David Robie: New Zealand Must Do More For Pacific And Confront Nuclear Powers
The New Zealand government needs to do more for its Pacific Island neighbours and stand up to nuclear powers, a distinguished journalist, media educator and author says., Pacific Waves presenter/producer
Lydia Lewis, RNZ Pacific presenter/bulletin editor
The New Zealand government needs to do more for its Pacific Island neighbours and stand up to nuclear powers, a distinguished journalist, media educator and author says.
Professor David Robie, a recipient of the New Zealand Order of Merit (MNZM), released the latest edition of his book Eyes of Fire: The last voyage of the Rainbow Warrior, which highlights the nuclear legacies of the United States and France.
Robie, who has worked in Pacific journalism and academia for 50 years, recounts his experiences aboard the Greenpeace vessel the Rainbow Warrior in 1985, before it was bombed in Auckland Harbour.
At the time, New Zealand stood up to nuclear powers, he said.
'It was pretty callous [of] the US and French authorities to think they can just carry on nuclear tests in the Pacific, far away from the metropolitan countries, out of the range of most media, and just do what they like,' Robie told RNZ Pacific. 'It is shocking, really.'
Speaking to Pacific Waves, Robie said that Aotearoa had forgotten how to stand up for the region.
'The real issue in the Pacific is about climate crisis and climate justice. And we're being pushed this way and that by the US [and] by the French. The French want to make a stake in their Indo-Pacific policies as well,' he said.
'We need to stand up for smaller Pacific countries.'
Robie believes that New Zealand is failing with its diplomacy in the region.
He accused the coalition government of being 'too timid' and 'afraid of offending President Donald Trump' to make a stand on the nuclear issue.
However, a spokesperson for New Zealand Foreign Minister Winston Peters told RNZ Pacific that New Zealand's 'overarching priority…is to work with Pacific partners to achieve a secure, stable, and prosperous region that preserves Pacific sovereignty and agency'.
The spokesperson said that through its foreign policy reset, New Zealand was committed to 'comprehensive relationships' with Pacific Island countries.
'New Zealand's identity, prosperity and security are intertwined with the Pacific through deep cultural, people, historical, security, and economic linkages.'
The New Zealand government commits almost 60 percent of its development funding to the region.
The spokesperson said that the Pacific was becoming increasingly contested and complex.
'New Zealand has been clear with all of our partners that it is important that engagement in the Pacific takes place in a manner which advances Pacific priorities, is consistent with established regional practices, and supportive of Pacific regional institutions.'
They added that New Zealand's main focus remains on the Pacific, 'where we will be working with partners including the United States, Australia, Japan and in Europe to more intensively leverage greater support for the region.
'We will maintain the high tempo of political engagement across the Pacific to ensure alignment between our programme and New Zealand and partner priorities. And we will work more strategically with Pacific Governments to strengthen their systems, so they can better deliver the services their people need,' the spokesperson said.
But former New Zealand Prime Minister Helen Clark, writing in the preface of Robie's book, said: 'New Zealand needs to re-emphasise the principles and values which drove its nuclear-free legislation and its advocacy for a nuclear-free South Pacific and global nuclear disarmament.'
Robie added that looking back 40 years to the 1980s, there was a strong sense of pride in being from Aotearoa, the small country which set an example around the world.
'We took on…the nuclear powers,' Robie said.
'And the bombing of the Rainbow Warrior was symbolic of that struggle, in a way, but it was a struggle that most New Zealanders felt a part of, and we were very proud of that [anti-nuclear] role that we took. Over the years, it has sort of been forgotten'.
'Look at history'
France conducted 193 nuclear tests over three decades until 1996 in French Polynesia.
Until 2009, France claimed that its tests were clean and caused no harm, but in 2010, under the stewardship of Defence Minister Herve Morin, a compensation law was passed.
From 1946 to 1962, 67 nuclear bombs were detonated in the Marshall Islands by the US.
