
Why they pleaded guilty to walk out of jail, end their legal ordeal
Tired of too many ads? go ad free now
As the court visitors rose from their seats after the verdict, Kunwarpal was a free man
Rishi from Bulandshahr — facing charges under the UP Gangster Act since 2002 — pleaded guilty after spending over nine years in jail. The court sentenced him to the time he had already served behind bars — 9 years, 5 months, and 12 days. Rishi walked out free after paying a Rs 5,000 fine.
Similarly, Sahil — arrested in Noida with 5.2gm of smack — chose to plead guilty after seven months in custody. The fast-track court, considering his status as the sole earning member of his family, sentenced him to the time already served in jail plus a Rs 1,000 fine
These are not cases in isolation.
They represent a growing trend where defendants are increasingly choosing to admit their guilt and plead for leniency instead of standing trial to expedite resolution. Called 'plea bargaining', the clause is being increasingly used by those who have spent considerable time in police custody.
"Most of these accused don't have active family members to pray on their behalf. So, they often spend several years behind bars without their cases even coming up for trial," said Prateek Kumar, a lawyer who claimed to know many such cases.
Special public prosecutor Varun Tyagi, who argued against Danish in a Gangster Act case, said the accused was advised by his lawyer to plead guilty. "He had been in jail since April 2023 and suffering from failing health. Danish had denied the charges against him on June 25. Merely a week ahead, he decided to confess to the crime. His counsel did not cross the prosecution's arguments, which suggests that the accused knew it was better to plead for leniency than continuing to argue the case," Tyagi said.
Tired of too many ads? go ad free now
Danish was sentenced to 2 years and three months of rigorous imprisonment with a fine of Rs 5,000. "He had already spent that period in jail. So, he walked out free," he added.
Ajit Nagar, secretary at the GB Nagar Bar Association, insisted that plea bargaining significantly reduced case pendency. "When an accused pleads guilty, they are at liberty to bargain under provisions of law for a lesser punishment from court," he added.
Nagar pointed out that in certain cases, most of the accused preferred to plead guilty to fast track their hearings. "For instance, no one wants to contest cases where vehicles are impounded by police for traffic violations. The vehicle will remain confiscated unless the matter is disposed of. So, pleading guilty and paying a fine to end the case seems better than deciding to argue," he said.
Similarly, in cases under the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances (NDPS) Act, the accused are often encouraged by their counsel to plead guilty when the quantity of the contraband is less.
Since the penal provision for smaller quantities of drugs is up to one year, the accused can bargain for a lesser sentence and secure release earlier than waiting for a trial, which may take several years.
In NDPS cases, the punishment and chances of bail depend upon the quantity of contraband recovered. According to lawyers, the quantity of drugs is categorised as 'small' and 'commercial' for different substances.
For instance, a kilo of ganja is considered 'small' while 20kg is treated as a 'commercial' quantity. But in the case of cocaine, 2gm is 'small' while 100gm is 'commercial'.
Ajit Handa, a defence counsel at the district court in Ghaziabad, pointed out that obtaining bail under the stringent NDPS Act was often difficult.
"Usually, those arrested in such cases remain in jail for a longer period because of high pendency.
But, if the quantity of drugs recovered is small, they can come out of jail early by pleading guilty," he said.
"Sahil's case is a pointer to this. The court acknowledged he was the sole breadwinner in his family and accepted his plea," Handed went on to addd.
Introduced in 2006 as Chapter XXI-A in the Criminal Procedure Code, plea bargaining aims at reducing court backlogs and streamlining the judicial process. However, it's not applicable in cases involving crimes against women or children below 14, those affecting socio-economic conditions, or repeat offenders.
Utkarsh Vats, special public prosecutor (Pocso), said cases involving serious crimes were exempt from plea bargaining as well.
