gaza reaches a fever pitch. Both Israel and its closest ally, the United States, refused to participate in the meeting, which Mr Barrot said is being attended by representatives of 125 countries, including 50 ministers. The aim of the conference, Mr Barrot said, is 'to reverse the trend of what is happening in the region – mainly the erasure of the two-state solution, which has been for a long time the only solution that can bring peace and security in the region.' He urged the European Commission to call on Israel to lift a financial blockade on two billion euros he says the Israeli government owes the Palestinian Authority; stop settlement building in the West Bank, which threatens the territorial integrity of a future Palestinian state; and end the 'militarised' food delivery system in Gaza by the Israeli-backed Gaza Humanitarian Foundation, which has resulted in hundreds of killings. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has rejected the two-state solution on both nationalistic and security grounds. The US has echoed its sentiment and on Monday called the conference 'unproductive and ill-timed'. 'The United States will not participate in this insult but will continue to lead real-world efforts to end the fighting and deliver a permanent peace,' State Department spokesperson Tammy Bruce said in a statement. 'Our focus remains on serious diplomacy: not stage-managed conferences designed to manufacture the appearance of relevance.' Ahead of the meeting, French President Emmanuel Macron announced that France would recognise Palestine as a state at the annual gathering of world leaders at the UN General Assembly in September. The bold but mostly symbolic move is aimed at adding diplomatic pressure on Israel. France is now the biggest Western power and the only member of the Group of Seven major industrialised nations to recognise the state of Palestine, and the move could pave the way for other countries to do the same. More than 140 countries recognise a Palestinian state, including more than a dozen in Europe. At the conference opening, Palestinian Prime Minister Mohammed Mustafa called for all countries who have not yet recognised Palestine as a state to do so 'without delay'. 'The path to peace begins by recognising the state of Palestine and preserving it from destruction,' he said. The other issue being discussed at the conference is normalisation between Israel and the Arab states in the region. Prince Faisal bin Farhan, the Saudi foreign minister, stressed that normalisation of relations with Israel 'can only come through the establishment of a Palestinian state'. With global anger rising over desperately hungry people in Gaza starting to die from starvation, US President Donald Trump on Monday called for increasing aid to Palestinians, a rare glimpse of daylight between him and Mr Netanyahu, who has said there is no starvation. Both Mr Barrot and Mr Farhan said on Monday that the US is an essential actor in the region and that it was the president in January who secured the only ceasefire in the 21-month war. 'I am firmly in the belief that Trump's engagement can be a catalyst for an end to the immediate crisis in Gaza and potentially a resolution of the Palestinian-Israeli conflict in the long term,' Mr Farhan said.