In 2024, then-US deputy secretary of state Kurt Campbell, while responding to a question from RNZ Pacific about America's nuclear legacy, said: 'Washington has attempted to address it constructively with massive resources and a sustained commitment.'
However, Robie said that was not good enough and labelled the destruction left behind by the US, and France, as 'outrageous'.
'It is political speak; politicians trying to cover their backs and so on. If you look at history, [the response] is nowhere near good enough, both by the US and the French.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
3 hours ago
- RNZ News
Is New Caledonia's agreement, championed by Macron, a 'new chapter' or a 'betrayal'?
By Doug Dingwall , Jordan Fennell and Johnson Raela , ABC with wires French officials met with New Caledonian representatives in Paris to negotiate an agreement on the territory's status. Photo: AP French President Emmanuel Macron hailed it a historic "new chapter" for New Caledonia, bringing a peaceful end to devastating turmoil that has rocked the Pacific territory. Leaders from New Caledonia, one of Australia's closest neighbours, emerged from marathon talks near Paris on Saturday with a proposal aiming to settle its recent conflict over the question of independence from France. The deal would create a "state of New Caledonia" within France, and a New Caledonian nationality. Emmanuel Macron says he hopes the new chapter will bring peace to New Caledonia. Photo: Reuters / Tom Nicholson Macron called it a "bet on trust", leading to a "peaceful relationship with France". But the draft agreement stops short of granting independence from France, and involves significant compromises from parties on each side of the debate. Observers say regardless of Macron's enthusiasm, the deal faces a long and uncertain path before it can take effect. They also say the proposal has no clear parallels, and will need explaining to the New Caledonian public, set to vote on it in a February referendum. So, how did it get to this point, how would the agreement work, and what needs to happen for it to take effect? Pro- and anti-independence groups, along with French officials, were locked in negotiations for 10 days. They were tasked with reaching a deal settling New Caledonia's future relationship with France. Ever since a majority of New Caledonians rejected independence from France in three referendums - including in a controversial third vote boycotted by pro-independence groups - leaders had not been able to agree on the way forward. Finally, parties resumed talks in February, a milestone that was lauded as an achievement in itself after tensions spilled over into violent unrest last year. Manuel Valls succeeded in bringing pro- and anti-independence groups back together. Photo: AFP / Delphine Mayeur But progress was initially slow, and despite efforts from France's Overseas Minister Manuel Valls to encourage compromise, early talks in New Caledonia didn't lead to an agreement. The discussions then shifted to Bougival, near Paris, this month when Macron convened and parties tried again. Again, it appeared there would be no breakthrough, according to Denise Fisher, former Australian consul-general in New Caledonia. "It looked like everything was just going sour," she said. The talks changed course on Friday afternoon, when pro-independence leaders consulted with their political bureau until the early hours of the morning, before meeting with Valls at 1am. When he convened the rest of the group at 6am on Saturday, a draft agreement was made. That evening, the parties announced the accord in a gilded hall at the Élysée presidential palace in Paris. The 13-page agreement calls for a "state of Caledonia" within the French Republic, which would be enshrined in France's constitution and could be recognised by other nations. It would also establish a "Caledonian nationality", letting residents combine that status with French nationality. The deal calls for an economic and financial recovery pact that would include a renewal of the territory's nickel processing capabilities. A special congress will be held to finalise next steps, which could include more sovereignty for New Caledonia over issues of international affairs, security and justice, according to excerpts published by New Caledonia's public broadcaster. The accord could also eventually allow New Caledonians to change the territory's name, flag and hymn. But it doesn't grant independence to New Caledonia, whose status as a "state" would be inscribed within French laws. While it would give it some measure of autonomy over its foreign affairs, these would have limits stopping it from clashing with France's interests overseas, experts say. One potential clash could be the destination of its vast nickel reserves - which New