Is Indoor or Outdoor Cycling a Better Workout? The Health Benefits Differ, Experts Say
And while indoor and outdoor cycling are both healthy forms of exercise, they provide some different health benefits. And one may align with your goals and preferences more than the other.
"They're both excellent sources of cardiovascular training," Dr. Jeffrey Fleming, a primary care sports medicine physician at the University of Pittsburgh Medical Center, tells TODAY.com, especially when it comes to increasing your cardiovascular endurance.
Indoor and outdoor cycling are also great for strengthening your legs and glutes, he says. "So, for those looking for both resistance training and cardiovascular training, (cycling is) a nice mix of the two," Fleming adds.
But the setting matters when it comes to cycling. And there are different health benefits whether you're pumping up the resistance in an air-conditioned spin class or taking the hills as they come on a tree-lined trail.
Benefits of Cycling Outside
Whether you're biking inside or outdoors, "the leg movements are essentially identical," Chris Barucci, a physical therapist and certified strength and conditioning specialist at the Boston University Physical Therapy Center, tells TODAY.com.
But outdoor cycling offers some unique benefits over indoor cycling. That includes "mental stimulation, exposure to nature and balance and handling challenges," Barucci says.
Riding outside is naturally more varied in slope and speed, and "the variability itself can be an advantage," Fleming says. "You have to react to the environment that you're right riding on in real time."
And simply being outdoors, whether you're on a trail or on your morning commute, "can have some positive effects psychologically," Fleming says.
Benefits of Indoor Cycling
Indoor cycling, also called spinning, has its own set of unique advantages.
A stationary bike allows you to precisely control your resistance and speed. That means it's generally safer than riding outdoors on unpredictable surfaces, the experts say.
"Indoor cycling removes a lot of the risks associated with outdoor cycling," Barucci notes. "Indoor riders don't have to worry about weather conditions, road conditions, motor vehicles, pedestrians or other cyclists," he says.
Additionally, indoor biking is better for those with "balance or reaction time issues, if they are recovering from an injury and if they don't live in an area that allows for safe biking," Barucci says.
The control a stationary bike gives you is also great for maximizing your workout's efficiency and burning a lot of calories in a relatively short amount of time, Fleming says.
Plus, there's the convenience factor: "An indoor bike can safely be used any time of day that it is available, where outdoor riding at night presents some safety challenges," Barucci says.
And, even though you're not cycling outside, spinning can offer its own set of psychological benefits to those who enjoy it, Barucci notes. Some people really value having time to watch or listen to something while spinning, while others appreciate the community of a Peloton ride or spin class.
Should You Do Indoor Cycling or Outdoor Cycling?
Mechanically, riding an indoor bike or cycling outside are very similar, the experts say. You'll generally work the same muscles, and both activities will provide an efficient cardiovascular workout.
So, if you're choosing between indoor and outdoor cycling, think about your goals and any conditions or injuries you may be dealing with.
Those who are looking for an efficient, convenient workout they can do pretty much any time without worrying about weather should opt for indoor cycling. The same is true for anyone who has issues with balance or reaction time. And if you're hungry for social connection while working out, give an indoor cycling class a try either in person or virtually via an app.
On the other hand, folks who prefer to be out in nature and welcome the "excitement and thrill" that comes with the variability of a trail would do better with outdoor cycling, Barucci says. And you don't have to ride alone, he adds, as there are cycling groups you can join all over the place.
Keep in mind that riding outside can be less predictable than spinning, and comes with some safety hazards like bad weather and traffic.
Of course, the two activities are not mutually exclusive. Many outdoor riders also enjoy indoor cycling when the weather isn't playing along, for instance. Either way, know that you can pedal your way to better physical and mental health.
