$300m SWAT project progress unsatisfactory: World Bank
The Bank in its Implementation Status and Results Report (ISR) also termed the progress toward achievement of project development objective moderately satisfactory.
The project was approved in December 2022 with the development objective to increase agricultural water productivity in selected farmers' organization command areas, improve integrated water resources management, and contribute to restoring crop production by small and medium-sized farmers affected by the 2022 floods.
Sindh takes significant stride towards water sustainability
Official documents revealed that the project continues to advance implementation on several fronts, although experiencing some delays. Water Resources: The design of the Hydro-Agro Informatics program under the auspices of the Irrigation Department and the Agriculture Department is underway. After the design is completed, implementation of key activities will start in 2026.
A first draft water resources bill has been prepared and is being reviewed by the Irrigation Department. The Sindh Law and Parliamentary Affairs Department submits a draft water resources bill for consideration by the Sindh Provincial Assembly that replaces the Irrigation Act (1879) and the Sindh Water Management Ordinance (2002) to create a unified legal framework for IWRM and irrigation services.
Further the Sindh Irrigation Department undertakes a water pricing reform study, and increases Abiana rates after due consideration of study recommendations. The Water Pricing Study will be informed by the ongoing Federal Water Pricing Study.
Farmer Organization (FOs) Sub-Projects: The Irrigation Department and the Agriculture Department are working with three pilot FOs to formulate area development plans (ADP) which will identify priority investments in irrigation and agriculture. Akram Wah Rehabilitation sub-project procurement activities are underway with contract award expected in early 2026.
The Agriculture Department has advanced work related to crop reporting, soil salinity management, value chain development. Discussions on wheat monitoring and agriculture research policy are underway. Flood Emergency Response (FERC) payments are expected to conclude later in 2025.
Project documents noted that Area Development Plans (ADP) for the three pilot FOs are under preparation. Subproject assessment reports will evaluate the change in agricultural surface water productivity (crop revenue divided by total volume of surface water supplied in PKR/m3) attributable to the project.
Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Recorder
4 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Pakistan's Rs7.2trn annual debt burden should finance growth-generating activities, says think tank
ISLAMABAD: Economic Policy & Business Development (EPBD) a think tank, called for fundamental restructuring of Pakistan's debt utilisation, advocating that borrowed resources be diverted from unproductive consumption toward productive economic investment. EPBD maintained that Pakistan's Rs7.2 trillion annual debt burden should finance growth-generating activities rather than subsidising banking profits and inefficient state-owned enterprises. The think tank claimed that the World Bank article in United Nations Development Programme (UNDP) latest development report validates this position, explicitly stating that Pakistan's debt is 'mostly used to finance consumption rather than investment' and that 'public borrowing continues to crowd out private sector credit.' Govt officials on boards of cos: remuneration restriction lifted The institution documented that Pakistan 'contracts new debt equal to around 28% of GDP annually' while allocating merely '2% of GDP' to development spending - a stark indicator of resource misallocation. Moreover, EPBD had stated that the ratio of current consumption to actual development deteriorated from 2.2:1 to 10.3:1 over a period of 15 years, demonstrating systematic shift away from productive investment. EPBD argued that Pakistan's current approach wastes borrowed capital on guaranteed banking returns through government bond purchases and state-owned enterprises (SOE) subsidies that generate no economic returns. Instead, the debt should finance manufacturing expansion, export infrastructure, technology adoption, and private sector development that creates employment and generates sustainable returns to service future obligations, the think tank said. EPBD added that Pakistani businesses face 11% financing costs compared to 5.5% regional averages, making them uncompetitive while banks earn guaranteed profits from public funds. With 59% of government debt in floating-rate instruments, reducing policy rates from 11% to 6% would generate Rs3 trillion annually - resources currently transferred to financial institutions rather than productive economic activities. It further stated that the World Bank confirmed that Pakistan 'achieved a primary surplus in fiscal year 2025,' providing fiscal space to redirect debt utilization. Rather than continuing current patterns of consumption-focused borrowing, EPBD advocated channeling these resources toward manufacturing competitiveness, export development, and business expansion that builds Pakistan's capacity to service debt through productive economic activity. Regional competitors demonstrate superior performance by utilising borrowed funds for business development and industrial expansion rather than banking sector subsidisation and SOE support. Their approach generates 6% annual growth by directing debt toward activities that create value, employment, and sustainable economic returns, according to EPBD. Govt notifies 7% hike in federal pensions from July 1 EPBD maintained that Pakistan must choose between what it called wasteful debt utilisation that enriches financial institutions and SOEs versus productive debt deployment that builds economic capacity. The organisation advocated immediate policy realignment to redirect borrowed resources from unproductive consumption toward manufacturing development, export infrastructure, technology adoption, and private sector expansion that generates sustainable returns and employment.
