Is the EU doing enough to integrate Ukrainian defence tech?
'This is a major contribution to Ukraine's fight for freedom, as well as to the Danish and European armament,' Morten Bødskov, Denmark's minister of industry, business and financial affairs, said in a press release last month.
This first deal between Ukraine and Denmark will 'ensure a higher degree of integration' for Ukraine in Europe's wider rearmament, the statement continued.
The agreement comes a month after Ukraine launched an international joint weapons production programme with its allied countries to build 'licensed production lines for Ukrainian weapons in partner countries'. But do these recent efforts go far enough?
How are European countries building Ukrainian tech?
There are already several projects in play between Ukraine and private industry in Europe, such as the UK's production of the Raybird surveillance drone, a 'flexible fixed-wing' 20-kilogram drone that can be deployed in under 25 minutes and can fly for roughly 28 hours over a 2,500-kilometre range.
A French auto manufacturer will produce first-person view (FPV) drones in Ukraine, with France's armed forces minister Sebastien Lecornu calling it a 'win-win partnership' in French media. Le Monde reported that automaker Renault was approached for this work.
Sweden's SAAB, Norway's Kongsberg, French-German KNDS, Germany's Rheinmetall, and the US's Raytheon are reportedly expanding their presence on the ground, according to a June press release from Ukraine's ministry of defence.
Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy said on Monday that his country struck more deals with European allies and a leading US defence company to 'step up drone production'.
Zelenskyy didn't name the businesses in his address. Euronews Next has followed up with the Ukrainian government to find out more about the deals that have been signed but did not receive a reply at the time of publication.
Ukraine is also working on draft legislation for joint weapons production with allies that should be put to a vote in their parliament later this month, according to Rustem Umerov, Ukraine's defence minister.
The programme includes plans to create a special legal and tax framework to help Ukrainian defence manufacturers scale up and modernise production, including building new facilities at home and abroad, Umerov said.
'We are not included in the common planning'
These projects are a promising first step but Ukraine is still not included in the 'common planning' that the European Union is doing regarding its rearmament, said Olena Bilousova, senior research lead of military at the Kyiv School of Economics.
She added that American-made M982 Excalibur shells dropped in efficiency to reach their targets from 70 per cent to six per cent as Russia continues to advance its electronic warfare (EW). This is a form of artillery that the EU has sent to Ukraine in the past.
'There are a lot of cases like that when we understand that the weapons which were common and still common in procurement of the EU should be reviewed [or] at least … modernised,' she told Euronews Next.
Ukraine's reliance on drones as a 'cheap solution' in its offensives against Russia is also misunderstood by Ukraine's allies, Bilousova added, noting that the country should be able to build drone procurement strategies with its partners.
It doesn't mean that Europe should be focused only on procuring drones, Bilousova continued, but that Ukraine should develop with them 'new strategies around conventional weapons,' including how many are needed and how they can be protected against drones.
Bilousova said Ukraine could also teach Europe how to speed up the development of new battle-tested technologies based on their model.
Ukraine uses the 'Danish model' of military procurement to develop a new technology from idea to product testing on the battlefield, which takes anywhere from three to six months, compared to traditional weapons procurement, which usually takes up to 18 months.
Ukraine can do this through earmarking an estimated $30.8 billion (€29.4 billion) in 2023 for the war effort, a level that is 20 times higher than the pre-2022 invasion level, a recent report from the Stockholm International Peace Research Institute found.
Crowdfunding through platforms such as United24 has also raised over $1 billion (€950 million) and distributed approximately $930 million (€884.61 million) of that to the Armed Forces of Ukraine in the last three years.
Both pots of money are then redistributed to Brave1, a 'united coordinational platform' that provides more than 470 grants worth an estimated 1.3 billion hryvnias (€29 million).
Pan-European approach to Ukraine defence tech 'unlikely'
Bilousova said it's not clear what forum would be the best to bring in Ukraine as a 'consultant' for rearmament.
But a pan-European initiative to get Ukraine fully integrated into rearmament might not be possible because time is 'of the essence,' said Jacob Kirkegaard, senior fellow with the Bruegel think tank.
'The vast majority of this integration will happen at the bilateral level and will be driven by Ukraine's desperate need for more weapons and the willingness by many member states … to provide the money,' he told Euronews Next.
'That is not, unfortunately, a capability that the EU has as a whole'.
However, it doesn't stop the Commission from identifying 'target projects' that would be of shared interest with Ukraine, such as developing advanced air defence, drone surveillance for subsea internet cables or cybersecurity, Kirkegaard continued.
The EU has already activated a €150 billion "SAFE" loan instrument that lets states borrow money for joint defence projects. At least 65 per cent of the weapons' components have to be sourced from within the EU or Ukraine.
It's also launched a joint EU-Ukraine task force to integrate Ukraine into the 'defence-tech ecosystem'.
However, Bilousova said that if the Commission doesn't step back and create a longer-term plan, the weapons it invests in could be 'ineffective' and delayed for the next conflict.
