US Senate pushes ahead on Trump tax cuts as non-partisan analysis raises price tag
The estimate by the Congressional budget office (CBO) of the bill's hit to the $36.2-trillion (R644-trillion) federal debt is about $800bn (R14.2-trillion) more than the version passed last month in the House of Representatives.
Senators are scheduled to start voting on a potentially long list of amendments to the bill beginning at 9am on Monday.
Republicans, who have long voiced concern about growing US deficits and debt, have rejected the CBO's long-standing methodology to calculate the cost of legislation.
Democrats the latest figure could stoke enough anxiety among fiscally-minded conservatives to get them to buck their party, which controls the two chambers of Congress.
'Republicans are doing something the Senate has never, never done before, deploying fake math and accounting gimmicks to hide the true cost of the bill,' Demo
Democratic Senate minority leader Chuck Schumer said when debate opened on Sunday. 'Republicans are about to pass the single most expensive bill in US history, to give tax breaks to billionaires while taking away Medicaid, Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Programme benefits and good paying jobs for millions of people.'
The Senate only narrowly advanced the tax-cut, immigration, border and military spending bill in a procedural vote late on Saturday, voting 51-49 to open debate on the 940-page megabill.
Senator Thom Tillis of North Carolina, one of two Republicans who voted to block the bill, explained his position in a speech to the Senate, saying White House aides had failed to give Trump proper advice about the legislation's Medicaid cuts.
'What do I tell 663,00 people in two years, three years, when President Trump breaks his promise by pushing them off of Medicaid because the funding's no longer there,' Tillis said, referring to his constituents.
Trump on social media hailed Saturday's vote as a 'great victory' for his 'great, big, beautiful bill'.
In a separate post on Sunday, he said: 'We will make it all up, times 10, with growth, more than ever before.'
In an illustration of the depths of the divide within the Republican Party over the bill, Tillis said he would not seek re-election next year after Trump threatened to back a primary challenger in retribution for Tillis' Saturday night vote against the bill.
On Sunday, Trump celebrated Tillis' announcement as 'great news' on Truth Social and issued a warning to fellow Republicans who have concerns over the bill.
'Remember, you have to get re-elected. Don't go too crazy,' Trump wrote in a post.
Tillis' North Carolina seat is one of the few Republican Senate seats seen as vulnerable in next year's midterm elections.
Trump wants the bill passed before the July 4 Independence Day holiday. While that deadline is one of choice, lawmakers will face a far more serious deadline later this year when they must raise the nation's self-imposed debt ceiling or risk a devastating default on $36.2-trillion (R644-trillion) in debt.
Senator Mark Warner, a Democrat from Virginia, said the legislation would come to haunt Republicans if it is approved, predicting 16-million Americans would lose their health insurance.
'Many of my Republican friends know they're walking the plank on this and we'll see if those who've expressed quiet consternation will have the courage of their convictions,' Warner told CBS News' Face the Nation with Margaret Brennan.
The legislation has been the sole focus of a marathon weekend congressional session marked by political drama, division and lengthy delays as Democrats seek to slow the legislation's path to passage.
Schumer called for the entire text of the bill to be read on the Senate floor, a process that began before midnight on Saturday and ran well into Sunday afternoon. Following up on 20-hours of debate on the legislation, the Senate will enter an amendment session, known as a 'vote-a-rama', before voting on passage. Lawmakers said they hoped to complete work on the bill on Monday.
Senator Rand Paul of Kentucky, the other Republican 'no' vote, opposed the legislation because it would raise the federal borrowing limit by an additional $5-trillion (R89-trillion).
The megabill would extend the 2017 tax cuts that were Trump's main legislative achievement during his first term as president, cut other taxes and boost spending on the military and border security.
Senate Republicans, who reject the CBO's estimates on the cost of the legislation, are set on using an alternative calculation method that does not factor in costs from extending the 2017 tax cuts. Outside tax experts, including Andrew Lautz from the non-partisan think-tank Bipartisan Policy Center (BPC(, call it a 'magic trick'.
Using the calculation method, the Senate Republicans' budget bill appears to cost substantially less and seems to save $500bn (R8.9-trillion) according to the BPC analysis.
