Optometrists refuse to treat urgent cases over fee dispute with province
Since March, the optometrists have referred all non-routine eye care cases, as well as patients who had surgery within the past three weeks, to the Misericordia Eye Clinic.
They've been directed to do so by the Manitoba Association of Optometrists.
The result is that Manitobans are taking the brunt of the job action because the clinic has become jam-packed with patients, forcing the clinic to scramble and enlist the help of the Winnipeg Regional Health Authority to find more staff.
PAT MCGRATH / FREE PRESS FILES
Since March, Manitoba optometrists have been refusing to handle all non-routine eye care cases out of frustration with the provincial government, which hasn't signed a deal with them in years.
PAT MCGRATH / FREE PRESS FILES
Since March, Manitoba optometrists have been refusing to handle all non-routine eye care cases out of frustration with the provincial government, which hasn't signed a deal with them in years.
'Patients are who the system is intended to serve and they are the most vulnerable,' said Winnipegger Mike Ellery, who learned about the labour dispute.
The optometry services contract expired on March 31, 2019, during the third year of the Pallister government.
Ellery admits he was confused when, back in May, his optometrist sent him to the Misericordia Eye Clinic for an issue when he had been treated for the same condition by that specialist a few years earlier.
Ellery said there were so many patients waiting when he went in to the clinic one morning that, after he was not seen by the afternoon, he had to leave. He returned the next day and was treated. He said he wasn't the only one who left without being seen by an optometrist.
'Patients are who the system is intended to serve and they are the most vulnerable.'–Mike Ellery
But Ellery said, before returning to the clinic, he spoke to the president of the association who confirmed job action was being taken.
He said Dr. Averi Van Dam told him that optometrists had gone six years without a contract.
'I also learned that optometrists get paid shockingly little for providing urgent care and they have had no opportunity to renegotiate their contract.'
Ellery said he told the association president it was not only 'inexcusable' for the province not to renegotiate a new contract, but the association's job actions were also 'both irresponsible and ineffective.'
He said he hoped now that the public knows what is going on, the situation will be resolved.
'Avoiding harms to patients must always be our top priority… now that the secret's out, maybe we can all start the work needed to heal the desperately unwell health care system for which we are responsible.'
Sundays
Kevin Rollason's Sunday newsletter honouring and remembering lives well-lived in Manitoba.
The association did not provide a statement about the contract issue before deadline, despite being told the government response and being sent a list of questions about the dispute.
A Doctors Manitoba spokesman said physicians are concerned about the ongoing dispute and the effect on patients.
'We understand optometrists are withholding certain services from patients while they seek a new contract, and we're hearing from physicians who have seen more patients seeking urgent care for eye issues, and longer wait times too,' the spokesman said, adding it's hoped the two sides can resolve the dispute quickly so care can be restored.
Mike Deal / Free Press files
Health Minister Uzoma Asagwara.
Mike Deal / Free Press files
Health Minister Uzoma Asagwara.
Health Minister Uzoma Asagwara said the government 'has been actively working with optometrists over the past several months.
'The previous government refused to even take a meeting with optometrists and this understandably caused frustration,' Asagwara said in a statement.
The minister said the contract covers optometric services, including eye exams and post-operative care, with optometrists being paid with a set tariff per service. As well, they said optometrists can also bill third-party insurers for additional services.
'We are aware of the increased demand for same-day eye care services at the Misericordia Eye Centre,' Asagwara said.
'In response, the WRHA has implemented temporary solutions, including reallocating staff and bringing in additional physicians.'
Noah Schultz, provincial director of the Manitoba Health Coalition, said patients can't afford more delays.
'We're in a system-wide staffing and physician crisis in Manitoba health care,' Schulz said. 'We need more health care professionals across the board, including specialists like optometrists and ophthalmologists. Patients in Manitoba already face year-long wait lists for essential procedures like cataract surgery.
'The previous government refused to even take a meeting with optometrists and this understandably caused frustration.'–Health Minister Uzoma Asagwara
'This puts Manitobans on such wait lists at risk and weakens trust in public health care.'
Schulz said Manitobans need quicker health care, not delayed.
'Eye care is health care and should be accessible to all Manitobans,' he said.
'We need expanded, fully public eye care services, and must push governments to provide more access, not less.'
While Progressive Conservative Health critic Kathleen Cook didn't address the lack of contract negotiations during the previous Tory government, she took aim at the current government for not settling it.
