Some witness statements ‘blatantly contradictory' to Alan Jones sexual assault allegations, court hears
Jones was excused from Tuesday's committal hearing but his lawyer Bryan Wrench asked for an extension to allow the department of public prosecutions (DPP) to consider whether they want to go ahead with all the charges.
The 84-year-old has been charged with 35 historical sexual assault offences allegedly committed in various places in New South Wales, including Newtown, Sydney city, Fitzroy Falls, Alexandria and Tamworth. Jones is a former 2GB and Sky News Australia broadcaster.
Wrench said he received the brief of evidence from the DPP on Monday and some of the witness statements are 'blatantly contradictory to some of the allegations'.
'Some of the witnesses said they had never seen Mr Jones engage in any sexually inappropriate behaviour at all,' he said.
The DPP should consider 'whether this matter will be proceeding' Wrench said in a brief hearing before magistrate Daniel Covington.
Covington asked how many complainants were involved in R v Alan Belford Jones and the DPP said there were 11.
The ages of the victims are not disclosed in the charge sheets but police have said previously the youngest was 17 at the time of the alleged offence.
According to a court document made available to media in March, Jones allegedly assaulted his 11th victim by grabbing and squeezing his bottom in Tamworth in June 2013.
Wrench was granted an eight-week extension in agreement with the DPP.
He was arrested at his unit in Sydney's Circular Quay on 18 November last year after a 'long, thorough, protracted' investigation.
Jones appeared for the first time at the Downing Centre local court in December 2024, where it was confirmed he would face a jury trial and his lawyer said he would plead not guilty to the 34, now 35, charges.
Police set up Strike Force Bonnefin in March 2024 to investigate alleged indecent assaults and sexual touching incidents allegedly involving Jones, after they were raised by the Sydney Morning Herald's investigative reporter Kate McClymont.
Jones has denied all wrongdoing and said he was planning legal action against Nine newspapers for the 'demonstrably false' allegations.
According to the charge sheets seen by Guardian Australia, there were 11 alleged offences against one man, Complainant C, between 2008 and 2009, including touching his inner thigh, rubbing his penis and kissing him on the mouth.
Police allege Jones kissed another man 'using his tongue' at Fitzroy Falls in 2017, resulting in a charge of assault with an act of indecency.
In 2001, the broadcaster is alleged to have touched and fondled the penis of another man and on a separate occasion 'kissed him on the lips'.
Police allege in another case Jones stroked a man's right thigh, touched his bottom and 'touched his penis pulling his scrotum'.
In 2012 he is alleged to have 'touched and squeezed' the bottom of a man.
The matter has been held over until 8 July 2025.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
3 hours ago
- The Independent
Child's interview can't be used in her father's trial in killings of wife and other man, judge rules
A northern Virginia circuit judge ruled on Friday that prosecutors' case against an IRS agent charged with killing his wife and another man cannot include a recorded interview from the defendant's young daughter. Fairfax Circuit Court Chief Judge Penney Azcarate on Friday denied prosecutors' motion on the admissibility of the young child's conversation with a forensic interviewer about what she believed was happening the morning her mother was killed at her home. That child's father, Brendan Banfield, was later charged with aggravated murder in the February 2023 deaths of his wife, Christine Banfield, and Joe Ryan, a man who was invited to the house that day. Deputy Commonwealth's Attorney Eric Clingan argued that the child's interview should be admissible evidence at trial because she is a victim of her father's alleged killing. The killings occurred while the child was in the Banfields' basement, authorities have said. In December, Banfield was indicted with child abuse and felony child cruelty in connection with the case. 'It's an act of abuse against her by virtue of what her father did that morning,' Clingan said in court. Meanwhile, John F. Carroll, who represents the father, argued in court that Banfield did not consent for his child to be interviewed by authorities at the police's headquarters. Azcarate sided with the defense, citing a statute that a child's interview would be admissible only if the child was being directly victimized by the parent. She acknowledged authorities later pressed child abuse-related charges, but she said those indictments were not the basis for officials' interview of Banfield's daughter that day. 'The interview doesn't fall within the statute,' Azcarate said. Complex investigation and prosecution The evidentiary hearing is one of a series of developments in the officials' multifaceted investigation and prosecution of Christine Banfield and Ryan's killings. Carroll also moved on Friday for the court to rescind Banfield's indictment and remove Clingan, the lead prosecutor, from the case. In his arguments, Carroll argued that Clingan guided Banfield's co-defendant in an interview, though Azcarate denied both motions. That co-defendant, Juliana Peres Magalhães, was originally arrested and charged with second-degree murder in the case. At the time of the killings, Magalhães and Banfield informed authorities that they walked in on Ryan attacking Christine Banfield and both shot him with different weapons, attorneys have said in court. But last year, Magalhães pleaded guilty to manslaughter in what prosecutors have long described as a scheme led by Banfield and the au pair to frame Ryan in the stabbing of Christine Banfield. Ahead of her plea, Magalhães provided a proffer to officials and was interviewed by Clingan, attorneys have stated in court. Her proffer corroborated a catfishing theory that Ryan was lured to the home on a social networking platform for people interested in sexual fetishes. She also corroborated the theory that Magalhães, who began working for the family in 2021, and Brendan Banfield had a romantic relationship that began before the killings, and that she helped the husband in his conspiracy to kill his wife. 