Impotent Effusions: The Joint Statement On Gaza
One such statement, released on July 21, proved to be yet another one of those flossy effusions made by, as Macbeth might have said, idiots, full of sound and fury, signifying nothing. The idiots numbered many: 28 international partners, including the foreign ministers of 27 states and, obviously not wanting to miss out, the EU Commissioner for Equality, Preparedness and Crisis Management. All, bar Australia, were from Europe. 'We, the signatories listed below, come together with a simple, urgent message: the war in Gaza must end now.'
The statement goes on to mention the drearily obvious. 'The Israeli government's aid delivery model is dangerous, fuels instability and deprives Gazans of human dignity.' The 'drip feeding of aid and inhumane killing of civilians, including children, seeking to meet their most basic needs of food and water' deserved condemnation. The deaths of over 800 Palestinians (the numbers are most certainly higher) while seeking aid was 'horrifying'. Even here, the language lacked rage. Israel's 'denial of essential humanitarian assistance to the civilian population is unacceptable.' The government 'must comply with its obligations under international humanitarian law.'
To that end, Israel was called upon to restore the flow of aid and enable the work of the United Nations and humanitarian NGOs to resume in the Strip. This is obviously something that the Netanyahu government is conscious of avoiding, given the systematic program of controlled starvation and deprivation being inflicted.
To add balance, the statement also notes the plight of the Israeli hostages still held by Hamas, their continued detention also something to be condemned. They were to be immediately and unconditionally released with a negotiated ceasefire being the best way of doing so.
The signatories do go so far as to acknowledge the dangers and intentions of Israel's administrative measures that seek 'territorial or demographic change in the Occupied Palestinian Territories. The E1 settlement plan announced by Israel's Civil Administration, if implemented, would divide a Palestinian state in two, marking a flagrant breach of international law and critically undermine the two-state solution.' The West Bank is also recognised in similar light, with the signatories urging a cessation to the violence taking place against Palestinians and a halt to the building of settlements across the territory 'including East Jerusalem'.
These statements are always interesting for what they omit. No toothy measures to address the maltreatment of Palestinian civilians are stipulated, other than an encouragement of 'a common effort to bring this terrible conflict to an end'. A benign, most unthreatening promise is made: the prospect of taking 'further action to support an immediate ceasefire and a political pathway to security and peace for Israelis, Palestinians and the entire region.' This may be code for recognition of a Palestinian state, fanciful given the systematic pulverisation of the people who would inhabit it. The signatory list also omits Germany and, most importantly of all, the United States, Israel's arch guardian and evangelical sponsor.
The US ambassador to Israel, Mike Huckabee, gave us a flavour of feelings in Washington about the signatories in a post on X. 'How embarrassing for a nation to side [with] a terror group like Hamas & blame a nation whose civilians were massacred for fighting to get hostages released.' In another post that made a vague shot at justifying the unjustifiable, the ambassador absolved Israel in its conduct; only the militant group Hamas deserved exclusive blame. The nations in question had 'put pressure on @Israel instead of savages of Hamas! Gaza suffers for 1 reason: Hamas rejects EVERY proposal. Blaming Israel is irrational.'
The Israeli foreign minister Gideon Sa'ar, ever lurking in the twilight of alternative reality, reasoned the statement away, much as relatives would the views of a demented, unloved aunt. 'If Hamas embraces you – you are in the wrong place.' Praise from the group was itself 'proof of the mistake they [the signatory countries] made – part of them out of good intentions and part of them out of an obsession against Israel.'
While the various foreign ministers were flashing their plumage of principles and international humanitarian law, the Israeli Defense Forces had busily commenced an operation on a part of Gaza they have yet to level: Deir al-Balah. Given its importance as a humanitarian hub that still houses UN staff and guesthouses, more slaughter is imminent.