'Over the last two years, Manitobans and health care professionals alike have been increasingly disappointed by the NDP's broken promises,' Cook said. 'Optometrists are joining other health care providers, from home care attendants to nurses, who have found that the NDP's words don't always match their actions.
She said she had written to Asagwara twice to work with the optometrists association and resolve the dispute.
kevin.rollason@freepress.mb.ca
Kevin RollasonReporter
Kevin Rollason is a general assignment reporter at the Free Press. He graduated from Western University with a Masters of Journalism in 1985 and worked at the Winnipeg Sun until 1988, when he joined the Free Press. He has served as the Free Press's city hall and law courts reporter and has won several awards, including a National Newspaper Award. Read more about Kevin.
Every piece of reporting Kevin produces is reviewed by an editing team before it is posted online or published in print — part of the Free Press's tradition, since 1872, of producing reliable independent journalism. Read more about Free Press's history and mandate, and learn how our newsroom operates.
Our newsroom depends on a growing audience of readers to power our journalism. If you are not a paid reader, please consider becoming a subscriber.
Our newsroom depends on its audience of readers to power our journalism. Thank you for your support.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Winnipeg Free Press
4 days ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
Optometrists refuse to treat urgent cases over fee dispute with province
Manitoba optometrists have been refusing to handle urgent cases out of frustration with the provincial government, which hasn't signed a deal with them in years. Since March, the optometrists have referred all non-routine eye care cases, as well as patients who had surgery within the past three weeks, to the Misericordia Eye Clinic. They've been directed to do so by the Manitoba Association of Optometrists. The result is that Manitobans are taking the brunt of the job action because the clinic has become jam-packed with patients, forcing the clinic to scramble and enlist the help of the Winnipeg Regional Health Authority to find more staff. PAT MCGRATH / FREE PRESS FILES Since March, Manitoba optometrists have been refusing to handle all non-routine eye care cases out of frustration with the provincial government, which hasn't signed a deal with them in years. PAT MCGRATH / FREE PRESS FILES Since March, Manitoba optometrists have been refusing to handle all non-routine eye care cases out of frustration with the provincial government, which hasn't signed a deal with them in years. 'Patients are who the system is intended to serve and they are the most vulnerable,' said Winnipegger Mike Ellery, who learned about the labour dispute. The optometry services contract expired on March 31, 2019, during the third year of the Pallister government. Ellery admits he was confused when, back in May, his optometrist sent him to the Misericordia Eye Clinic for an issue when he had been treated for the same condition by that specialist a few years earlier. Ellery said there were so many patients waiting when he went in to the clinic one morning that, after he was not seen by the afternoon, he had to leave. He returned the next day and was treated. He said he wasn't the only one who left without being seen by an optometrist. 'Patients are who the system is intended to serve and they are the most vulnerable.'–Mike Ellery But Ellery said, before returning to the clinic, he spoke to the president of the association who confirmed job action was being taken. He said Dr. Averi Van Dam told him that optometrists had gone six years without a contract. 'I also learned that optometrists get paid shockingly little for providing urgent care and they have had no opportunity to renegotiate their contract.' Ellery said he told the association president it was not only 'inexcusable' for the province not to renegotiate a new contract, but the association's job actions were also 'both irresponsible and ineffective.' He said he hoped now that the public knows what is going on, the situation will be resolved. 'Avoiding harms to patients must always be our top priority… now that the secret's out, maybe we can all start the work needed to heal the desperately unwell health care system for which we are responsible.' Sundays Kevin Rollason's Sunday newsletter honouring and remembering lives well-lived in Manitoba. The association did not provide a statement about the contract issue before deadline, despite being told the government response and being sent a list of questions about the dispute. A Doctors Manitoba spokesman said physicians are concerned about the ongoing dispute and the effect on patients. 'We understand optometrists are withholding certain services from patients while they seek a new contract, and we're hearing from physicians who have seen more patients seeking urgent care for eye issues, and longer wait times too,' the spokesman said, adding it's hoped the two sides can resolve the dispute quickly so care can be restored. Mike Deal / Free Press files Health Minister Uzoma Asagwara. Mike Deal / Free Press files Health Minister Uzoma Asagwara. Health Minister Uzoma Asagwara said the government 'has been actively working with optometrists over the past several months. 