Five petitioners urge Supreme Court to set early deadline for Centre to restore statehood in J-K
Citing assurances made by the Union Government, parliamentary statements, and the Supreme Court's observations in the 2023 verdict, the signatories expressed concern that the prolonged Union Territory status, imposed in 2019, violates the Constitution's basic structure doctrine and sets a dangerous precedent for Indian federalism.
The petitioners, in their letter to the CJI, have also raised concerns that the Union government may argue that, considering the recent Pahalgam terrorist attack, now is not an appropriate time to restore statehood in J&K. However, the petitioners have asserted that this is not a tenable argument against bringing statehood to the region.
'We are concerned that the Union administration will again argue that the time is not appropriate for the restoration of Jammu and Kashmir's statehood, given the Pahalgam terrorist attack of April 2025. Not only is that argument not tenable, but it can be argued that this is exactly the time to do so. The high turnout in the October 2024 assembly elections, with no violence, and the absolute majority of electors gave the National Conference, a regional party, indicated the people had voted for an elected administration with the strength to govern according to public aspirations', the letter reads.
Furthermore, the letter argues that the Lieutenant Governor Manoj Sinha administration's hasty and unjustified punitive actions have triggered widespread public anger, which is exacerbated by the exclusion of the elected government from security and grievance redressal processes.
The Chief Minister is excluded from security briefings, and the Lieutenant-Governor has rejected the elected government's request to be involved in civil service matters despite a Supreme Court ruling in a similar Delhi case, the letter asserts.
It is further stated in the letter that with no human rights commission in J&K and police not answerable to elected representatives, citizens have no avenue for redress.
The letter warns that the post-Pahalgam environment, which is conducive to peace, is deteriorating and stresses that restoring statehood, with civil and political rights, is the most effective remedy.
Thus, the petitioners have appealed to the top court to take suo motu cognisance of this letter, constitute a bench of the Supreme Court to hear petitions on the unconstitutionality of the removal of Jammu and Kashmir's statehood and to set an early deadline for its restoration.
The five petitioners are Radha Kumar, a former member of the Group of Interlocutors for Jammu and Kashmir. Gopal Pillai, former Union Home Secretary of India. Major-General Ashok K. Mehta (retd), Indian Army. Air Vice-Marshal Kapil Kak (retd). Indian Air Force Amitabha Pande. Former Union Secretary, Inter-State Council of India. (ANI)
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
43 minutes ago
- Time of India
Commercially driven: Maya hits out at Centre over train fare hike
Lucknow: national president on Tuesday said that the central govt's decision to increase the passenger train fare is driven more by commercial concerns than the welfarist objectives of the Constitution. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now She said that at a time when people in the country are badly hit by poverty, unemployment, inflation and lesser incomes, the train fare hike is not in public interest. "It will be better if the govt immediately rethinks it," she added. The govt increasing the burden on people in their day-to-day lives in the name of 'nation first', through railways, just like GST, is highly inappropriate, said the BSP chief. Train travel is not a fashion, joy or tourism for crores of people who are forced to migrate because of poverty, inflation, and lack of permanent and respectable employment, and to take care of their families, she said. She added, "The highly uncomfortable train travel is a compulsion and basic requirement for them." The govt should be sympathetic towards them, and instead of thinking about its profit or a handful of rich and prosperous people, it should be concerned about crores of such people who are craving to live a life of self-respect. They are bound to take little benefits from govt's welfare schemes to get a stomachful of food at least one time a day, she said. "It is because of this that 95 crore people in the country were forced to be a beneficiary under at least one of the social welfare schemes of the govt. In 2025, there were 64.3 per cent such people against 22 per cent in 2016. But, the govt is citing this data from the International Labour Organisation as its achievement," said the former UP CM. She also said that the central and Delhi govts should also look at the exploitation and difficulties faced by the middle-class urban population and crores of poor and hardworking people on the pretext of pollution control almost every day. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now Instead of acting strictly against the lifespan of vehicles to control pollution, the govt needs to act on other measures as well, so that people in the transport business are saved from further inconvenience and financial hardships, she added. She also decried the Delhi govt's demolition drives in slums as "anti-people" and said that the govt is doing it without making any alternate arrangements for people. "The govt is saying that it is doing so on court's order, when the court has not put any ban on making alternate arrangements for people before displacing them," said Mayawati. The shortage of electricity supply in the entire country has affected people, industrialists, and small traders alike, she added.