Till Israel assumes the status of a pariah state it seemingly craves to become, its rogue army confined and depleted, its economy humbled and isolated, the industrial appetite for slaughter and dispossession will only continue. The Palestinians will be left to be relics of moral anguish, banished to the footnotes of bloodied history along with many more statements of concern and sheer impotence.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NZ Herald
an hour ago
- NZ Herald
EU deforestation rules: NZ beef and wood exporters may face extra costs
The regulation was amended to exclude sheep products in 2022, and its implementation was delayed last year. But the beef, meat and wood processing sectors were preparing for the new requirements. It was announced this week that the Meat Industry Association, Beef + Lamb and an analytics firm were developing aerial and satellite-generated farm maps, as well as compiling the movement of livestock. The New Zealand Deforestation Map initiative was to help the sector prepare the documents and data needed with each shipment of their products to the EU from December 31. The regulation was expected to affect $213 million in beef and leather exports to the EU and $100 million in wood products. Minister 'banging on the table' for exemption Agriculture Minister Todd McClay speaking at the Red Meat Sector Conference in Christchurch on Tuesday. Photo / RNZ, Monique Steele McClay, the Minister for Agriculture, Forestry and Trade and Investment, told the Red Meat Sector Conference in Christchurch on Tuesday that companies should prepare for the incoming rules. 'Well done for preparing,' he said. 'I'm so very sorry this cost has been put upon you, because in my view it is unnecessary. 'Since we came to government, I have consistently said to the European Union we have standards, the equivalent to yours if not higher, so you should not be putting costs upon every single producer in New Zealand, and we have been looking for ways to find exemptions or to changes, or to get the cost down.' McClay wrote to the European Commission last year and said he met one of the commissioners in Brussels last month, who suggested other countries were also trying to gain exemptions, such as France. 'You'd figure when the EU member states don't like something, perhaps there's a change coming,' McClay said. New Zealand already had rules protecting native forests, and penalties for offending. 'They [the EU] have nothing to worry about in New Zealand. 'You're not allowed to deforest native forests in New Zealand. 'Ultimately, I, as the Government, can give an absolute assurance that it doesn't happen because we prosecute, we go and find these things.' He said the new regime was likely to impose 'unreasonable' costs on producers, creating a barrier to trade, despite New Zealand's free-trade agreement with the EU. 'So you need to keep preparing in case they don't get there, but we're gonna keep banging the table.' Mapping farms and tracking livestock Industry analytics firm Prism Earth is a partnership between Silver Fern Farms and Lynker Analytics, launched to meet the increased demand for carbon traceability, its website says. It uses satellite imagery, aerial photography, remote laser sensing and artificial intelligence to map farms and identify grazing areas and forests. It also tracks animals via the National Animal Identification and Tracing (Nait) programme. Managing director Matt Lythe, who also spoke at the red meat industry event, said the challenge was to accurately understand the conversion of land and animal movements. 'Every consignment will need to have a due diligence statement that essentially monitors every Nait tag, every animal and its passage through the New Zealand landscape and the grazing process through all its dimensions, and whether it's past deforested land or not. 'There are some record-keeping requirements that need to be held in place for five years, so it's a reasonably onerous obligation on us all to achieve.' Its modelling showed there were just under 14,000 hectares of beef production farmland to October 2024 from which forests had been removed, and 1600 'affected Nait' farms. 'So headline number, just under 14,000 hectares have had forest removal,' he told the conference. The main types of removal were pine rotation, followed by woodlots, then shelterbelts. The modelling showed 32 hectares of indigenous forest were removed, affecting 24 farms. 'I've highlighted the indigenous loss as really the key critical area that we're focusing on. 'Thirty-two hectares of indigenous forest in New Zealand has been removed that breaches that European rule.' Owners of farms deemed to have been deforested would need to demonstrate to Prism that the removal of trees was not to convert land for agricultural use. Lythe said farmers could mitigate the risk of cattle crossing into deforested land through fencing or other controls, and demonstrate that the removal of trees was due to either animal welfare, erosion control, health and safety or conservation and biodiversity protection. The New Zealand Deforestation Map will be updated before December and updated every year. The Meat Industry Association is then expected to engage with the wider sector. - RNZ
