Birkenstock cracks down on fakes in India, court-ordered factory visits held, sources say
Birkenstock's case is occurring around the same time other shoemakers are in the news in India. Crocs this month secured a court nod to pursue a nine-year-old infringement case, while Prada is facing heat over showcasing sandals similar to ethnic Indian footwear without initially giving credit to India.
Reuters is first to report the Indian case details related to Birkenstock sandals, which have evolved from a counterculture symbol to a trendy fashion item, and are also popular in India.
In May, Birkenstock filed an infringement lawsuit in the Delhi High Court against four footwear traders, four factories and two unnamed individuals. Its complaint stated an internal investigation found counterfeits were being made in rural areas in and around the tourist hub of Agra, and sold locally and exported to other countries.
On May 26, Delhi judge Saurabh Banerjee issued a confidential order that was only made public on the court's website last week. It said 10 local lawyers were appointed as commissioners to visit the suspected factories.
The judge said commissioners can "seize, pack and seal the infringing products", and his order included photographs that Birkenstock submitted showing the alleged counterfeit footwear and shoe boxes with the company's branding.
The visits have been completed and reports were submitted confidentially to the judge, the three people familiar with the matter said on Saturday, asking to remain unidentified. The next hearing in the case is set for October 6.
The visits were conducted in Agra, home to the Taj Mahal, and in India's capital New Delhi, the people said, declining to give further details from their inspection.
Birkenstock did not respond to queries from Reuters and its lawyers from Delhi-based law firm Lall and Sethi declined to comment, citing the pending legal case.
In his May order, Banerjee said he reviewed photographs and samples of the alleged counterfeit products in court, and they "seem like a cheap knock off" of Birkenstock products.
"There is all likelihood of the public getting deceived ... The differences, hardly if any, are not something which can be discernable to the naked eyes," he wrote.
Once popular with hippies, tech enthusiasts and medical professionals, Birkenstock gained widespread attention after Australian actress Margot Robbie wore a pair of pink Birkenstocks in the final scene of the 2023 hit movie "Barbie".
In February, a German court said Birkenstock sandals do not qualify as art and are therefore not protected by copyright, dismissing a lawsuit brought by the German company.
In India, Birkenstock footwear for women is priced between $46 and $233.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Khaleej Times
an hour ago
- Khaleej Times
India: CBI cracks down on cybercrime syndicate scamming UK, Australian citizens
India's Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) has cracked down on a transnational cybercrime syndicate running a sophisticated tech support scam targeting citizens of the United Kingdom and Australia, as part of their Operation Chakra-V. The syndicate's call centre was operating under the name FirstIdea. The key operative partner of FirstIdea has been arrested, the CBI said in a statement. The syndicate posed as technical support staff of reputed multinational companies, including Microsoft. The fraudsters were cheating foreign nationals by falsely claiming that their devices were compromised, and extorted money under the guise of resolving non-existent technical issues. The CBI collaborated closely with the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI), National Crime Agency (UK), and Microsoft Corporation, to trace the syndicate's operations and locations. Searches were carried out at three locations in Noida, Uttar Pradesh, including at a fully functional fraudulent call centre operating from the Noida Special Economic Zone. The operation was meticulously timed with the time zones of the victims, resulting in the detection of live scam calls in progress during the raids, the CBI said in a statement. During the searches, the CBI seized extensive evidence, including advanced calling infrastructure, malicious scripts used to deceive victims, and documents revealing the scale of the fraud and extortion. Firstldea, was found to be technologically sophisticated, enabling cross-border anonymity and large-scale victim targeting. The arrested partner is being produced before the Special CBI Court today, July 8.