'I think it is always a good time to make a strategy even if war is already in place,' she said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
LeMonde
25 minutes ago
- LeMonde
French energy giant EDF takes 12.5% stake in new UK nuclear power plant
French energy giant EDF will have a 12.5% stake in new British nuclear power plant Sizewell C, London and Paris revealed on Tuesday, July 8, in the first deal announcement of President Emmanuel Macron's state visit to the UK. France's state-owned EDF will invest "around £1.1 billion ($1.5 billion) for a 12.5-percent participation," the French government said in a statement regarding a project aimed at meeting Britain's net-zero and energy security targets. Prime Minister Keir Starmer said in a separate statement that the investment will help deliver "lower energy bills" and "better energy security" for Britain. The announcement comes after Starmer's Labour government said in June it would invest £14.2 billion in Sizewell C, which is being built in eastern England. Britain's government is the majority shareholder in Sizewell C, after Chinese company CGN exited the project. The plant, which is set to cost £20-30 billion to build according to current estimates, is not expected to start generating electricity until 2035. The UK has refocused on shoring up nuclear power since the start of the war in Ukraine, in the name of energy security and faced with a fleet of ageing power stations. Labour also wants to increase the share of non-carbon-emitting energy. The UK government has pledged to reduce UK greenhouse gas emissions by 81 percent on 1990 levels by 2035 and reach net-zero by 2050. The use of nuclear energy as an alternative to fossil fuels is highly controversial, however, with many environmental groups warning about safety risks and the disposal of nuclear waste. The Sizewell C announcement has been met with anger by some local residents worried about the impact of the new plant on the local town of Leiston in Suffolk. Nearby is the Sizewell B nuclear power station, which is due to close in 2035, and Sizewell A, which is in the process of being decommissioned. EDF is also building the Hinkley Point C nuclear power plant in southwestern England, although it has been blighted by delays and rising construction costs.
LeMonde
40 minutes ago
- LeMonde
France will lend Bayeux Tapestry to the UK, Macron announces
Emmanuel Macron first made the announcement as a post-Brexit gesture in 2018, during the 35 th Franco-British summit at Sandhurst in Berkshire, England. Seven years later, the promise is becoming reality: the Bayeux Tapestry, the thousand-year-old embroidery depicting the feats of William the Conqueror and the Norman invasion of England in 1066, will be loaned to the United Kingdom. The French presidential office made the announcement as Macron began a state visit to the UK on Tuesday, July 8. The nearly 70-meter-long linen masterpiece is expected to be displayed for almost a year, from summer 2026 to August 2027, at the British Museum in London. "At a time when Franco-British relations are warming, it makes sense," said Hervé Morin, centrist president of the Normandy administrative region, who had strongly advocated for the loan. The project took shape as the museum holding the tapestry prepared to close its doors for two years on September 1. "You cannot understand how deeply the histories of Normandy and the United Kingdom are intertwined," Morin said. "The blood of Charles III is that of William the Conqueror," he emphasized, already looking ahead to the 2027 celebrations marking the 1,000 th anniversary of the birth of William the Conqueror.
Euronews
43 minutes ago
- Euronews
Far-right Patriots for Europe lead negotiations on key climate file
The far-right Patriots for Europe group will lead negotiations on the EU's new climate target, MEPs and parliament officials told Euronews, a role that could derail the bloc's objective to reduce greenhouse emissions by 90% by 2040. 'The Patriots got the climate legislation file,' Iratxe Garcia, the leader of the socialist group told reporters during a press conference on the margins of the plenary in Strasbourg. 'They've got the rapporteurship… I mean it is the patriots who are going to be the lead negotiators.' Garcia referred to a recent Commission proposal to amend its EU Climate Law by setting a new target to reduce the EU's net greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions by 90% by 2040. It is now up to the parliament and the council to discuss and adopt the text. Officials say giving the 2040 climate target file to the far-right Patriots for Europe in the Parliament's Environment, Public Health and Food Safety committee is the result of a complex system of attribution, which gives the large groups control over important files. The Patriots for Europe is the third largest group in the European Parliament and has 11 full fledged members in the ENVI committee, including from France's National Rally and Italy's Lega party. The group has systematically opposed the EU's climate policies, with National Rally leader Jordan Bardella calling for the immediate suspension of the EU's Green deal a few months ago. It will give the Patriots increasing influence over the EU's climate policy as rapporteurs are ultimately responsible for recommending a political line on the file. Though a rapporteur won't prevent other groups from reaching a deal on the text, he or she could slow down or complicate the legislative work. The Commission proposal is aimed at reaffirming the bloc's 'determination to tackle climate change' according to the Commission's website, and 'shape the path' to climate neutrality, an objective that is at the heart of the EU's green deal. The job represents a breach of the cordon sanitaire - the process through which centrist pro-European groups effectively club together to deny the right-wing fringe top jobs such as presidencies or vice-presidencies of the European Parliament's committees. The practice has historically excluded lawmakers from France's National Rally, Viktor Orbán's Fidesz and Matteo Salvini's Lega from power roles in the Parliament. Last October, Bardella and fellow Patriots' MEP Hungarian Kinga Gál filed a complaint to the European Court of Justice last week against their political groups' exclusion through the so-called 'cordon sanitaire' from leading positions at the European Parliament.
