Legal proceedings initiated over cancelled social housing
Mr Browne said legal documents were received by the department on Friday in relation to legal proceedings over the Social Housing Public Private Partnership (PPP) Bundle 3 project.
The project involved the delivery of around 486 social homes across six sites in Dublin, Wicklow, Kildare and Sligo.
However, the Department of Housing decided not to proceed with the homes due to value for money concerns.
Social Democrats TD Rory Hearne raised the issue at the Oireachtas Committee on Housing this afternoon, asking the minister if he was aware that legal proceedings had been initiated by the preferred bidder for the project.
Mr Browne initially said he was not personally aware of any legal proceedings against his department.
However, he later said department officials had made inquiries and clarified that legal proceedings had indeed been initiated.
"My department was notified of it. I wasn't aware of that, but I can confirm that legal documents were received by my department in relation to the judicial review proceedings in relation to the PPP project.
"If I was aware of it, I wouldn't have made some of my comments earlier, because with legal proceedings hadn't commenced, it was not appropriate for me to make any comment in relation to matters under legal proceedings.
"But perhaps, just like my legal background and my commentary might indicate, I actually was not aware of it," Mr Browne told the committee.
Earlier, Mr Hearne told reporters that the legal threat could result in High Court action and had the potential to further delay related projects.
He said: "I was speaking to Dublin City Council officials yesterday, you will remember we've been raising concerns about the collapse of the PPP projects which are in a number of constituencies from Wicklow to Sligo to Dublin.
"We found out yesterday that it is our understanding that the preferred bidder in the PPP is taking the Department of Housing to the High Court to challenge these projects.
"Now, what that is likely to mean, we understand from the meeting, is that these projects are unlikely to proceed in other avenues being tendered even though they have planning permission.
"This is an absolute mess.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Journal
29 minutes ago
- The Journal
Department of Housing did not consult with tenants on plans to shrink minimum apartment sizes
THIS MORNING, THE government signed off on plans to drastically reduce the minimum standards for apartments in a bid to boost supply. Under the changes, which take effect immediately, the minimum size of a studio apartment will be reduced from 37 sq m to 32 sq m, while developers will no longer have to provide a mix of unit sizes in apartment blocks. Fewer windows and balconies will also be required, while a requirement to have indoor 'communal, community and cultural facilities' has been scrapped. The Department of Housing did not consult with tenant organisations, homeowner organisations or members of the public ahead of the changes. It is understood the changes were kept under wraps due to the fact that they were 'extremely commercially sensitive' and may have led to developers pausing building that is currently underway ahead of the changes being confirmed. As part of the changes signed off today, a rule that required that half of apartments in a development be somewhat bigger than the minimum standard has been reduced to 25 per cent. While another rule that required half of apartments in suburban developments and 33 per cent of apartments in urban developments to be 'dual aspect' (which means having windows that can be opened on at least two walls) has now been reduced to 25 per cent in all settings. Housing Minister James Browne said the changes come in an effort to unblock blockages in apartment delivery. He said he wants to clear away red tape and address 'viability issues', which he blames on delays in the housing system. Advertisement 'We are taking decisive action, without compromising on any essential regulations, to ensure apartments are viable to build,' he said. Speaking on his way into Cabinet this morning, the minister said apartment delivery in Dublin has 'collapsed'. 'We've looked at the housing delivery from last year, it was certainly lower than we hoped, lower than we expected, and it was very disappointing,' he added, arguing that the government has tied itself in 'regulatory knots' in recent years. Department officials believe the changes announced today could lead to a cost reduction of between €50,000 and €100,000 per apartment. It was also confirmed today that apartment buildings that have already received planning permission but are not yet complete will not have to be sent back to the beginning of the planning process if they wish to tweak their designs to align with the new rules. Reacting to the new rules, Sinn Féin's housing spokesperson Eoin Ó Broin said they prove that the government has been 'captured by the institutional investor lobby'. 'This policy was tried and tested in 2018 by then Fine Gael Housing Minister, Eoghan Murphy. It was such a disaster that Darragh O'Brien reversed it in 2022. 'That government is reintroducing it again now shows the absolute poverty of ideas from Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael when it comes to housing,' he said. Meanwhile, Social Democrats housing spokesperson Rory Hearne said the changes would allow developers to build 'glorified shoeboxes'. 'It will only result in increased profits for developers – and unaffordable apartments that nobody wants to live in,' he said. Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone... A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article. Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation. Learn More Support The Journal
