Gautam Gambhir's Future As India Coach Under Scrutiny Over England Series? Ex-Star Says: "BCCI Will Slowly..."
In an exclusive conversation with IANS, Panesar spoke on the importance of picking a bowling lineup that can deliver in England.
"The problem is that if Gautam has the ability to make his team into a good batting unit, he then needs to show the ability can make the team into a good bowling unit. Fans are going to troll. They're going to come after Gautam Gambhir. When India were 400 plus, India should have won the Test match. But the question is, 'Is Gautam Gambhir a good coach to make the bowling good? Does he have the ability? ' He needs to show that.
'He needs to now think, right, I know how to get the batting to fire, but as a coach, can I pick the team to take 20 wickets? That's his biggest challenge right now in England, and if he is not able to demonstrate that, then I think the BCCI will slowly, Test by Test match, assess him, and they'll just think, you know, what should we do after the end of the series? His biggest challenge is going to be to pick the right attack for every venue to take 20 wickets,' Panesar told IANS.
The former left-handed opening batter was appointed as India's head coach following Rahul Dravid 's departure. Since his appointment, India have won only three of their 11 Tests played - 2-0 win vs Bangladesh and 1-3 loss in the Border-Gavaskar Trophy - which also led to India falling out of the top two in the 2023-25 World Test Championship cycle.
When asked to predict the conditions at Edgbaston, Panesar revealed he expects it to be a turning wicket which will help Kuldeep Yadav or Washington Sundar, with the former England cricketer advising team India to bring in one of these two as the frontline spinners.
'It's going to be a turning wicket. Edgbaston is dry. We won't see much grass from the wicket. I think it will help India. The Edgbaston wicket will suit India. India just need to work out, right? Batting isn't the problem. It's bowling. We need to take 20 wickets to win a Test match. That's the most important thing, and Shubhman Gill did say, 'I will pick 5-4 tailenders, but an attack that can take 20 wickets.'
'From that point of view, I think Prasidh Krishna bowls too short, maybe give him a rest. Bumrah, I think, will rest anyway. Kuldeep Yadav comes in, or Washington Sundar, one of the other, to play an extra spinner. Ashdeep Singh has to play. Left arm seam, I think that will cause problems for the England team. Then, they have Mohammed Siraj, maybe Shardul Thakur could play,' he added.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
India Today
an hour ago
- India Today
ZIM vs SA: Keshav Maharaj ruled out of 2nd Test, Wiaan Mulder to lead South Africa
South Africa has confirmed that Keshav Maharaj has been ruled out of the second Test against Zimbabwe due to a groin injury, with Wiaan Mulder set to captain the side in his absence. The match is scheduled to take place in Bulawayo from Sunday, 6 sustained the injury while batting on the third day of the opening Test. Cricket South Africa (CSA) has confirmed that he will return home for further assessment to determine the extent of the Proteas have named Senuran Muthusamy as Maharaj's replacement in the squad. Mulder, who had a memorable outing in the first Test, will take over the captaincy. The all-rounder impressed with a four-wicket haul and a superb 147-run knock in the second Hero Ngidi Released CSA also announced that pacer Lungi Ngidi has been released from the squad. The move is aimed at giving the bowlers who featured in the first Test another opportunity to prove themselves in the longest the first Test, South Africa fielded a pace-heavy attack, featuring specialists Kwena Maphaka and Codi Yusuf, alongside all-rounders Corbin Bosch and Mulder. Maharaj was the sole spinner in the played a pivotal role in South Africa's World Test Championship final triumph over Australia. His decisive spell, which accounted for Steve Smith, Beau Webster, and Pat Cummins, turned the tide in South Africa's favour, helping them secure their first ICC title in over two Eye Series WhitewashDespite the personnel changes, South Africa will back themselves to complete a series whitewash following their emphatic win in the opening Test. The victory was built on a dominant batting performance, with young stars Lhuan-dr Pretorius and Corbin Bosch scoring centuries to set the tone. Bosch capped off a brilliant all-round display by claiming a five-wicket haul in the second innings, as the Proteas cruised to a commanding 328-run win.- Ends
Hindustan Times
an hour ago
- Hindustan Times
Jasprit Bumrah blamed as 'surprising' act laid bare after Edgbaston omission: 'You keep those cards close to your chest'