'The previous government refused to even take a meeting with optometrists and this understandably caused frustration,' Asagwara said in a statement. The minister said the contract covers optometric services, including eye exams and post-operative care, with optometrists being paid with a set tariff per service. As well, they said optometrists can also bill third-party insurers for additional services. 'We are aware of the increased demand for same-day eye care services at the Misericordia Eye Centre,' Asagwara said. 'In response, the WRHA has implemented temporary solutions, including reallocating staff and bringing in additional physicians.' Noah Schultz, provincial director of the Manitoba Health Coalition, said patients can't afford more delays. 'We're in a system-wide staffing and physician crisis in Manitoba health care,' Schulz said. 'We need more health care professionals across the board, including specialists like optometrists and ophthalmologists. Patients in Manitoba already face year-long wait lists for essential procedures like cataract surgery. 'The previous government refused to even take a meeting with optometrists and this understandably caused frustration.'–Health Minister Uzoma Asagwara 'This puts Manitobans on such wait lists at risk and weakens trust in public health care.' Schulz said Manitobans need quicker health care, not delayed. 'Eye care is health care and should be accessible to all Manitobans,' he said. 'We need expanded, fully public eye care services, and must push governments to provide more access, not less.' While Progressive Conservative Health critic Kathleen Cook didn't address the lack of contract negotiations during the previous Tory government, she took aim at the current government for not settling it. 'Over the last two years, Manitobans and health care professionals alike have been increasingly disappointed by the NDP's broken promises,' Cook said. 'Optometrists are joining other health care providers, from home care attendants to nurses, who have found that the NDP's words don't always match their actions. She said she had written to Asagwara twice to work with the optometrists association and resolve the dispute. Kevin RollasonReporter Kevin Rollason is a general assignment reporter at the Free Press. He graduated from Western University with a Masters of Journalism in 1985 and worked at the Winnipeg Sun until 1988, when he joined the Free Press. He has served as the Free Press's city hall and law courts reporter and has won several awards, including a National Newspaper Award. Read more about Kevin. Every piece of reporting Kevin produces is reviewed by an editing team before it is posted online or published in print — part of the Free Press's tradition, since 1872, of producing reliable independent journalism. Read more about Free Press's history and mandate, and learn how our newsroom operates. Our newsroom depends on a growing audience of readers to power our journalism. If you are not a paid reader, please consider becoming a subscriber. Our newsroom depends on its audience of readers to power our journalism. Thank you for your support.
Winnipeg Free Press
4 days ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
Pedal power for Parkinson's awareness
Tim Hague vividly remembers the day his doctor delivered the life-changing news: he had Parkinson's disease. 'He said, 'You can plan on 10 to 15 good years,' the 60-year-old Winnipegger recalled in an interview with the Free Press on Wednesday. 'Well, I'm 14 years and five months into this thing, and I don't feel like I'm at the end of my good years yet. And I attribute that to exercise.' Hague, a retired nurse, has built an impressive physical regimen — one that once helped him and his son, Tim Jr., win the inaugural season of The Amazing Race Canada in 2013. Staying fit has also become the cornerstone of his fundraising efforts for U-Turn Parkinson's, the Winnipeg-based wellness centre he founded to help others living with the disease. 'It is the fastest growing neurological disease in the world,' said Hague. 'There's over 11 million people now with it worldwide — including more than 7,000 in Manitoba — and that's expected to double by 2040.' Hague really put his plans in motion last summer with the first-ever Team 81 Ride for Parkinson's, which teamed up with Winnipeg Jets forward Kyle Connor. Unfortunately, the two men share a common bond — Connor's late grandfather and father both had the disease. 'You sometimes think people who are of a certain stature — and he's a big stature — don't have time for this sort of thing. But he's been 100 per cent present,' said Hague. 