Irish Times
44 minutes ago
- Irish Times
Legal proceedings initiated against Department of Housing after pulling out of PPP deal in ‘11th hour'
Legal proceedings have been initiated against the Department of Housing after it pulled out of a public-private partnership (PPP) agreement at the 'eleventh hour' over value for money concerns, an Oireachtas committee has heard. Last month, the department pulled out of the PPP projects in which a private investment consortium was to deliver almost 500 social homes in Dublin, Kildare, Sligo and Wicklow. The decision was made on a 'value for money basis,' according to the department. Minister for Housing James Browne initially told committee members on Tuesday he was not aware of any legal proceedings. However, he was later informed by department officials that a judicial review had been lodged. Social Democrats housing spokesman Rory Hearne, who initially asked the Minister whether the preferred bidder for the PPP projects had initiated legal proceedings, said it was 'jaw-dropping' that Mr Browne was unaware. READ MORE While believing PPP 'has a role to play', Mr Browne, who would not speak further on the legal proceedings, said it must be 'completely overhauled and re-examined'. 'It is an important route to be able to get homes that we need in the country but it has to be done in a manner that is fair to the taxpayer as well as giving value for money for the taxpayer,' he said. Labour TD Conor Sheehan said the cancellation of the PPP projects at the 'eleventh hour' has made the delivery route 'essentially unviable.' Separately, Mr Browne told committee members that it will be 'exceptionally difficult' to meet housing targets in 2025. Mr Browne said that while there was a significant increase in commencement notices last year, there was a sense that developers 'turned their attention to further commencements as opposed to finalising the projects they were working on at that time.' Some 60,000 commencement notices were lodged last year, an increase of 84 per cent from the year prior. This was driven largely by temporary development levies introduced to stimulate housing construction. Mr Browne said there has been a consistent level of housing delivery predictions this year from different bodies 'in and around the low 30,000s mark'. 'When you see that level of consistency, it's difficult to disagree with. Certainly, it will be exceptionally difficult to meet our own target that was set out for this year coming from such a low base,' he said. Several committee members also raised concerns over new design standards for apartments , with Sinn Féin housing spokesman Eoin Ó Broin saying they will allow for 'smaller, darker apartments with less amenities in sub-optimally planned residential developments'. Several questioned how the changes would result in cost reductions of between €50,000 and €100,000 per unit, a claim made by Mr Browne earlier on Tuesday, with Mr Ó'Broin saying he did not believe such a reduction was possible. Mr Browne said the cost reductions will be made possible by the 'significant increase' in the number of units that can be 'put on to the one box unit.' The Minister said he would publish data concerning the projected cost reductions 'in the near future.'
Irish Examiner
2 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Independent Ireland TD under fire for 'fuelling racism' with comments on 'protecting' Irish culture
An Independent Ireland TD has been lambasted for comments that Irish people could become a 'minority' in the years ahead, with some describing the comments as a 'dog whistle'. Limerick TD Richard O'Donoghue was speaking in reference to the upcoming presidential election, when asked who Independent Ireland might support as a candidate. 'We want someone who will represent our culture in this country, that it's not obliterated,' Mr O'Donoghue said. 'We welcome other cultures in here, we do that 100%. But we also want to make sure the Irish culture is recognised and set in stone for the future.' Pressed on what he meant, Mr O'Donoghue referred to Irish people respecting the cultures of other countries when they travel abroad. My son and his girlfriend went to Dubai, and the culture out there is that you cannot enter one of their mosques or whatever unless you are covered up...I want us protected the same way as we recognise other people's culture when we go to their country. The comments were branded as a 'dog whistle' and 'untrue' by other opposition TDs, with the Social Democrat's Jennifer Whitmore rejecting them outright. 'It's fuelling racism, it's fuelling misinformation. It's fuelling a narrative out there that people are coming into this country and are not contributing, which is wrong,' Ms Whitmore said. Social Democrats TD Gary Gannon described Mr O'Donoghue's comments as 'pathetic', while Rory Hearne said his comments were 'dangerous'. We're seeing the real rise of the far right and sowing of division in communities, particularly around the housing issue. These comments have very real impacts in communities. People Before Profit's Paul Murphy said it was 'dog whistling' by Independent Ireland, saying the comments were inappropriate. When contacted by the Irish Examiner, Mr O'Donoghue doubled down on his comments around Irish people becoming the minority, saying it could happen by 2050. He cited comments from then president of DCU Ferdinand von Prondzynski, who made the claim in 2005. Mr von Prondzynski cited unpublished UK-based research at the time, which was not identified. However, Mr O'Donoghue rejected any assertions by the opposition that he was a racist. "Under no circumstances am I a racist. I'm actually the opposite," Mr O'Donoghue said.