Khaleej Times
3 hours ago
- Khaleej Times
UAE: Indian family seeks answers after engineer son dies aboard Sharjah vessel
Those were the final words Anurag Tiwari said to his father during a video call on the evening of June 28. The next morning, the 33-year-old marine engineer from Lucknow left Dubai for Sharjah to board the commercial vessel Jana 505, where he was to begin a new assignment. Before the day was over, the family received the devastating news: Anurag was dead. His father, Anil Tiwari, recounted their last exchange. Speaking to Khaleej Times from his home, he said he had messaged Anurag 'Best of luck' at 4am India time (2.30am UAE time) on June 29. Stay up to date with the latest news. Follow KT on WhatsApp Channels. 'He responded immediately, so I knew he was awake and probably preparing to leave. I didn't call then,' he said. 'But when I tried (to call) at 7am and got no reply, I assumed he was busy. Later, when even my messages went unanswered, I thought it must be a network issue.' At 9.38pm, the family received a call informing them that Anurag was no more. What happened at the ship? According to an email from the Mumbai-based placement agency, Avishka Shipping Pvt Ltd (ASPL), Anurag was found unconscious in the ship's engine room. CPR was administered, and he was transported by crew boat to the port, but emergency responders found no pulse during the ECG. A preliminary forensic report cited heatstroke leading to multi-organ failure as the cause of death. Khaleej Times contacted Avishka Shipping Pvt Ltd through email and phone calls. No response was received at the time of publication. The family was not convinced, saying that the official explanation has not addressed their concerns. They are now calling for an independent investigation into the circumstances of Anurag's death. Anil questioned why his son was allegedly sent alone into the engine room, a task he claims should have been carried out in teams. 'Anurag had clearly told us that no one would go in alone. The job was to be done together. Then why was he by himself?' The family also believes that critical safety procedures may not have been followed. 'The SOP clearly warns about toxic gases, and the area was supposed to be ventilated before anyone entered,' Anil said. He added that the sequence of events remains unclear. 'There's no timeline: when exactly he was sent to the engine room, who found him, or what immediate medical aid was provided. None of that has been shared with us.' Anil also questioned the emergency response. 'If he was still breathing but unconscious, why was CPR performed? That's generally done when the heart stops. We just want honest answers.' 'A serious discrepancy' Anurag had joined the crew in Dubai on June 19. He was working as a third engineer for Singapore-headquartered Synergy Ship Arabia, which was overseeing the commissioning of Jana 505, a jack-up vessel owned by a Saudi conglomerate. In a letter to the family, ASPL's general manager stated that Anurag collapsed during offloading operations and was found in the engine room. However, Anil said they were initially told that his son had fainted on the deck. 'That's a serious discrepancy. The deck and the engine room are entirely different locations.' The Indian Consulate in Dubai, responding to Khaleej Times said: 'The Consulate was in constant touch with the bereaved family and extended all possible assistance for the repatriation of the mortal remains.' Anurag's body arrived in Lucknow on July 5 and was cremated that evening. At home, the grief is still raw. 'My wife and daughter-in-law have fainted twice. They are inconsolable,' Anil said. 'His three-year-old son keeps asking for him. As if he senses something.' A life full of promise Anurag had recently purchased a car and was planning to pursue an academic course in shipping in the UK after completing this assignment. 'He had dreams. He was working hard for his family,' Anil said. 'Now we're left with heartbreak, silence, and questions.' The family is urging UAE authorities to conduct a thorough inquiry, including a toxicology report. 'We request that his blood samples be examined for signs of toxic gas inhalation,' Anil said. 'A proper investigation must be conducted to identify what went wrong and who may be responsible. A life was lost, and a 30-year-old wife, a three-year-old child, and elderly parents were left shattered," he added.
Khaleej Times
4 hours ago
- Khaleej Times
Indian villagers beat five to death for 'witchcraft' in northern state of Bihar
Indian villagers beat a family of five to death and dumped their corpses in a lake accusing them of "practising witchcraft" after the death of a boy, police said on Tuesday. Three people have been arrested and have confessed to the crime, police in the northern state of Bihar said in a statement. Three women -- including a 75-year-old -- were among those murdered. The main accused believed that his son's recent death was caused by one of those killed, and blamed "him and his family of practising witchcraft", the statement said. "After beating the victims to death, the perpetrators loaded the bodies onto a tractor and dumped them in a pond," police said. The murderers and victims all belonged to India's Oraon tribe in Bihar, India's poorest state and a mainly Hindu region of at least 130 million people. Despite campaigns against superstition, belief in witchcraft remains widespread in rural areas across India, especially in isolated tribal communities. Some states, including Bihar, have introduced laws to try to curb crimes against people accused of witchcraft and superstition. Women have often been branded witches and targeted, but the killing of the family of five stands out as a particularly heinous recent example. More than 1,500 people -- the overwhelming majority of them women -- were killed in India on suspicion of witchcraft between 2010 and 2021, according to the National Crime Records Bureau. Some believe in the occult, but attackers also sometimes have other motives including usurping their rights over land and property.
