Simultaneous elections could lead to 1.5% point rise in GDP growth, Parliamentary panel told
In a joint presentation, Singh and Prachi Mishra, director of Isaac Centre for Public Policy at Ashoka University, said the uptick in growth would amount to ₹4.5 lakh crore in FY24 figures, according to people familiar with the matter. This would be almost half the total health budget or a third of the education budget, they pointed out.
But the two economists also cautioned that the fiscal deficit may rise by 1.3 percentage points due to higher post-election spending.
In their presentation, based on a study published in June 2024, Singh and Mishra referred to the election cycles in India and how simultaneous polls continued till 1967 before some assemblies and Lok Sabha faced different schedules..
When national and state elections were held together in India, including when over 40 per cent of the assemblies went to polls the same year along with the Lok Sabha, they said their studies indicated the capital-to-current spending ratio is 5.4 percentage points higher than after simultaneous elections, indicating a shift towards productive and return-generating investments.
The investment ratio against the gross fixed capital formation also goes up by 0.5 percentage point, reflecting greater investment activity, especially private and foreign, the presentation said.
Singh and Mishra added that frequent elections disrupt economic activity due to uncertainty, adversely impacting manufacturing, construction, tourism and healthcare, with migrant workers frequently returning home and affecting productivity.
Noting that migrants comprise nearly one-third of India's population, they said multiple elections impose financial burden on them, weakening their use of their voting rights.
School enrolment also goes down by 0.5 percentage point around non-simultaneous elections due to the deployment of teachers on election duty and schools being converted into polling booths, they said.
They argued that the diversion of police for frequent electoral duties leads to a growth in crime during non-simultaneous elections due to a longer duration of deployment.
(With PTI inputs)
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Of controversies and incomplete tenures
1 2 Ranchi: The political life of eminent tribal leader and key architect of the formation of Jharkhand state, Shibu Soren, has been plagued by controversies. The 'Dishom Guru' struggled to complete his tenure in the Union govt as well as in the state. Soren served as the chief minister three times, but he held office cumulatively for only 308 days. His shortest tenure lasted just 10 days, from March 2 to March 12, 2005. In 2009, while he was still serving as the chief minister, Shibu was defeated in the Tamar by-election by Raja Peter. He was appointed as the Union coal minister in former Prime Minister Manmohan Singh's cabinet, following the alliance between JMM and UPA for the Lok Sabha polls in 2004. However, a three-decade-old Chirudih massacre case returned to haunt him. Facing potential arrest, Shibu went underground for several days before resigning from the Union govt on July 24, 2004. In November of that year, after securing bail, Shibu was reappointed as coal minister in Manmohan's cabinet. However, he was removed again in March 2005 due to a murder case in 1994, involving his secretary, Sashinath Jha, who was allegedly attempting to blackmail him in a "cash for vote scam" that was aimed at saving former PM Narasimha Rao's govt in 1993. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like This Bond Accounts offers a 6%+ yield on your investment 6% Yield Bond Account Learn More Undo In January 2006, Shibu returned as a Union minister but was forced to resign in November after Delhi's Tis Hazari court found him guilty of Jha's murder. Shibu was allegedly accused of abducting Jha from Delhi on May 22, 1994, and having him killed in Ranchi. The CBI's charge-sheet claimed that Jha was aware of a monetary arrangement between Congress and JMM to avert a no-confidence motion against the Narasimha Rao govt in 1993 and was "blackmailing" Shibu for money, allegedly resulting in the murder. In the end, Shibu was acquitted in all the cases -- Kudko, Chirudih, Shashinath Jha murder and vote-for-cash scam.