Business Recorder
3 days ago
- Business Recorder
$300m SWAT project progress unsatisfactory: World Bank
ISLAMABAD: The World Bank has rated the overall implementation progress of 'Sindh Water and Agriculture Transformation (SWAT)' project worth around $300 million moderately unsatisfactory which envisaged to increase agricultural water productivity in selected farmers' organization command areas, improve integrated water resources management, and contribute to restoring crop production by small and medium-sized farmers affected by the 2022 floods. The Bank in its Implementation Status and Results Report (ISR) also termed the progress toward achievement of project development objective moderately satisfactory. The project was approved in December 2022 with the development objective to increase agricultural water productivity in selected farmers' organization command areas, improve integrated water resources management, and contribute to restoring crop production by small and medium-sized farmers affected by the 2022 floods. Sindh takes significant stride towards water sustainability Official documents revealed that the project continues to advance implementation on several fronts, although experiencing some delays. Water Resources: The design of the Hydro-Agro Informatics program under the auspices of the Irrigation Department and the Agriculture Department is underway. After the design is completed, implementation of key activities will start in 2026. A first draft water resources bill has been prepared and is being reviewed by the Irrigation Department. The Sindh Law and Parliamentary Affairs Department submits a draft water resources bill for consideration by the Sindh Provincial Assembly that replaces the Irrigation Act (1879) and the Sindh Water Management Ordinance (2002) to create a unified legal framework for IWRM and irrigation services. Further the Sindh Irrigation Department undertakes a water pricing reform study, and increases Abiana rates after due consideration of study recommendations. The Water Pricing Study will be informed by the ongoing Federal Water Pricing Study. Farmer Organization (FOs) Sub-Projects: The Irrigation Department and the Agriculture Department are working with three pilot FOs to formulate area development plans (ADP) which will identify priority investments in irrigation and agriculture. Akram Wah Rehabilitation sub-project procurement activities are underway with contract award expected in early 2026. The Agriculture Department has advanced work related to crop reporting, soil salinity management, value chain development. Discussions on wheat monitoring and agriculture research policy are underway. Flood Emergency Response (FERC) payments are expected to conclude later in 2025. Project documents noted that Area Development Plans (ADP) for the three pilot FOs are under preparation. Subproject assessment reports will evaluate the change in agricultural surface water productivity (crop revenue divided by total volume of surface water supplied in PKR/m3) attributable to the project. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Business Recorder
3 days ago
- Business Recorder
Combating climate chaos: call to action
EDITORIAL: Speaking at the opening of an aid conference in Seville city of Spain on Monday, UN Secretary-General Antonio Guterres noted that a two-thirds of the UN's sustainable development goals set for 2030 are off track, and over US$ 4 trillion in annual investment is needed to combat climate chaos and support the world's most vulnerable populations. His message basically highlights the fact that climate change is no longer a distant threat; it is already upon us and accelerating. From record-breaking heatwaves in Europe and North America to cycles of deadly floods and droughts in South Asia and Africa, climate-related disasters are exacting a rising toll on human lives, economies, and ecological systems. A key issue on the agenda in Seville was the urgent need to reform the international financial system to help poorer nations free themselves from mounting debt burdens that inhibit their respective capacity to achieve progress in healthcare, education and climate resilience. As per UN data, the total external debt of the least developed countries has more than tripled over the past 15 years. Many nations in the Global South, like Pakistan, have too small a carbon footprint, yet are most vulnerable to climate disasters brought on by global warming. Already facing the brunt of floods and droughts, they are forced to divert scarce resources away from economic development to debt servicing. The result is perpetuation of underdevelopment, vulnerability, and inequality. No surprise, then, that there is growing criticism from the Global South of the US-dominated global financial system, created in the aftermath of World War II, which they argue no longer reflects realities of today's interconnected world. Greater representation and equity are urgently needed. The UN chief has also highlighted a glaring imbalance: while some nations continue to subsidise fossil fuels, others are left struggling to fund clean energy transitions or recover from climate catastrophes. This is not only unfair; this is dangerously short-sighted. Since we are all in this together the response must reflect that reality. The industrialised wealthiest nations, responsible for the vast majority of historical greenhouse gas emissions, owe a climate debt to developing nations. The Seville conference offers a vital opportunity to reset the climate and development agenda. For far too long, the international financial architecture has served the interests of the rich and powerful nations. What is needed now is major reform of the international finance system, with a focus on increasing access to concessional finance, restructuring unsustainable debt, and introduction of innovative instruments such as climate-resilient debt clauses and green bonds. No less important, institutions like the IMF and the World Bank need to evolve from crisis lenders to proactive enables of sustainable development. The time for decisive, collective action is now. The longer the transition is delayed, the more costly and painful it will become. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
