Should Be Given 12-18 Months...: Monty Panesar Defends Indias Head Coach Gautam Gambhir
India's loss against England by five-wickets in the first test at Headingley, Leeds drew a lot of criticism as It was India's 7th defeat in 9 Tests under Head coach Gautam Gambhir. India marked a new era in the test with Shubman Gill, the newly test captain taking the helm and new faces replacing the Test greats. Rohit Sharma and Virat Kohli announced retirement from Test cricket before this series and the five-match test series is first assignment of Gill and Gambhir together
The loss has prompted scrutiny of head coach Gautam Gambhir's role, with many questioning his approach and strategy. As debate intensifies over Gambhir's future at the helm, former England spinner Monty Panesar has stepped forward to defend him. Panesar believes that Gambhir deserves more time to mold the team in line with his vision.
Despite early control in the Headingley Test, India's eventual collapse led to criticism from fans and experts alike. The outcome placed added pressure on Gambhir, whose decisions are now being closely scrutinized.
Panesar Backs Gambhir Amid Transition
Panesar, however, called for patience and support for the Indian coach, stressing the impact of losing key senior players.
'Gautam Gambhir should be given at least 12–18 months to develop this young Test squad. Gambhir is without the likes of Kohli and Sharma. You can not expect him to win the Test series against England without experienced players,' Panesar told Insidesport.
Gambhir's Record Under the Microscope
After the T20 World Cup 2024, Gambhir took over from Rahul Dravid as the head coach of the Indian team. While he has overseen some success in limited-overs cricket, results in the Test arena have been underwhelming. Since assuming the role, India has played 11 Tests, managing only 3 wins against 7 notable losses. A home series whitewash at the hands of New Zealand and a heavy defeat in the Border-Gavaskar Trophy have added to growing concerns.
Moreover, for the first time in the current World Test Championship (WTC) cycle, India failed to secure a spot in the final which is a worrying sign under Gambhir's leadership. With the loss in the opening match of the five-Test series against England, pressure continues to mount on both the team and its coach. All eyes are on Gambhir to coach this new team better and have a smooth transition for India.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
News18
30 minutes ago
- News18
Travis Head Creates History, Becomes 1st Cricketer In The World To...
Last Updated: Head scored twin half-centuries (59 and 61) for Australia in the first Test against the West Indies and won the Player of the Match award. Travis Head was on fire for Australia with the bat in the first Test against the West Indies, which was played from June 25 to 27 at Kensington Oval in Barbados. He scored 59 runs from 78 balls with the help of nine fours in the first innings on Wednesday (June 25) and amassed a total of 61 runs from 95 balls in the second. For his twin half-centuries in the series opener, which the Aussies won by 159 runs inside three days, Head won the Player of the Match award. The POTM award on Friday (June 27) helped Head enter his name in the history books as he became the first player in the world to bag 10 POTM awards in WTC. Head has played 50 WTC matches so far for Australia and has scored 3196 runs. Head won his first POTM award in WTC during the Australia-New Zealand Test played at Melbourne Cricket Ground from December 26 to 29 in 2019. In that match, the left-handed batter from South Africa scored 114 runs in the first innings and 28 in the second. His 2nd POTM award was against England in the first Test of the 2021-22 Ashes series, which was played at The Gabba in Brisbane. He scored 152 runs from 148 balls in the first innings to help Pat Cummins's led side secure a win by 9 wickets. In the fifth Test, Head scored a century (101) in Hobart and won his third POTM award. Head then scored 175 and 38 (not out) runs in the Day-Night Test played against the West Indies at Adelaide Oval from December 8 to 11 in 2022 to win the POTM award and bagged the same honour in the next Test played against South Africa as well in Brisbane for scoring 92 runs. In the WTC 2023 final played against India at The Oval, Head scored 159 runs in the first innings for Pat Cummins & Co., and it helped him win his sixth POTM award in WTC. His next three POTM awards in WTC were against West Indies in January 2024 (Adelaide), India in December 2014 (Adelaide), and India in December 2014 (Brisbane). In the list of players with the most POTM awards in WTC, Head is followed by Ben Stokes and Joe Root of England. Both the legendary English cricketers have won 5 POTM awards each in the WTC for the English team. Only a total of six players—Shane Warne (17), Ricky Ponting (16), Steve Waugh (14), Steve Smith (13), Glenn McGrath (11), and Allan Border (11)—have won more POTM awards in Tests for the Baggy Greens than Head. Get latest Cricket news, live score and match results on News18. Download the News18 App to stay updated! Location : Barbados First Published: June 28, 2025, 16:06 IST
Hindustan Times
37 minutes ago
- Hindustan Times
AFI sets new norms for private training centres