Time of India
2 hours ago
- Time of India
Eyes on Hemant-Kalpana duo to carry forward legacy
1 2 Ranchi: In an early morning tweet, chief minister Hemant Soren wrote, "Respected Guru Dishom has left us all. Today, I have become empty..." The early morning tweet left a trail of grief not just in Jharkhand but across the country's political spectrum as the JMM founder and patriarch Shibu Soren, 81, died after battling illness in a Delhi hospital for over a month. For the Soren junior, who is running an alliance govt in the state for the second consecutive term, stepping into his father's shoes full-time and keeping all tribals united under his party — JMM — may not be a tough task, many political analysts believed. In April this year, Shibu formally made way for Hemant to lead JMM full-time during the party's 13th central convention in Ranchi by appointing the latter as the full-time central president. Shibu, who led the party for 38 consecutive years, assumed the role of founding patron of the party. A political analyst and professor of DSPMU, Vinay Bharat, said the 2024 Lok Sabha and assembly polls not only established Hemant as a mature and astute leader, but that year, amid turbulent political times, a new leader, Kalpana Soren, Hemant's wife, came to the fore. "Between 2019 and 2024, when Hemant was leading the alliance govt, he underwent numerous challenges, from ED probes to office for profit cases, among others. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Elevate Business Writing With This Desktop App Grammarly Learn More Undo But despite the obstacles, his return to office with greater might in the 2024 election without surrendering to political pressure has finally established him nationally," Bharat remarked, adding that while Shibu's physical departure happened only on Monday, he was away from public life for quite some years. Another political analyst and retired journalist, Om Prakash Ashk, said the 2024 election year gave birth to not just one but two leaders within the JMM ranks, which today is a formidable combination. "Year 2024 was a make-or-break moment for JMM given the kind of tussle within the party ranks and files, desertion of veteran leaders like Sita Soren, Champai Soren, and most importantly, Hemant going to jail... The way Hemant and Kalpana, fought back established their credibility within their voter base. Their people saw Guruji's virtues in them as Shibu was synonymous with aandolan (struggle)," Ashk. After walking out of jail last year in June, Hemant adopted Shibu's look, donning a long beard, which struck a chord with the voters, Ashk added. The way Hemant stood by his ailing father, shuffling between Ranchi and Delhi, to personally oversee treatment while taking care of governance simultaneously, has already struck a chord among the ardent Shibu supporters, said many. Ranchi University's Sanjay Singh said, "Even though he was a reluctant politician, Hemant has grown into a mature leader today, capable of taking the fight alone. The demise of Guruji is definitely going to create a vacuum both in the party and family, but it isn't going to hurt the political prospects at the moment as he is among the tribal leaders in national politics." The emergence of the Hemant-Kalpana duo has further scuttled the prospects of infighting within the family, he added. Bharat complemented, saying, "Hemant's younger brother Basant Soren, also an MLA, is already subdued as he knows he doesn't have greater acceptance. Their bhabi, Sita Soren, after joining BJP, is also said to be trying to return to JMM."
Time of India
2 hours ago
- Time of India
How Nemra's Shibu made Santhal Parganas his citadel
Dumka: The news of the death of the JMM patriarch, Shibu Soren, while being admitted at Sir Gangaram Hospital in New Delhi for the last month, cast a pall of gloom over Dumka in particular and the entire Santhal Pargana at large. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now The region proved to be his karma bhumi, having accorded him the status of a towering figure of the tribal society at the national level. Transformed from Shivcharan Marandi (his former name) to Shibu Soren after jointly forming the JMM along with A K Rai and Vinod Bihari Mahto, the separation of Jharkhand from the erstwhile undivided Bihar was its ultimate political objective. His further transformation to be the Dishom Guru (mentor of the tribals across the country) took place in Santhal Pargana, which emerged as the epicentre of the statehood movement that he led for over three decades by mobilising the local tribal community and other native residents. "We learnt about someone called Shibu Soren becoming popular among the tribals and other marginalised communities in terms of raising their voices against exploitation. It was then that we called on him at Tundi in Dhanbad to request him to come to Santhal Pargana in the late seventies to guide the community members against the oppressive practice of money lending and grabbing of tribal lands," veteran JMM leader, the late Simon Marandi, had once said. Due to his charismatic leadership quality, Shibu soon became an iconic figure among the local tribals, particularly Santhals, resisting the administrative arrangements against the proposed meetings elsewhere to undo the same. "It was by then that the slogan 'Kaisi lenge Jharkhand, lad ke lenge Jharkhand' (How to get Jharkhand, to get it by fighting) was coined," recalled Jitendra Singh, a JMM revolutionary. "It was due to Guruji's inclusive philosophy that even the non-tribal populace of Santhal Pargana started admiring him," said Jitendra, now in his late fifties. Shibu was first elected to the Lok Sabha in 1980 from Dumka. He represented this seat in 1989, 1991, 1996, 2004, and 2014 general elections, apart from serving as chief minister of Jharkhand three times.