Scoop
2 hours ago
- Scoop
UN Official Reiterates Call For Gaza Ceasefire As ‘Nightmare Of Historic Proportions' Unfolds
23 July 2025 Khaled Khiari, Assistant Secretary-General for the Middle East, told ministers and ambassadors that ongoing talks must lead to a permanent end to hostilities, the release of all hostages, unimpeded entry of humanitarian aid and for recovery and reconstruction to begin. He painted a grim picture of conditions on the ground, citing expanded Israeli military operations, particularly in Deir Al-Balah, which have led to further mass displacement. UN premises were also struck, hampering humanitarian operations and exacerbating the already dire situation. ASG Khiari briefs the Security Council. Humanitarian toll deepens At least 1,891 Palestinians have been killed in Gaza since 30 June, according to figures from Gazan health authorities, including 294 people reportedly killed while attempting to collect aid near militarised distribution points. Evacuation orders continue to force repeated displacement while food insecurity and malnutrition are worsening despite a limited uptick in the entry of humanitarian supplies. On the Israeli side, 13 soldiers have been killed in the same period. Palestinian armed groups have continued sporadic rocket attacks into Israel. According to Israeli sources, 50 hostages, including 28 believed to be dead, are still being held by Hamas and other groups. ' The Secretary-General has repeatedly condemned the continued holding of hostages by Hamas and other armed groups,' Mr. Khiari stressed. ' Hostages must be released immediately and unconditionally. ' Places of worship struck The briefing also highlighted growing concerns about civilian casualties and attacks on protected sites. Mr. Khiari condemned a 17 July strike on the Catholic Church of the Holy Family in Gaza City, which killed three and injured several others. The strike forced the evacuation of roughly 600 Palestinians, including children and persons with special needs, who had been sheltering there. The Israeli Prime Minister's Office expressed regret, describing the strike as the result of 'stray ammunition' and said an investigation was underway, Mr. Khiari reported. Dire fuel shortages Since 9 July, Israel has allowed limited fuel deliveries through the Kerem Shalom/Karim Abu Salem crossing after 130 days of a full blockade. However, the amount is ' a fraction of what is required to run essential life-saving services in Gaza, where nearly every aspect of life depends on fuel ', Mr. Khiari warned. Occupied West Bank Turning to the occupied West Bank, Mr. Khiari reported high levels of violence, including deadly Israeli military operations, attacks by settlers on Palestinians and retaliatory attacks by Palestinians against Israelis. He noted that the Palestinian Authority (PA) is facing a severe fiscal crisis, with $2.7 billion in withheld clearance revenues, crippling its ability to pay salaries and provide basic services. ' Unless urgently addressed, the deterioration of the PA's fiscal and institutional situation could have catastrophic consequences, undermining the significant progress made over many years to build up Palestinian institutions,' he warned, urging immediate international support. Tensions in the wider region Mr. Khiari also highlighted continued tensions along the Blue Line between Lebanon and Israel as well as renewed violence in Syria's Sweida region and Israeli airstrikes on Syrian territory. He urged both Israel and Syria to adhere to the 1974 Disengagement Agreement and to avoid any actions that risk escalating the conflict. Call for a political horizon Mr. Khiari concluded by reiterating that only a revived political process towards the two-State solution can deliver a sustainable solution. ' Our goal is clear: realising the vision of two States – Israel and a viable and sovereign Palestinian State of which Gaza is an integral part – living side by side in peace and security within secure and recognised borders on the basis of the pre-1967 lines with Jerusalem as the capital of both States,' he said.
NZ Herald
3 hours ago
- NZ Herald
Israel denies Gaza ‘mass starvation' accusations
Israel has hit back at growing international criticism that it was behind chronic food shortages in Gaza, instead accusing Hamas of deliberately creating a humanitarian crisis in the Palestinian territory.