New Delhi: India's track and field athletes are preparing for the season this year at various private and government run training centres as per Athletics Federation of India (AFI) ambitious plan to give them the freedom to train at centres of their choice. AFI has also done away with long-duration training camps except for relay teams. Praveen Chithravel . (Getty Images) The idea is to create an open and competitive training environment and broaden the talent pool. Senior AFI officials feel the plan to decentralise training is showing results as is evident from performance at the Asian Championships in Gumi, South Korea, where Indian athletes scooped up 24 medals finishing second in medal tally behind China. However, AFI is also facing some teething troubles in monitoring the athletes and has decided to put in place a mechanism to deal with that. In a meeting with various stakeholders, including government and private entities, AFI set several guidelines that these training centres will have to follow. The federation has already issued directions to athletes to get their training and competition programme cleared by them in case they want to head overseas. AFI said there is a growing trend of athletes choosing to train and compete abroad with funding and support from Target Olympic Podium Scheme and institutes like Reliance and JSW, who run their own centres. But when it comes to major international competitions their performances have dipped. The Paris Olympics were a big lesson for the AFI. Long jumper Jeswin Aldrin, Triple jumper Praveen Chithravel, Javelin throwers Kishore Jena and Annu Rani were among those who failed to deliver in Paris. They weren't even close to their best. Now, the federation doesn't want to make the same mistake with the Commonwealth Games and Asian Games scheduled next year. 'We want to ensure that athletes train with a target in mind, and not aimlessly go for overseas competitions. When you are competing abroad, you don't belong to JSW or Reliance, you belong to India,' said AFI spokesperson and former president Adille Sumariwalla. Chithravel, who equalled his national record of 17.37m this season, went for a few meets in Spain without AFI's permission. 'The point is that they just go and then perform badly. If you are a coach, all we are saying is tell us the annual programme. Which meets you will compete in India and which meet you will compete outside. Why do you want to go to a particular meet and train?' Sumariwalla said the Mission Olympic Cell does not give approval to athlete training abroad without AFI permission. 'Earlier there were cases where MOC had given permission even when AFI did not agree and all those athletes failed. Now, they take our approval,' he said. AFI also said that Indian coaches have a big role to play in pushing athletes to train outside because of their own interest. 'We have a full fledged calendar now in alignment with the world athletics calendar, so why do you want to compete outside? The standard of some of these tournaments are so low. In India you will get better competition,' said senior AFI official Lalit Bhanot to stakeholders. 'Neeraj Chopra trains outside because of a reason. Jyothi Yarraji can train and compete in meets outside because she doesn't have much competition at home but I can't understand why our jumpers and throwers are so eager to go out,' the seasoned administrator said. He said that participating in state meets and national championships is now mandatory and AFI has even set qualifying standards for its important domestic events. AFI has also started the process of registering coaches to track which athletes are being trained by whom. 'Some of these coaches are into manipulation, they encourage doping. They are also changing their wards from one training centre to another by taking money,' said Bhanot. AFI chief coach Radhakrishan Nair said coaches have to be very sure of periodisation. 'In the lead-up to the Paris Olympics, we had some wonderful performances. For example, Jeswin jumped 8.47m and Praveen did 17.37m. Going by their performance as a coach I would feel that at the Olympics, the jumpers would do better but we all know what happened in Paris,' said the chief coach. 'So we should have a combined plan. We can't just send our athletes to compete in events abroad without a plan. The stakeholders have to justify why they are participating. Recent studies show there is no one method of periodization. Next season we have CWG and Asian Games, and we need to sit together and chart out which events we need to give importance to and accordingly set training plans,' he said.
News18
38 minutes ago
- News18
'Gautam Gambhir Must Deliver Against England': Former India Cricketer Warns Team India Head Coach
Former India opener Aakash Chopra questioned Gautam Gambhir's suitability as Test coach after India's poor red-ball record under his leadership. Despite winning the 2025 Champions Trophy, Gambhir's Test tenure includes only three wins in 11 matches and heavy series defeats. Chopra warned that with selectors granting all his requests, Gambhir has no excuses if results don't improve in England. This series could define his legacy and impact India's World Test Championship hopes. and subscribe to our channel and never miss a to CricketNext YouTube channel to never miss a video: CricketNext on Facebook: CricketNext on Twitter: CricketNext on Instagram: : vs ENG Test Series, India England Test Series 2025, Aakash Chopra, Gautam Gambhir, Indian Cricket, Gautam Gambhir Coach, Test Cricket, Aakash Chopra Analysis, India Test Cricket Record, Cricket News, IND ENG Highlights, IND ENG Live, Cricket Controversy, Gambhir Under Pressure, Indian Cricket Team, World Test Championship, Shubman Gill, Rohit Sharma, BCCI, Cricket Updates, Gambhir Test Record, Cricket Discussions, England Cricket, Indian Cricket Coaching, Cricket Opinions, Gambhir Criticism, Gambhir Legacy, Cricket Analysis, Cricket Debate