This article was originally published on TODAY.com
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CNET
20 minutes ago
- CNET
Is Trump's Chronic Venous Insufficiency Diagnosis Actually 'Benign'? A Vein Specialist Weighs In
Last Thursday, July 17, the White House announced that President Trump was diagnosed with chronic venous insufficiency (CVI). According to a memo from Dr. Sean P. Barbabella, the president's physician, this diagnosis came after the president noticed mild swelling in his legs. However, Barbabella reports that CVI is "benign" and common in older adults over the age of 70. Trump is 79. Though the doctor's memo summarized that "President Trump remains in excellent health," we were curious to learn more about CVI and whether or not it's as benign as it's being made out to be. For that information, we contacted Khanh Nguyen, DO, chief medical officer of the Center for Vein Restoration. What is chronic venous insufficiency? Plus, CVI causes Chronic venous insufficiency is when your legs' veins don't work as well as they should. "Normally, veins have small valves that help keep blood flowing back up toward the heart," explains Nguyen. "But if those valves become weak or damaged, blood can start to pool in the legs instead of moving upward like it should." The most common causes of CVI, according to Nguyen, are: Aging : "As we get older, our veins and valves naturally weaken." : "As we get older, our veins and valves naturally weaken." Family history : "If close family members have vein problems, you're more likely to develop them, too. Genetics play a significant role in developing venous disease." : "If close family members have vein problems, you're more likely to develop them, too. Genetics play a significant role in developing venous disease." Being overweight : "Extra weight puts more pressure on the veins in your legs." : "Extra weight puts more pressure on the veins in your legs." Sitting or standing for long periods : "This makes it harder for blood to move out of the legs, especially without movement. Blood is constantly fighting against gravity to return to the heart, so walking and activating the calf muscle helps the blood to be pumped back." : "This makes it harder for blood to move out of the legs, especially without movement. Blood is constantly fighting against gravity to return to the heart, so walking and activating the calf muscle helps the blood to be pumped back." Pregnancy : "Increased blood volume and hormone changes can put a strain on the venous system. In addition, the enlarged fetus and uterus also put pressure on the abdomen and pelvis, compressing the veins and impeding blood return, further increasing venous hypertension." : "Increased blood volume and hormone changes can put a strain on the venous system. In addition, the enlarged fetus and uterus also put pressure on the abdomen and pelvis, compressing the veins and impeding blood return, further increasing venous hypertension." Previous blood clots: "A history of deep vein thrombosis (DVT) can damage vein valves and puts a patient at higher risk for developing venous disease." DVT occurs when a blood clot forms in one or more of the body's deep veins, typically in the legs. These various factors can cause an increase in pressure in the leg veins over time, contributing to venous insufficiency. However, Nguyen states that early treatment and lifestyle changes can help manage symptoms and prevent worsening conditions. Chronic venous insufficiency symptoms While CVI symptoms can vary, Nguyen lists common ones as: leg swelling, heaviness, aching, throbbing, restless legs and cramping. Many patients also notice varicose veins and skin changes like darkening or itching around the ankles. In advanced cases, you may even see venous ulcers or open wounds near the lower legs. "Symptoms often worsen after prolonged periods of standing or sitting and improve with leg elevation and the use of compression stockings," states Nguyen. PonyWang/Getty Images Is it true that chronic venous insufficiency is 'benign'? Though Dr. Sean P. Barbabella, Trump's doctor, claims CVI is "benign," Nguyen says that's not the full picture. "While CVI is often labeled 'benign' because it's not life-threatening like arterial disease, it's not a harmless condition," he says. "Left untreated, it can significantly impact quality of life and lead to complications like chronic pain, skin changes, venous ulcers and potentially blood clots." In other words, chronic venous insufficiency isn't something you should ignore. "It's a medical issue that warrants expert attention and treatment, particularly because early intervention can help prevent its progression," Nguyen explains. How is chronic venous insufficiency diagnosed? "CVI is typically diagnosed by taking a thorough history and performing a physical examination followed by a duplex ultrasound, a noninvasive imaging test that visualizes blood flow and evaluates the function of the veins and their valves," says Nguyen. This test allows doctors to confirm venous reflux (when veins struggle to circulate blood back to the heart) and rule out other conditions like deep vein thrombosis. How is chronic venous insufficiency treated? Nguyen reports that CVI is treated with a combination of the following: compression therapy, lifestyle changes and minimally invasive procedures that close off or redirect blood flow from malfunctioning veins. "Today's advanced outpatient treatments typically take under an hour to complete, require little to no downtime, and are covered by insurance when medically necessary," he explains. "Patients can return to their normal routine immediately, with few restrictions." Early CVI diagnosis and treatment are key According to Nguyen, one of the biggest challenges with CVI is that people ignore early symptoms, writing them off as fatigue or aging. This is especially concerning because CVI is treatable, thanks to modern therapies that are effective, safe and fast. "If you're experiencing leg discomfort, swelling or visible veins, don't wait -- early diagnosis and treatment can make a tremendous difference in your longterm leg health and comfort," concludes Nguyen.