If the Senate passes the bill, it will then return to the House of Representatives for final passage before Trump can sign it into law. The House passed its version of the bill last month.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
TimesLIVE
25 minutes ago
- TimesLIVE
Why it's a good time to buy wine
South Africa's producers are not inured to these worldwide trends. First, the domestic market is shrinking — hardly a surprise given the stagnant economy — while exports are not taking up the surplus. On the contrary, Trump's tariffs will have a significant impact on our wineries. In 2023 the US was our fourth largest international market for bottled wine — this at a time when we had the full Agoa benefit. It's a fair assumption that most, if not all, this wine will need to find a new home. Given the decline in consumption in most of the established markets, this won't be easy. Champagne — probably the strongest and most recognised of categories — has shed 20% of its volumes in the past two years. In many ways it is a bellwether of all that is happening in the world of wine. No-one feels like celebrating when the world is in a mess, to paraphrase a remark made by a leading producer. Then there's the problem of fewer people drinking wine, and drinking less of it, whether because they don't have the money or don't regard it as an essential purchase or because the legalisation of marijuana has hijacked that portion of their household budget. There's no easy solution to this growing stock overhang: grubbing up vineyards is a last resort because of the high cost of replacing them and because often there's no obvious replacement crop. So it may be that the producers who survive are those who reduce prices first and with the deepest cuts. For consumers with a little disposable income, there might never be a better time to go shopping.
TimesLIVE
an hour ago
- TimesLIVE
Modi faces opposition fury after Trump's 25% tariff threat
Indian opposition parties criticised the government on Thursday, describing US President Donald Trump's threat of a 25% tariff as a diplomatic failure for New Delhi, while the rupee tumbled and equity indices slid in response to the news. The 25% rate would single out India more harshly than other major trading partners and threatens to unravel months of talks, undermining one of Washington's strategic partners in the region, viewed as a counterbalance to China. Trump said the tariff on goods imports from India would start from Friday, in addition to an unspecified penalty for Russian dealings and involvement in the Brics grouping of nations, but added later that trade talks continued. In response, the government of Prime Minister Narendra Modi said it was studying the implications of Trump's remarks and was dedicated to securing a fair trade deal. 'This development reflects a broader collapse of foreign policy under the Modi government,' a legislator of the main opposition Congress said in a notice asking for a discussion of the matter in the lower house. The debate would focus on the 'government's economic and diplomatic failure in preventing the imposition of 25% US tariffs plus penalties on Indian exports,' it added. Commerce minister Piyush Goyal is expected to brief the lower house later on Thursday, TV news channels said. Economists warned the steep tariff could hurt India's manufacturing ambitions and trim up to 40 basis points from economic growth in the financial year to March 2026. India's benchmark equity indices, the Nifty 50 and BSE Sensex, fell about 0.6% each, while the rupee declined to 87.74, its lowest in more than five months, before paring losses. India has received a 'raw deal', said Priyanka Kishore, an economist at Asia Decoded. 'While further trade talks may bring the tariff rate down, it appears unlikely that India will secure a significantly better outcome than its eastern neighbours,' she added.
TimesLIVE
2 hours ago
- TimesLIVE
US hits Iranian shipping network with major new sanctions
The US Treasury department announced fresh sanctions on Wednesday against more than 115 Iran-linked individuals, entities and vessels, in a sign the Trump administration is doubling down on its 'maximum pressure' campaign after bombing Tehran's key nuclear sites in June. The sanctions broadly target the shipping interests of Mohammad Hossein Shamkhani, the son of Ali Shamkhani, who is an adviser to Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei. The US Treasury said it was the most significant Iran-related sanctions action since 2018, during President Donald Trump's first administration. According to the Treasury, Shamkhani controls a vast network of container ships and tankers through a complex web of intermediaries that sell Iranian and Russian oil and other goods throughout the world. Treasury accused Shamkhani of using personal connections and corruption in Tehran to generate tens of billions of dollars in profits, much of which is used to prop up the Iranian regime. Overall, the new sanctions target 15 shipping firms, 52 vessels, 12 individuals and 53 entities involved in sanctions evasion in 17 countries, ranging from Panama to Italy to Hong Kong. A US official said the new sanctions would make it 'much more difficult' for Iran to sell its oil, but added that the administration did not anticipate any sustained disruption to global oil markets.