Caledonia might want to sell within the region, but that France wants to stay within the European Union, Pacific journalist Nic Maclellan said. And under the agreement New Caledonia residents will, in the future, be allowed to vote after living 10 years in the archipelago - one of the primary issues that ignited the territory's civil unrest last year. France still has territories across the Pacific, giving it access to resources like nickel. Photo: ABC News / Jarrod Fankhauser It would differ from deals between other Pacific nations and their former colonial rulers, such as the "free association" agreement that gives Cook Islands broader power over its affairs from New Zealand. But it remained unclear how the arrangement - creating a state within a nation state - would work, Mr Maclellan said. He said there was no clear parallel elsewhere. "There's absolutely no precedent in French law - and this whole deal is framed in French law," he said. Macron - and the parties striking the deal - have been eager to promote it. Valls described it as "intelligent compromise". Emmanuel Tjibaou, New Caledonia's pro-independence member of the French National Assembly and son of the late independence movement leader Jean-Marie Tjibaou, said the accord would help "us get out of the spiral of violence". Emmanuel Tjibaou says the proposal negotiated in France will help end violence in New Caledonia. Photo: AFP / Delphine Mayeur He described a ''difficult path'' ahead but one that would allow Kanaks and other Caledonians to move forward together while mending divisions. On the anti-independence side, politician Nicolas Metzdorf called it a compromise born of "demanding dialogue", and described the Caledonian nationality as a "real concession''. In Paris, the proposal will need support from France's National Assembly, which will vote on enshrining the changes in the constitution. And, it will need to pass a referendum in New Caledonia, where the proposal has already met backlash from some quarters. Anti-independence groups have long voiced their opposition to splitting New Caledonia from France. Photo: AFP / Theo Rouby Those who signed the draft agreement admitted during a meeting with Macron on Saturday evening that they were struggling to win over opponents of the deal. New Caledonian journalist Brigitte Whaap said while members of the public were relieved there had been progress and an agreement was proposed, some members of the pro- and anti-independence groups felt differently. "They are the ones who are feeling the most sensitive to it," she said. "They're feeling betrayed, really upset about this situation." Philippe Blaise, the anti-independence first vice-president of Southern Province government, said the agreement "crossed a red line" by recognising a "Caledonian state" and a "distinct nationality", which he said was incompatible with French unity. The draft agreement will need the backing of pro-independence supporters within New Caledonia. Photo: AFP / Delphine Mayeur Some pro-independence activists also took to social media to condemn the deal. Brenda Wanabo-Ipeze, a leader of the pro-independence group CCAT, currently incarcerated in France, said: "This text was signed without us. It does not bind us." Melanie Atapo, president of the pro-independence USTKE union, which represents Kanak people, said she was "surprised" by the agreement and that the signatories should "come back to share with the bases before signing". Joel Kasarerhou, president of civil society group Construire Autrement (Build Differently), called the agreement "stillborn", describing it as "lacking ambition and vision". Kasarerhou said the youth at the heart of the May 2024 uprising had been "forgotten or barely mentioned". He feared another "May 13" - the date the 2024 riots began. The pro-independence Kanak and Socialist National Liberation Front (FLNKS) said in a statement on Monday that the agreement included "major advances towards the objective of bringing together, over time, all the elements of sovereignty". "At a difficult time for our country, marked by a deep political, economic and social crisis, we, the group mandated by FLNKS have assumed responsibility," it said. "All the elements set out in the draft agreement will be submitted to our structures for approval, with a view to a collective debate on the next steps to be taken, and to informing the public." Maclellan said political leaders now had to return from Paris and sell the agreement to the public. "To ordinary New Caledonians, there's going to be a lot of questions." -ABC/AFP
RNZ News
5 hours ago
- RNZ News
NZ PM to be a no-show at the Cook Islands 60th celebrations
It's been confirmed New Zealand's prime minister Christopher Luxon will not be travelling to the Cook Islands for its 60th Constitution celebrations next month.