"People accused under the Pocso Act cannot plead guilty for want of leniency by the court. Even if an accused pleads guilty, their case is heard in keeping with available penal provisions in the law," he added.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Scroll.in
6 minutes ago
- Scroll.in
Kerala nuns held in Chhattisgarh for alleged religious conversion, bishops' group calls case ‘false'
Two nuns from Kerala and a man were arrested at the Durg railway station in Chhattisgarh on Saturday for alleged human trafficking and religious conversion, The News Minute reported. The nuns – Preeti Mary and Vandana Francis – are members of the Assisi Sisters of Mary Immaculate, a congregation under the Syro-Malabar Church in Alappuzha district's Cherthala town and were working at a hospital in Agra, Mathrubhumi reported. The two nuns and the man, identified as Sukhman Mandavi, were accompanying three women from Chhattisgarh's Narayanpur district. Sebastian Poomattam, vicar general of the Raipur Archdiocese, told The News Minute that the nuns were taking the women to Agra where they had been offered jobs of kitchen helpers at a convent. 'They had the consent letters from their parents and were all above 18 years of age,' he added. While at the railway station, a ticket examiner questioned the group on the platform. 'The girls and one man entered the platform where the nuns were waiting,' The News Minute quoted Poomattam as saying. 'The examiner asked about their tickets, and they said the nuns had them.' The vicar general claimed that the examiner informed members of the Hindutva group Bajrang Dal about the situation and that the outfit's members 'arrived in large numbers within minutes'. The police detained the nuns, the man and the three women. The Bajrang Dal vigilantes protested at the police station and demanded the registration of a first information report against the nuns, The News Minute reported. The nuns and Mandavi were remanded to judicial custody till August 8. They were charged under sections of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita pertaining to human trafficking and sections of Chhattisgarh Religious Freedom Act. The three women were taken to a government-run shelter home. Unidentified police officers told the Hindustan Times that the nuns were allegedly taking the women to Agra with the promise of 'good facilities and a monthly salary of Rs 8,000 to Rs 10,000'. The police had reached the railway station based on a tip-off from members of the Bajrang Dal, the officers were quoted as having said. 'When questioned, the women said that initially they were told they would be offered jobs within Chhattisgarh, but when they reached Durg, they were told that the nuns had come to take them to Agra,' the newspaper quoted the officers as saying. Commenting on the incident, the Catholic Bishops' Conference of India alleged that a ' false ' case had been filed against the nuns under the influence of Hindutva groups, Onmanorama reported. The bishops' conference sought the intervention of Prime Minister Narendra Modi and Union Home Minister Amit Shah in the matter. Kerala CM seeks PM's intervention Kerala Chief Minister Pinarayi Vijayan on Sunday also sought Modi's intervention in ensuring justice to the two nuns, PTI reported. In a letter to the prime minister, the chief minister said that Mary and Francis were arrested when they had gone to receive women who were coming to work in their convent. Family members of the two nuns have claimed that they had not been able to communicate with them after they were taken into custody, he added. Vijayan requested the prime minister to intervene in the matter and ensure transparent and fair proceedings, PTI reported. Alappuzha MP KC Venugopal said on Sunday that attacks on minorities had seen 'a rampant increase under BJP-ruled states, be it Chhattisgarh, Odisha or MP [Madhya Pradesh]'. The Congress leader said that he had written to the Union home ministry and Chhattisgarh Chief Minister Vishnu Deo Sai demanding strict punishment against the culprits and the urgent need to uphold the Constitution 'so that fundamental rights of minorities are not threatened under their rule'. 'The latest attacks by Bajrang Dal goons on 2 Catholic nuns in Durg, Chhattisgarh point to a tacit support for such hate crimes from the ruling establishment,' Venugopal said on social media. In his letter to the home ministry and the Chhattisgarh chief minister, Venugopal said that it was 'deeply disturbing that self proclaimed vigilantes can instigate communal tension and make baseless accusations of conversion and trafficking without any legal foundation'. He added: 'Despite clear documentation and parental consent, the authorities have chosen to keep the nuns and the man in custody, reportedly under political pressure.'