'He is engaged with Parkinson's, and it's very clear. Because this is close to his heart, and he wants to make a lasting impression.' The inaugural ride featured 24 cyclists, 13 of whom completed a gruelling five-day, 550-kilometre trek from Russell to Falcon Lake. Ten of those riders are living with Parkinson's. JOHN WOODS / FREE PRESS FILES The second annual Team 81 Ride For Parkinson's at Assiniboine Park will be held on Aug. 1 — or 8/1, matching Winnipeg Jets forward Kyle Connor's jersey number. JOHN WOODS / FREE PRESS FILES The second annual Team 81 Ride For Parkinson's at Assiniboine Park will be held on Aug. 1 — or 8/1, matching Winnipeg Jets forward Kyle Connor's jersey number. 'To see their determination, their smiles of accomplishment at the end of every day, to know their needs firsthand — we were stopping so they could take their medication and rest to ensure they were physically capable — it was incredible to witness and be a part of,' said Kevin Donnelly, senior vice-president of True North Sports & Entertainment. Donnelly has a personal connection to the cause. He's known Hague for years, and the two are about to become family — Hague's daughter, Jordana, is marrying Donnelly's son, Chris, in September. He also played a key role in getting Connor involved after the death of Connor's father, Joe, in 2021, 'Kyle came to Mark (Chipman, co-owner of the Jets) and said, 'I'm ready to reach out, how do I get connected, what's the right organization?'' said Donnelly. 'And this really began to accelerate fast.' Last year's debut event raised more than $141,000 for U-Turn Parkinson's, which uses exercise and wellness programs to support those living with the disease. 'It was absolutely fantastic,' Hague said. And, admittedly, a bit too ambitious. In response, organizers have scaled things back this year, with the goal of making an even bigger impact. Next Friday, Aug. 1 — or 8/1, matching Connor's jersey number — has been officially designated Ride for Parkinson's Day in Manitoba. The second annual Team 81 Ride for Parkinson's will feature a single-day, 50-kilometre route beginning and ending at Assiniboine Park. 'A more manageable ride,' said Hague. Participants will be welcomed at the finish line with a family-friendly celebration, including a bike parade, decorating station, DJ, face painting, mascots and more. Manitoba Liquor & Lotteries is sponsoring the bike parade, which aims to 'turn heads and show powerful support for those living with Parkinson's.' Canadian Tire is sponsoring the ride. Hague emphasized that people of all ages and abilities are welcome — even those who don't want to hop on a bike. Parkinson's is a progressive neurological disorder that affects movement, often beginning gradually before worsening over time. It impairs co-ordination, balance and strength, and is the world's leading cause of permanent disability. Frank Franklin II / THE ASSOCIATED PRESS FILES Winnipeg Jets forward Kyle Connor's late grandfather and father both had Parkinson's disease. Frank Franklin II / THE ASSOCIATED PRESS FILES Winnipeg Jets forward Kyle Connor's late grandfather and father both had Parkinson's disease. Connor issued a statement encouraging the public to consider sponsoring a rider or making a donation of '$81, $810, $8,100 or any other amount you can donate.' 'Every dollar helps,' said Connor. 'Currently, there is no cure, however exercise has been proven to slow the progression of the disease and an event like the Team 81 Ride For Parkinson's can bring awareness to the benefits of exercise.' All proceeds go towards U-Turn Parkinson's, which had been operating out of a church basement but recently moved into Southdale Community Centre. Hague's hope is to one day find a permanent facility of their own. 'We're moving along,' he said. 'We're not even quite a month in, but it's a brand new addition to the community centre and it's absolutely beautiful. It's way more space for us, a way more welcoming space and more suited to what we do.' For more information about the organization and/or the event, visit call 204-510-4869, or email info@ 'There's nobody else in Manitoba that's doing Parkinson's-focused therapy,' said Donnelly. 'When you think about other ailments like heart and stroke and cancer and all these things that are so deserving, there is such a huge infrastructure that exists that isn't there for Parkinson's-afflicted people. So there's a real catch-up that has to happen with this diagnosis and with this community.' X and Bluesky: @mikemcintyrewpg Mike McIntyreReporter Mike McIntyre is a sports reporter whose primary role is covering the Winnipeg Jets. After graduating from the Creative Communications program at Red River College in 1995, he spent two years gaining experience at the Winnipeg Sun before joining the Free Press in 1997, where he served on the crime and justice beat until 2016. Read more about Mike. Every piece of reporting Mike produces is reviewed by an editing team before it is posted online or published in print — part of the Free Press's tradition, since 1872, of producing reliable independent journalism. Read more about Free Press's history and mandate, and learn how our newsroom operates. Our newsroom depends on a growing audience of readers to power our journalism. If you are not a paid reader, please consider becoming a subscriber. Our newsroom depends on its audience of readers to power our journalism. Thank you for your support.