Scoop
17 hours ago
- Scoop
David Robie: New Zealand Must Do More For Pacific And Confront Nuclear Powers
Article – RNZ The New Zealand government needs to do more for its Pacific Island neighbours and stand up to nuclear powers, a distinguished journalist, media educator and author says., Pacific Waves presenter/producer Lydia Lewis, RNZ Pacific presenter/bulletin editor The New Zealand government needs to do more for its Pacific Island neighbours and stand up to nuclear powers, a distinguished journalist, media educator and author says. Professor David Robie, a recipient of the New Zealand Order of Merit (MNZM), released the latest edition of his book Eyes of Fire: The last voyage of the Rainbow Warrior, which highlights the nuclear legacies of the United States and France. Robie, who has worked in Pacific journalism and academia for 50 years, recounts his experiences aboard the Greenpeace vessel the Rainbow Warrior in 1985, before it was bombed in Auckland Harbour. At the time, New Zealand stood up to nuclear powers, he said. 'It was pretty callous [of] the US and French authorities to think they can just carry on nuclear tests in the Pacific, far away from the metropolitan countries, out of the range of most media, and just do what they like,' Robie told RNZ Pacific. 'It is shocking, really.' Speaking to Pacific Waves, Robie said that Aotearoa had forgotten how to stand up for the region. 'The real issue in the Pacific is about climate crisis and climate justice. And we're being pushed this way and that by the US [and] by the French. The French want to make a stake in their Indo-Pacific policies as well,' he said. 'We need to stand up for smaller Pacific countries.' Robie believes that New Zealand is failing with its diplomacy in the region. He accused the coalition government of being 'too timid' and 'afraid of offending President Donald Trump' to make a stand on the nuclear issue. However, a spokesperson for New Zealand Foreign Minister Winston Peters told RNZ Pacific that New Zealand's 'overarching priority…is to work with Pacific partners to achieve a secure, stable, and prosperous region that preserves Pacific sovereignty and agency'. The spokesperson said that through its foreign policy reset, New Zealand was committed to 'comprehensive relationships' with Pacific Island countries. 'New Zealand's identity, prosperity and security are intertwined with the Pacific through deep cultural, people, historical, security, and economic linkages.' The New Zealand government commits almost 60 percent of its development funding to the region. The spokesperson said that the Pacific was becoming increasingly contested and complex. 'New Zealand has been clear with all of our partners that it is important that engagement in the Pacific takes place in a manner which advances Pacific priorities, is consistent with established regional practices, and supportive of Pacific regional institutions.' They added that New Zealand's main focus remains on the Pacific, 'where we will be working with partners including the United States, Australia, Japan and in Europe to more intensively leverage greater support for the region. 'We will maintain the high tempo of political engagement across the Pacific to ensure alignment between our programme and New Zealand and partner priorities. And we will work more strategically with Pacific Governments to strengthen their systems, so they can better deliver the services their people need,' the spokesperson said. But former New Zealand Prime Minister Helen Clark, writing in the preface of Robie's book, said: 'New Zealand needs to re-emphasise the principles and values which drove its nuclear-free legislation and its advocacy for a nuclear-free South Pacific and global nuclear disarmament.' Robie added that looking back 40 years to the 1980s, there was a strong sense of pride in being from Aotearoa, the small country which set an example around the world. 'We took on…the nuclear powers,' Robie said. 'And the bombing of the Rainbow Warrior was symbolic of that struggle, in a way, but it was a struggle that most New Zealanders felt a part of, and we were very proud of that [anti-nuclear] role that we took. Over the years, it has sort of been forgotten'. 'Look at history' France conducted 193 nuclear tests over three decades until 1996 in French Polynesia. Until 2009, France claimed that its tests were clean and caused no harm, but in 2010, under the stewardship of Defence Minister Herve Morin, a compensation law was passed. From 1946 to 1962, 67 nuclear bombs were detonated in the Marshall Islands by the US. In 2024, then-US deputy secretary of state Kurt Campbell, while responding to a question from RNZ Pacific about America's nuclear legacy, said: 'Washington has attempted to address it constructively with massive resources and a sustained commitment.' However, Robie said that was not good enough and labelled the destruction left behind by the US, and France, as 'outrageous'. 'It is political speak; politicians trying to cover their backs and so on. If you look at history, [the response] is nowhere near good enough, both by the US and the French.
