Yankees Face 'All-Around Terrible' Giancarlo Stanton Decision After Brutal Injury
The New York Yankees might have avoided a worst-case scenario on Aaron Judge, but the reality is still far from pleasant.
As the team endures a marked fall from grace after a torrid start to the year, it has placed the franchise slugger on the injured list with a strained flexor tendon. He is expected to return this season, but the fallout from that brutal injury will still be far reaching.
Without Judge to carry the batting order, the team could be changing its approach to the trade deadline with less confidence that bringing in some win-now talent can propel a championship. And Judge's injury could drive a surprising change for designated hitter Giancarlo Stanton as well.
"Yes, Judge can still swing with a bad flexor, but where does that leave Stanton?" Yankees columnist Bob Klapisch asked for NJ.com. "Back to the outfield, which is an all-around terrible idea. Give Stanton credit for a good attitude — 'I'll do whatever it takes' — but let's be serious about a defender who's afraid to run, lest he gets hurt again."
TORONTO, ON - JULY 21: Giancarlo Stanton #27 of the New York Yankees walks to the dugout during a game against the Toronto Blue Jays at Rogers Centre on July 21, 2025 in Toronto, Ontario,...
TORONTO, ON - JULY 21: Giancarlo Stanton #27 of the New York Yankees walks to the dugout during a game against the Toronto Blue Jays at Rogers Centre on July 21, 2025 in Toronto, Ontario, Canada. (Photo by) More
Ridley/Getty
The Yankees have plenty of outfield options even without Judge, including Cody Bellinger, Trent Grisham and Jasson Dominguez. But if Judge has to move to an everyday designated hitter role, there could be no way for the Yankees to get at-bats for Stanton without putting him back into the outfield for the first time in two years.
Still, Stanton is such a defensive liability and at so much risk of injury himself that the team might be forced to choose between at-bats for him or Judge for a significant stretch of the season. Judge's injury might have been worse, but even a slight setback for the franchise star seems like a major problem for the Yankees.
"All of which is to say, if the Yankees were going nowhere with a healthy Judge and his MVP-caliber production, imagine what the next couple of weeks will be without him," Klapisch added. "Think July's been a rough month in the Bronx? Just wait. It's about to get a lot worse."
After a high-octane start to the year, the Yankees are suddenly facing some tough decisions.
More MLB: Yankees Make Trade, Send Veteran Pitcher to Atlanta Ahead of Trade Deadline
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New York Times
9 minutes ago
- New York Times
WNBA mailbag: Submit your questions
We're in the second half of the WNBA season and the playoff race is on. Which teams are making a push? Who's having an MVP season? What's going to happen with the collective bargaining agreement negotiations? Submit your questions in the comment section, and our expert, Sabreena Merchant, will answer later this week.
Yahoo
36 minutes ago
- Yahoo
When Addison Barger hits a changeup, Blue Jays star homers 13% of the time
Who knew that Addison Barger was the changeup crusher? The Toronto Blue Jays' breakout lefty hitter has mashed against all sorts of offerings this season, but he's had an absurd campaign against changeups. The latest moment came Tuesday afternoon when Barger got a changeup from Charlie Morton and blasted a two-run home run. After Barger rounded the bases, Sportsnet play-by-play man Dan Shulman shared a stat that was hard to believe. Barger has had 54 at bats this season end with a changeup. Seven of those have resulted in homers, a 13% rate. It seemed too good to be true, but Barger's Baseball Savant page confirms the data as Shulman presented it. MORE: Corbin Carroll is unmatched in MLB history Barger has five singles and two doubles this season off changeups (technically splitters and forkballs would fall into this classification, too), but the seven homers show that's not necessarily a pitch you want to throw to the Blue Jays slugger. Hitting changeups is a skill requiring a bat that stays through the zone a long time, and a lower half that hangs back just long enough to adjust to the offspeed pitch. Barger clearly has that skill down, and he showed it again on Tuesday afternoon. MORE MLB NEWS: Dodgers sign Missouri football's QB to contract Blue Jays make Toronto history not achieved since 1992 World Series team Emmanuel Clase goes from trade target to concerning Guardians story Orioles' catcher used a Happy Gilmore swing to hit a home run There's a sad truth to Aaron Judge's injury for Yankees Edwin Diaz is MLB's best pitcher since learning his legs were different lengths
Newsweek
36 minutes ago
- Newsweek
MLB Insider Predicts Yankees Trade For Diamondbacks' $13.5M All-Star
Based on facts, either observed and verified firsthand by the reporter, or reported and verified from knowledgeable sources. Newsweek AI is in beta. Translations may contain inaccuracies—please refer to the original content. Baseball season is heating up, but the New York Yankees have cooled off dramatically. Sitting at 22-28 in their last 50 games, the Yankees have turned a seven-game lead in the American League East into a 5 1/2-game deficit. They're now missing superstar Aaron Judge for what they hope is only about 10 games, and their pitching staff is shorthanded. By the Thursday trade deadline, the Yankees have to add pitching reinforcements if they want any shot at defending their AL pennant from last season. PHOENIX, ARIZONA - MARCH 29: Zac Gallen #23 greets starting pitcher Merrill Kelly #29 of the Arizona Diamondbacks after Kelly was removed from the game during the seventh inning against the Colorado Rockies at Chase... PHOENIX, ARIZONA - MARCH 29: Zac Gallen #23 greets starting pitcher Merrill Kelly #29 of the Arizona Diamondbacks after Kelly was removed from the game during the seventh inning against the Colorado Rockies at Chase Field on March 29, 2024 in Phoenix, Arizona. MoreThat's why one insider foresees the Yankees acquiring a former All-Star starting pitcher with World Series experience. On Tuesday, Jim Bowden of The Athletic predicted that the Yankees would bring Arizona Diamondbacks starter Zac Gallen to New York ahead of the 6 p.m. ET Thursday deadline. "The Yankees solved their third-base situation with the trade for Ryan McMahon, then added infielder Amed Rosario, who provides versatility and a good bat versus lefties (.829 OPS)," wrote Bowden. "Now, they are focused on acquiring a starting pitcher and a reliever or two. They will not trade outfielder Spencer Jones or shortstop George Lombard Jr., but are open-minded about swapping their other top prospects in the right deal." Gallen, who turns 30 on Sunday, is a huge reason the Diamondbacks are surprise sellers at this deadline. He's got a brutal 5.60 ERA this season, in large part because he's given up a National League-high 23 home runs. Plus, Gallen is expensive, which might actually work in the Yankees' favor. He'd be owed the remainder of his $13.5 million salary by the acquiring team, though one figures most contenders are prepared to add a bit of payroll. The real question is whether or not the Yankees think the 2023 All-Star who shined in the World Series that year is still hidden among the peripheral stats. More MLB: Dodgers Should Pursue Orioles' 'Hidden Gem' in Last-Minute Deadline Deal