CNN
21 minutes ago
- CNN
Is Frozen Produce Healthier Than Fresh? - Chasing Life with Dr. Sanjay Gupta - Podcast on CNN Podcasts
Dr. Sanjay Gupta 00:00:03 Welcome to Paging Dr. Gupta. As you know, this podcast is one of my favorite podcasts because the best health conversations that I've heard often start with simple, honest questions. And that's what we try and address here each week. Kyra's back with us. What do we have first? Kyra Dahring 00:00:23 So first up today, this listener has a question sparked by a recent Chasing Life episode. And honestly, it kind of has me thinking back to that conversation too. Take a listen. Listener Question 00:00:35 I am following up on your episode with Dr. Tim Spector and he talks about 30 vegetables. What would be those 30 vegetables? And are frozen vegetables just as good as fresh vegetables? I've heard that they're better, hold their nutrients, vitamins, etc. Thank you. I look forward to hearing a podcast answering these questions. Dr. Sanjay Gupta 00:01:01 This is a really good question, are frozen vegetables actually healthy, or are they just plan B when fresh isn't available? I'm going to tell you the answer to that, plus really dig into what Dr. Spector meant about 30 vegetables right after this quick break. Dr. Sanjay Gupta 00:01:20 Okay, let's start with the 30 vegetable part of this. Here is a quick refresher of that Chasing Life episode with Dr. Tim Spector... Dr. Tim Spector 00:01:29 What I'm trying to do is give myself the room so I can have 30 different plants during my week. And that's that diversity of plants, which I think is probably the most crucial rule for nutrition. Dr. Sanjay Gupta 00:01:42 'Okay, so what does that mean? First of all, it does not mean you need to eat 30 vegetables a week. What he's really saying is try to eat thirty different plant-based foods each week. That could include vegetables, yes, but also fruits, whole grains, nuts, seeds, legumes, herbs, even some spices. So spinach and kale, for example, that's two. Apples and bananas, that is two more. Lentils, chia, garlic, turmeric, all of it counts. What we're getting at is this idea that really comes from the American Gut Project, which found that people who ate 30 or more different plants a week have more diverse gut bacteria. And that's linked to better digestion, less inflammation, and stronger immunity. So yeah, you want to eat a variety of foods. Again, it doesn't mean 30 different vegetables, but just think about plant-based foods and incorporating at least 30 different plant-based foods into your diet every week. It's not that hard to do. It's important to do, but not enough people do it. Now, onto frozen vegetables. So the short answer to your question, yes frozen veggies are a healthy choice. In many cases, they're just as nutritious as fresh vegetables, and sometimes, importantly, even more so. Here's why: vegetables meant for freezing are picked at their peak ripeness. That's when they're most nutrient rich. They are then typically blanched, which means they are briefly dipped in hot water to stop spoilage, and then they are flash frozen. And that's what locks in most of their nutrients. Now it is true that some heat-sensitive nutrients like vitamin C, that may dip slightly during the blanching process. But overall, studies have shown frozen vegetables, frozen veggies, have nutrient levels that are very similar to fresh and sometimes even higher. Especially if that fresh produce has been sitting around for days. Now, another key point here, frozen veggies are actually really good at holding onto their nutrients. Fresh produce starts losing vitamins the moment they are picked and continues to lose them in transport and storage in your refrigerator. Frozen vegetables don't keep losing nutrients the way fresh ones do. So, frozen vegetables, they're a win. In so many ways, including cost and convenience and variety. They last longer. They're often more affordable, and they can help you get to that 30 plant-based foods a week, even when something's out of season. Do check the labels. Some frozen veggies come with sauces, and that can add a lot of stuff you don't want, unneeded fat and sodium and preservatives. When you're cooking your veggies from frozen, go for lightly steaming or microwaving. Why? To help preserve the nutrients and the texture. There's no need to thaw first. And finally, a simple trick, add a squeeze of lemon after cooking to brighten flavor and also add a little bit of that vitamin C back in that I was talking about earlier. Bottom line, whether your vegetables are fresh or frozen, the goal is imperfection, it's variety. Keep it colorful, mix it up, and yes, frozen definitely counts. Now, coming up. It's become quite popular and makes some pretty remarkable health promises, but what does pink Himalayan salt actually do for you? We have that in just a moment. Dr. Sanjay Gupta 00:05:17 All right, Kyra, what do we have next? Kyra Dahring 00:05:19 Yes, we got this next question from a listener who is wondering about a health trend that some of us might have seen on social media. Here's what she asked. Listener Fran 00:05:28 Hi, my name is Fran and I'm 70 years old. I am calling in to find out about all the studies on pink Himalayan salt. There are people that drink Himalayan salt with lemon water in the morning and what it's good for. Dr. Sanjay Gupta 00:05:44 'Okay Fran, thank you so much for your question about pink Himalayan salt. It's definitely popular right now. I think we have some sitting in our own kitchen. Interestingly the salt primarily comes from a mine in Pakistan near but not in the Himalayas. The pink color comes from trace minerals like iron, calcium, potassium, and magnesium, which some people think makes it healthier than regular table salt. Just a side note by the way, sea