The Hindu
2 hours ago
- The Hindu
Palghar school watchman held for allegedly sexually abusing two minor boys
Police have arrested a 53-year-old security guard of a private school in Maharashtra's Palghar district for allegedly sexually abusing two male students, officials said. The alleged incidents occurred between June 15 and 20, the officials said on Sunday (July 27, 2025). The victims, aged 17 and 15, are students of the same school located in Virar area. "The alleged incidents occurred in the canteen of the school," the Arnala police stated. The accused was arrested on Saturday (July 26, 2025)evening, the police added. "After receiving a complaint from the school's manager, we registered an FIR against the watchman, Raymond Wilson Dias, under section 75 (sexual harassment) of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS) and sections 5, 8 and 12 of the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences (POCSO) Act," the Arnala police station official said. Sections 5 of the POCSO Act pertains to penetrative sexual assault. In August 2024, a male sweeper at a school in Badlapur in neighbouring Thane district allegedly sexually abused two four-year-old girls, causing a huge outrage and massive protests. The accused was killed in September last year in the 'retaliatory firing' by police after he allegedly snatched the gun from a policeman in a police vehicle.


Hans India
2 hours ago
- Hans India
Hyd police blow lid off illegal surrogacy racket
Hyderabad: Hyderabad City Police with the support of the Medical and Health department busted an illegal surrogacy and baby selling racket. Police arrested eight persons, including the doctor and owner of Universal Srushti Fertility Centre in Hyderabad and Andhra Pradesh. The arrested persons were Dr Athaluri Namratha Pachipala (64), owner of Universal Srushti Fertility Centre, and associates Pachipala Jayanth Krishna (25), C Kalyani Atchayyamma (40), working as Manager at the centre, Gollamandala Chenna Rao (37), Lab Technician & Embryologist, Nargula Sadanandam (41), Anesthesia Specialist and working doctor in Gandhi Hospital, Dhanasri Santoshi (38), Mohammed Ali Adik (38), and Nasreen Begum (25), all three native of Assam. According to police, the complainant couple approached Universal Srushti Fertility Centre located in Gopalapuram in August 2024 for fertility and IVF consultation. There they met Dr Namrata who after conducting fertility related tests advised them to go for surrogacy. The couple was directed to another branch of the clinic at Visakhapatnam for collection of specimens and were told that the surrogate will be arranged by the clinic and the embryo would be transplanted to the surrogate. 'Over the course of 9 months, the couple made several payments to the clinic and updates as to the baby's health were given by the clinic. In June 2025, the complainant was informed that the surrogate had delivered a baby boy via C-section in Visakhapatnam and that they should pay extra amount for the delivery charges and collect the baby from Visakhapatnam,' said S Rashmi Perumal, DCP North Zone. The DCP said the complainant reached Vizag and the baby boy was handed over to her along with documentation which showed registration of the child as having been born to the couple themselves, creating a false birth certificate document. 'Overall, the clinic took over Rs 35 lakhs from the couple as consultation charges for the procedures. Later, the couple went in for a DNA test which revealed that the child's DNA did not match theirs at all. They tried to get in touch with the clinic, but they were refused any documentation and were threatened, which prompted them to approach the police,' said the DCP. Rashmi said that in an inquiry it was revealed that the main accused, Dr Namratha was conducting a large-scale illegal surrogacy and fertility scam. She began medical practice in 1995 and transitioned into fertility and IVF services from 1998. Over the years, she expanded into unethical and illegal practices, collecting Rs 20 – Rs 30 lakh from each client under false promises. 'She, along with associates, targeted vulnerable women, particularly those seeking abortions and lured them into continuing pregnancies in exchange for money. These newborns were then passed off as children conceived through surrogacy, misleading clients into believing the babies were biologically theirs.' The original parents of the baby were identified (native of Assam and living in Hyderabad) and the delivery was planned at Vizag. After taking the baby, a paltry sum was handed over to them and the couple was sent back to Hyderabad. On charges of baby selling, the original parents were also tracked and arrested. A simultaneous raid was planned at Hyderabad and Vizag clinics, which led to several arrests. With the help of the medical department, the clinic at Gopalapuram was seized and large-scale equipment was found at the area which substantiated the facts that the accused was conducting IVF treatments, creating live embryos, doing real medical procedures without any proper license. Gopalapuram police seized medical equipment and medicines being used at the clinic, mobile phones and digital devices, case records and surrogacy documents seized with help from Medical and Health Department officials. More than 10 cases have been registered previously so far. Police said the investigation is ongoing, and further legal action is being pursued. The Medical and Health Department had cancelled the registration of the fertility clinic previously, but the accused continued to operate the place from the building and put the name of another certified doctor Dr. Suri Shrimati on the official letter pads of the clinic.