Amid the rising criticism over the Indian team management resting Jasprit Bumrah for the second Test match against England in Birmingham, former England fast bowler Stuart Broad blamed the 31-year-old for his "surprising" act before the start of the series. India's Jasprit Bumrah during the warm up before the match(Action Images via Reuters) BCCI chief selector Ajit Agarkar confirmed at the time of the announcement of the Test squad for the England tour that Bumrah would play just three of the five Test matches in the series to manage his workload. The fast bowler had incurred back spasms during the tour of Australia earlier this year, which resulted in him missing the Champions Trophy. Later, in an interview with Dinesh Karthik for Sky Sports right before the start of the Test series, Bumrah revealed that he first communicated with the BCCI to discuss his workload management after sensing that he was being considered for the leadership role. ALSO READ: Sunil Gavaskar explodes over Kuldeep Yadav snub, exposes Gautam Gambhir's blunder: 'Nitish Reddy, Sundar won't fix that' "I called the BCCI and said I don't want to be looked at in a leadership role because I won't be able to give [it my] all Test matches coming a five Test-match series. So then, yes, the BCCI was looking at me at leadership. But then I had to say no," he said. Broad outlined Bumrah's statement, saying that he should not have made his plan to play just three Test matches in England public. Admitting it was a "surprising" decision from India to rest Bumrah at Edgbaston after his performance in Leeds, Broad, speaking to Sky Cricket, said what was more baffling to him was the fast bowler's decision to reveal his plan, which he felt should have been kept a secret. MUST READ: Why India, England players are wearing black armbands in Birmingham Test? 'A week is a very good time off for a fast bowler. '[Bumrah's omission] does surprise me and what also surprised me was him saying before the series he will only play three of the five Tests,' he said after Akash Deep replaced the 31-year-old in the playing XI. 'You keep those cards close to your chest and play each week as it comes. 'They will definitely want Bumrah at Lord's because of the movement you can get through the air." Earlier on Tuesday, in the pre-match presser, India captain Shubman Gill had said that Bumrah, who picked up a five-wicket haul in the first Test, was available for selection. However, India decided to rest him in Birmingham to keep him fresh for the third Test at the Lord's. "Just to manage his workload. We did get a good break and this is an important match for us. But the third Test being at Lord's, we think there'll be more in that pitch so we'll use him there," Gill explained after losing the toss.
Hindustan Times
an hour ago
- Hindustan Times
Gautam Gambhir's 'fixation' will 'never work', head coach badgered by former India and Australia cricketers
India's XI for the second Test against England at Edgbaston in Birmingham has T20 cricket written all over it. Two all-rounders replacing a specialist batter and a pacer who can who can bat a bit, left India with only five designated batters and three specialist bowlers. Having batters till No.8 and six bowling options has been India head coach Gautam Gambhir's template. It has worked for him in white-ball cricket, especially in T20s. Be it the IPL or international cricket, Gambhir's fondness for all-rounders has brought results. But the same style has hurt him in Test cricket. It did against New Zealand at home. Then in Australia, and if India don't get the desired result in Edgbaston, England will be added to that list. Indian captain Shubman Gill and coach Gautam Gambhir during a practice session(PTI) After choosing a predictable XI for the series opener in Birmingham, which they lost by five wickets despite dominating the match for a better period, India pressed the panic button. They rang in three changes. One of them was, of course, due to Jasprit Bumrah's workload management. The other two can be credited to Gambhir's 'fixation' for all-rounders. Calling India's selection "baffling," former Australia all-rounder Tom Moody said packing the team with all-rounders has never worked in Test cricket. India vs England Live Score, 2nd Test "India's selection for this test is baffling. No Bumrah is one thing, but to only have 5 specialist batsmen is a gamble. The fixation on all-rounders who are there to offer depth with bat and ball has never worked. Specialists are always going to offer more over a test," Moody wrote on X. India replaced Jasprit Bumrah with pacer Akash Deep and brought in seam-bowling all-rounder Nitish Kumar Reddy in place of Shardul Thakur, and the third change was another surprising one. They dropped Sai Suidharsan, who batted at No.3 on is Test debut in Headingley, made way for Washington Sundar. Sudharsan was caught down the leg side for a duck in the first innings but played a decent knock in the second. Former India batter Subramanium Badrinath said it was a harsh call to drop a youngster after just one Test. "Sai scored a crucial 30 and was involved in an important partnership in the second innings. Dropping a youngster high on confidence doesn't feel right," Badrinath wrote on X. The selection of Sundar was a strange one in more than one way. After the assistance that Ravindra Jadeja got on Day 5 of the first Test from the rough created on the left-hander's off stump on a placid Headingley pitch, the chorus to include Kuldeep Yadav as the lead spinner grew, especially considering the conditions at Birmingham, the venue for the second Test. Ever since the advent of Bazball cricket, Edgbaston has produced some of the flattest tracks that naturally tend to offer something to the spinner towards the end of the five-day affair. India, however, did not pick Kuldeep and went with Washington Sundar as their second spin-bowling option. Captain Shubman Gill said it was due to batting depth.