salt also contains many of these same minerals. And sure, pink Himalayan salt tends to be less processed than table salt, which is refined, table salt is to remove impurities, they may contain anti-caking agents as well in table salt and oftentimes it's fortified with iodine, a micronutrient that is essential to human health and wellbeing. But here's the thing, those extra minerals that we're talking about in pink Himalayan salt, those minerals that are often at the root of a lot of these health claims. They're really only present in tiny trace amounts, too small to really have any health impact unless you're consuming unrealistic quantities and you shouldn't do that because it's salt and we eat too much salt already. Additionally, many of the minerals that are in pink Himalayan salt in those trace amounts are actually easily obtained from other healthy foods. Now, some of the health claims you may have heard about pink Himalyan salt, improves sleep, balances your body's pH, boosts energy. But the truth is, there's little scientific evidence to support those specific benefits. Now, to be fair, it'd be really hard to do a study like that, but there just isn't the scientific data to support these claims. Now, this idea about adding it to water. That is actually a trend people are doing. It's called sole, sole water. It's made by adding pink salt dissolved in water and often consumed with lemon. People say that it boosts energy, it detoxifies the body, but again, there's not solid science behind those claims. What is important to know again, is that most people already consume way more sodium than they need. So drinking sole water just adds even more sodium into your diet, which can actually have risks, high blood pressure, kidney issues. So bottom line, is pink Himalayan salt better than regular salt? Not really. It's a fine natural option if you prefer it, but it doesn't offer any proven meaningful health advantages, and it does tend to cost more. Plus, as I mentioned, it typically does not contain added iodine, which is really important to your health. So if you're using pink Himalayan salt exclusively, do make sure you're getting your iodine from foods like seafood or dairy or seaweed. In the end, whatever salt you choose, it is still salt. Moderation is key. Hope that helps, Fran! Dr. Sanjay Gupta 00:08:41 'And thanks to everyone who sent in questions, your curiosity, your stories, your voices, I love hearing it, and that's what brings this show to life. So keep it coming. If there's something health-related you've been wondering about, send it to us. We might answer it next week! Record a voice memo, email it to AskSanjay@ or give us a call, 470-396-0832 and leave a message. Thanks for listening. I'll be back next Tuesday.
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
AstraZeneca pledges $50bn US investment ahead of drugs tariffs
British pharmaceuticals giant AstraZeneca has revealed it plans to invest $50 billion (£37 billion) in America over the next five years. The commitment came only a week ahead of expected confirmation from Donald Trump of swingeing tariffs of up to 200% on imported drugs The investment will be made in medicines manufacturing and R&D, and create tens of thousands of high skilled jobs, the Cambridge based company said. By 2030 half the company's expected $80 billion of revenues will be generated in the USA. The investments will include a new multi-billion dollar drug substance manufacturing centre focused on chronic diseases in Virginia. It will be the company's biggest commitment to a single facility anywhere in the world. It will produce drug substances for the company's weight management and metabolic portfolio, including oral GLP-1, baxdrostat, oral PCSK9 and combination small molecule products. The $50 billion investment also includes: Expansion of an R&D facility in Gaithersburg, Maryland; an R&D centre in Kendall Square, Cambridge, Massachusetts; manufacturing facilities for cell therapy in Rockville, Maryland and Tarzana, California; continuous manufacturing expansion in Mount Vernon, Indiana; and specialty manufacturing expansion in Coppell, Texas Howard Lutnick, US Secretary of Commerce, said: "For decades Americans have been reliant on foreign supply of key pharmaceutical products. President Trump and our nation's new tariff policies are focused on ending this structural weakness. 'We are proud that AstraZeneca has made the decision to bring substantial pharmaceutical production to our shores. This historic investment is bringing tens of thousands of jobs to the US and will ensure medicine sold in our country is produced right here." Governor Glenn Youngkin, Commonwealth of Virginia, said: "I want to thank AstraZeneca for choosing Virginia as the cornerstone for this transformational investment in the United States. 'This project will set the standard for the latest technological advancements in pharmaceutical manufacturing, creating hundreds of highly skilled jobs and helping further strengthen the nation's domestic supply chain. 'Advanced manufacturing is at the heart of Virginia's dynamic economy, so I am thrilled that AstraZeneca, one of the world's leading pharmaceutical companies, plans to make their largest global manufacturing investment here in the Commonwealth." Pascal Soriot, CEO, AstraZeneca, said: "Today's announcement underpins our belief in America's innovation in biopharmaceuticals and our commitment to the millions of patients who need our medicines in America and globally." The US is AstraZeneca's largest market and home to 19 R&D, manufacturing and commercial sites. The company employs more than 18,000 people and support 92,000 jobs across the United States. The US represents 42% of total revenue. Error in retrieving data Sign in to access your portfolio Error in retrieving data