'I'm just so upset and heartbroken for doing this to Brendan,' the au pair wrote to her mother from the Fairfax County jail last October in a message, which has since been entered into court evidence. 'I love him and he loves me too, I have no doubts. But it's the right thing to do. For you. I want to be with you again.' Dispute arises over catfishing theory Despite her proffer, a divide appears evident among officials over the catfishing theory. Brendan Miller, a digital forensic examiner with the police department, testified earlier this month that his analysis of forensic evidence also suggested Christine Banfield was seeking to have an affair with Ryan. Miller testified that his analysis was based on multiple devices, and he concluded that Christine Banfield had connected with Ryan through a social networking platform for people interested in sexual fetishes and matched her with Ryan. His findings diverged from a theory held by other officials in the department that the messages Ryan had been receiving were actually from Brendan Banfield posing as his wife. Deputy Chief Patrick Brusch, who oversaw the department's major crimes bureau at the time, confirmed in testimony earlier this month that he said Miller would 'never be doing another digital forensics case in your major crimes bureau' after he analyzed the evidence. Carroll, Banfield's attorney, argued in court that officials were not adhering to proper investigative guidelines when building their case and backing Brusch's catfishing theory without the supporting facts. In a court filing, Carroll wrote that Brusch resigned from the department after the hearing in which he had testified. He wrote in another motion that 'there is a willfulness in the lack of recognition of the science,' adding: 'The digital forensics are facts, and the Commonwealth chooses to ignore and disregard those facts.' ___
Daily Mail
4 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Woman allegedly stabbed by her co-worker at Intercontinental Hotel
A woman has been rushed to hospital after she was allegedly stabbed by her co-worker at a luxury hotel with a pair of scissors. Emergency services were called to the Intercontinental by IHG on Bridge Street in Sydney 's CBD around 2.20am on Saturday, following reports of an assault. The 30-year-old woman was found with wounds to her face, back and hands. She was rushed to St Vincent's Hospital in a stable condition. A 31-year-old woman was arrested by police and taken to Day Street Police Station where she was assisting officers with their inquiries. It's expected she will be charged this morning. Police have confirmed the women were known to each other.
Daily Mail
7 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Woman, 28, 'gang-raped by three Brits was bitten all over her body during two-hour ordeal in Croatian beach hotel'
Three British men have appeared in court in Croatia charged with the gang rape of a local woman at a popular holiday resort. Ami Arifi, 29, Gezhim Xhafa, 28, and Sohqib Shakibi, 24, appeared before an investigating judge on Thursday. The men have all been remanded in custody pending further investigations into the incident which happened on Tuesday in the port of Split. Police said the 28-year-old woman, who is local, was the victim of a planned attack and the men, who are all from London, face up to ten years in jail if convicted. One of the suspects is said to have offered a bail of 30 thousand euros, but it was not accepted. The suspects met the woman that same evening on Matejuška, the popular waterfront in Split and popular with tourists and locals. She is said to have taken a ride on a motorbike with one of them, then accepted their invitation to go to their four star hotel room at around 5.30 in the morning. According to local media, the first defendant insulted and swore at her, bit her lips and touched her private parts. The court heard the alleged victim objected to this behaviour and said it hurt, but the first defendant continued to assault her. He is alleged to have taken away the woman's mobile phone and asked her to have sexual intercourse with the second defendant. The victim, in fear, agreed and went to the room with the second defendant, it is alleged. After that, the first defendant allegedly asked the victim to perform oral sex on the third defendant, the court heard. According to the woman, he bit her and touched her all over her body. She says she resisted, but at one point managed to free herself and call her ex boyfriend who alerted police. Officers came to the hotel and arrested one of the suspects in the room. The others were quickly found. The court heard the drama in the hotel room lasted two hours. The suspects have all denied their guilt. They claim that everything happened without any coercion. Two are originally from Kosovo, but have British citizenship as does the third.