Winnipeg Free Press
5 days ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
Home-care scheduling chaos worsening, overwhelmed staff say
Home care workers feeling overwhelmed and burned out because of heavy caseloads say leadership's response to a recent Free Press report on the city's centralized scheduling office only intensified the pressure on staff over the past weekend. 'Expectations are already way too high, and they constantly ignore our concerns,' said one employee, who asked not to be identified, fearing the consequences of speaking out. 'The direction on Friday was to fill all of the calls for the weekend by Friday at 4 p.m., which is impossible.' The employee, whose position is being withheld to protect their identity, said that between Friday and Sunday, more than 2,100 scheduled visits by nurses and health-care aides were cancelled with notice. That figure represented about a quarter of the visits that were expected to go unfilled late last week. Internal data showed more than 8,660 visits were at risk of being unassigned heading into the weekend. The Winnipeg Regional Health Authority said Tuesday that 727 visits were cancelled on Saturday, while another 782 were shelved Sunday — significantly lower than figures from late last week. Health Minister Uzoma Asagwara said Tuesday that the lower total of missed visits came after the WRHA was told last week to remedy the situation. Asagwara said they are also working quickly to bring more 'expertise' to look at the system and recommend changes. 'A fresh set of eyes,' Asagwara said, adding those people could be installed within days. Some of the experts will include front-line workers, including nurses and health-care aides, who Asagwara called 'rock stars' in wanting to provide the best possible care for clients. They will work closely with WRHA leadership and the province, the minister said. However, Progressive Conservative health critic Kathleen Cook said Tuesday it's safe to say that enough time has passed to indicate the switch to a centralized scheduling office hasn't worked. 'It's been four months since they rolled it out… and I think it's incumbent on the minister to say they tried something and it didn't work and maybe it's time to revert back to the old scheduling system,' Cook said, adding she has heard similar concerns from nurses and health-care aides, and raised them during question period in April, only to be told by Asagwara that she was fear-mongering. 'Worse, they assured Manitobans these issues were being addressed and resolved very, very quickly. We now know that was not the case. These problems persist. If the scheduling system is the problem, let's fix it.' Asagwara shot back, saying it was under the former Tory government that the 2023 death of cancer patient Katherine Ellis, who was incorrectly classified and denied timely home care, led to a review. That review produced 21 recommendations, including the shift to a centralized scheduling office. The WRHA centralized its home-care scheduling system in March, in an effort to improve communication, workload and client support. The overhaul has been harshly criticized by workers, who have complained of long wait times in contacting the central office. 'The critic has a short memory, and would do well to understand where this rollout came from,' Asagwara said. 'I think it's incredibly disingenuous of the health critic to comment on a system that is a direct result of the PCs' failings.' On Tuesday, two employees told the Free Press that leadership pushed staff, including resource co-ordinators, to work additional hours. While staff were previously only permitted to take on full shifts, management reportedly said they could now pick up partial hours to help manage the growing backlog. 'Their desperation was showing,' one employee said. Added another: 'They wanted them to ensure that visits were covered until the following Wednesday, which is hard to do when you're already trying to cover thousands of visits that are for the same day and next day.' While leadership was physically present at the office over the weekend, employees said they didn't check in to offer help or support. 'Their presence is being received as an intimidation factor; that we must be on our best behaviour while they are here,' an employee who worked the weekend said. 'Our breaks were also scheduled for the first time since moving here, which makes us feel like children who have to be constantly micromanaged.' Looking ahead to the upcoming weekend, internal data shows 8,152 home-care visits — affecting 2,860 clients — remain unfilled for Saturday and Sunday. The WRHA, which oversees about 16,500 home visits daily, has said those numbers are fluid and often fluctuate up to the day of service. Their latest seven-day average for cancelled visits, they said last week, was 3.7 per cent. Meanwhile, a new voicemail system meant to prioritize urgent calls has been rolled out haphazardly, employees say. 'Nurses and health-care aides are leaving messages on the wrong line, and they are also scheduling people to only answer phone calls for the entirety of their shift,' one said. 'It seems their general response to the health minister's questions is to offer as much overtime as people want and put increased pressure and blame on the schedulers who are already burned out from working as hard as we can with the limited number of staff we have. 'This is not sustainable. The mood in the office is toxic, people are struggling with their mental and physical health, and we are tired of coming into work each day feeling like things will continue to get worse.' 'The pressures are high,' another employee said. 'The expectations are high. The support is low, and the wild thing is that they tell us that we should be 'fully staffed' now, but then post over 50 available shifts for the weekend… if we had enough staff, we would not be needing to post that many available shifts for office staff.' Scott BilleckReporter Scott Billeck is a general assignment reporter for the Free Press. A Creative Communications graduate from Red River College, Scott has more than a decade's worth of experience covering hockey, football and global pandemics. He joined the Free Press in 2024. Read more about Scott. Every piece of reporting Scott produces is reviewed by an editing team before it is posted online or published in print — part of the Free Press's tradition, since 1872, of producing reliable independent journalism. Read more about Free Press's history and mandate, and learn how our newsroom operates. Our newsroom depends on a growing audience of readers to power our journalism. If you are not a paid reader, please consider becoming a subscriber. Our newsroom depends on its audience of readers to power our journalism. Thank you for your support.