United News of India
an hour ago
- United News of India
VHP flays Karnataka Minister Priyank Kharge over RSS remarks
New Delhi, July 1 (UNI) The Vishwa Hindu Parishad (VHP) today launched a scathing attack on Karnataka Minister Priyank Kharge, accusing him of making fallacious and irresponsible remarks about the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS), and termed the Congress party as anti-India. In a statement, VHP National Spokesperson Vinod Bansal said, "Priyank Kharge's arguments come from a deeply distorted mindset. This is not the first time he has made controversial comments about Sanatan Dharma. His public stature is negligible, he only blabbers." Referring to Kharge's statement, made in Bihar, about banning the RSS if the Congress returns to power at the Centre, Bansal said, "They made such claims but couldn't follow through. The Congress party has tried to ban the RSS thrice — each time ending in embarrassment." Citing historical instances, Bansal recalled, "The first attempt was after Mahatma Gandhi's assassination. The court gave them such a tight slap that the mark is still visible. The second was during the Emergency, when the entire nation was held hostage. Indira Gandhi had to go to jail. The third was during the Ram Mandir movement, and again, the courts dismissed their actions." Calling the Congress party shameless, Bansal said, "Despite being rejected by the people and reduced to just two or three states, the Congress continues to make such irresponsible statements. They're trying to salvage their sinking political fortunes by targeting nationalist organizations." He further added, "If they want to understand the RSS, they should attend a shakha. But they have neither the stature nor the credibility to suppress the Sangh or hold India hostage again. They've already murdered democracy and tampered with the Constitution once — that mistake won't be repeated." The strong response from the VHP came after Priyank Kharge today stated: 'If Congress comes to power in the Centre again, we will ban RSS.' He argued that the RSS spreads hatred in society and does not operate within the bounds of the a post on X, Priyank Kharge, the son of Congress chief Mallikarjun Kharge, said: "RSS leaders have long pushed to erase the words 'socialist' and 'secular' from our Constitution. Now, BJP leaders have started parroting the same demand, conveniently ignoring the fact that the Supreme Court has repeatedly upheld their inclusion as integral to the Constitution's spirit."Before preaching constitutional edits, the RSS should take a long, hard look at the BJP's own party constitution. Article II of its preamble clearly states that the BJP is committed to the principles of socialism and secularism. Perhaps they should begin by amending that first." UNI BDN RN
Hindustan Times
an hour ago
- Hindustan Times
Argentina's top court finds a dozen boxes of Nazi materials in its basement
BUENOS AIRES, - Argentina's top court finds a dozen boxes of Nazi materials in its basement Around a dozen boxes of Nazi material confiscated by Argentinean authorities during World War II were recently rediscovered in the Supreme Court's basement, the court said on Sunday. The boxes were among 83 sent by the Germany embassy in Tokyo to Argentina in June 1941 aboard the Japanese steamship "Nan-a-Maru," according to the history that the court was able to piece together, it said in a statement. At the time, the large shipment drew the attention of authorities, who feared its contents could affect Argentina's neutrality in the war. Despite claims at the time from German diplomatic representatives that the boxes held personal items, Argentine customs authorities searched five boxes at random. They found postcards, photographs and propaganda material from the Nazi regime, as well as thousands of notebooks belonging to the Nazi Party. A federal judge confiscated the materials, and referred the matter to the Supreme Court. It was not immediately clear why the items were sent to Argentina or what, if any, action the Supreme Court took at the time. Eighty-four years later, court staffers came across the boxes as they prepared for a Supreme Court museum. "Upon opening one of the boxes, we identified material intended to consolidate and propagate Adolf Hitler's ideology in Argentina during the Second World War," the court said. The court has now transferred the boxes to a room equipped with extra security measures, and invited the Holocaust Museum in Buenos Aires to participate in their preservation and inventory. Experts will also examine them for any clues about still-unknown aspects of the Holocaust, such as international financing networks used by the Nazis. Argentina remained neutral in World War II until 1944, when it broke relations with Axis powers. The South American country declared war on Germany and Japan the following year. From 1933 to 1954, according to the Holocaust Museum, 40,000 Jews entered Argentina as they fled Nazi persecution in Europe. Argentina is home to the largest population of Jews in Latin America. This article was generated from an automated news agency feed without modifications to text.
