‘Nineteen Eighty-Four' might have been inspired by author George Orwell's fear of drowning
Having misread the tidal schedules, on the way back Orwell mistakenly piloted the boat into rough swells. He was pulled into the fringe of the Corryvreckan whirlpool off the coasts of Jura and Scarba. The boat capsized and Orwell and his relatives were thrown overboard.
It was a close call – a fact recorded with characteristic detachment by Orwell in his diary that same evening: 'On return journey today ran into the whirlpool & were all nearly drowned.' Though he seems to have taken the experience in his stride, this may have been a trauma response: detachment ensures the ability to persist after a near-death experience.
We don't know for sure if Nineteen Eighty-Four was influenced by the Corryvreckan incident. But it's clear that the novel was written by a man fixated on water's terrifying power.
Nineteen Eighty-Four isn't typically associated with fear of death by water. Yet it's filled with references to sinking ships, drowning people and the dread of oceanic engulfment. Fear of drowning is a torment that social dissidents might face in Room 101, the torture chamber to which all revolutionaries are sent in the appropriately named totalitarian state of Oceania.
An early sequence in the novel describes a helicopter attack on a ship full of refugees, who are bombed as they fall into the sea. The novel's protagonist, Winston Smith, has a recurring nightmare in which he dreams of his long-lost mother and sister trapped 'in the saloon of a sinking ship, looking up at him through the darkening water'.
The sight of them 'drowning deeper every minute' takes Winston back to a culminating moment in his childhood when he stole chocolate from his mother's hand, possibly condemning his sister to starvation. These watery graves imply that Winston is drowning in guilt.
The 'wateriness' of Nineteen Eighty-Four may have another interesting historical source. In his essay My Country Right or Left (1940), Orwell recalls that when he had just become a teenager he read about the 'atrocity stories' of the First World War.
Orwell states in this same essay that 'nothing in the whole war moved [him] so deeply as the loss of the Titanic had done a few years earlier', in 1912. What upset Orwell most about the Titanic disaster was that in its final moments it 'suddenly up-ended and sank bow foremost, so that the people clinging to the stern were lifted no less than 300 feet into the air before they plunged into the abyss'.
Sinking ships and dying civilisations
Orwell never forgot this image. Something similar to it appears in his novel Keep the Aspidistra Flying (1936), where the idea of a sinking passenger liner evokes the collapse of modern civilisation, just as the Titanic disaster evoked the end of Edwardian industrial confidence two decades beforehand.
Sinking ships were part of Orwell's descriptive toolkit. In Nineteen Eighty-Four, a novel driven by memories of unsympathetic water, they convey nightmares. Filled with references to water and liquidity, it's one of the most aqueous novels Orwell produced, relying for many of its most shocking episodes on imagery of desperate people drowning or facing imminent death on sinking sea craft.
The thought of trapped passengers descending into the depths survives in Winston's traumatic memories of his mother and sister, who, in the logic of his dreams, are alive inside a sinking ship's saloon.
There's no way to prove that Nineteen Eighty-Four is 'about' the Titanic disaster, but in the novel, and indeed in Orwell's wider body of work, there are too many tantalising hints to let the matter rest.
Thinking about fear of death by water takes us into Orwell's terrors just as it takes us into Winston's, allowing readers to see the frightened boy inside the adult man and, indeed, inside the author who dreamed up one of the 20th century's most famous nightmares.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Indian Express
3 hours ago
- Indian Express
DU's undergraduates can now exit after 3 years under four-year programme. Check the details
For the first time, Delhi University (DU) has formally opened the 'exit option' for undergraduate students who have completed three years under the National Education Policy (NEP), 2020. This marks a major step forward in the roll-out of the Four-Year Undergraduate Programme (FYUP). The notification, issued on Thursday, comes as DU students are preparing to enter the final year of the four-year degree structure for the first time since the university adopted NEP. Last month, the Academic Council had approved the curriculum for the seventh and eighth semesters, finalising the academic blueprint for the fourth year. Now, with DU offering an official exit route, students who have successfully completed six semesters (three years) can choose to graduate early with a recognised degree. 'Students enrolled in the four-year Undergraduate Curriculum Framework 2022 based on the NEP 2020 and have successfully completed six semesters (three years) are eligible to submit their intent to exit the programme with a three-year degree for multi-core discipline programmes and an Honours degree for single core discipline programmes, as applicable,' stated the notification issued by the Registrar. The move operationalises NEP 2020's provision for multiple entry and exit points in higher education. The DU has advised eligible students to submit their intent on the university portal. 'This initiative aligns with the NEP 2020's emphasis on providing multiple entry and exit points in higher education, offering students enhanced autonomy over their educational pathways,' the notification stated. University officials have also encouraged students to consult teachers and mentors before opting to exit, citing the importance of aligning academic decisions with long-term goals. 'The university encourages eligible students to carefully evaluate their academic and career goals before making this decision and recommends consulting with their teachers and mentors to ensure informed decision-making,' the notification added.
The Hindu
8 hours ago
- The Hindu
DU notifies exit option for third-year FYUP students
The University of Delhi (DU) on Thursday notified that third-year students of the Four-Year Undergraduate Programme (FYUP) are now eligible to exit the programme with a graduation degree. The first batch of the FYUP, implemented in 2022, will advance into its fourth or final year this month. The notification comes at a time when several students have been complaining about the lack of clarity regarding the course exit. 'Students enrolled in the four-year undergraduate curriculum framework 2022 based on the National Education Policy (NEP) 2020 and have successfully completing six semesters (three years) are eligible to submit their intent to exit the program with a three-year degree for multi-core discipline programmes and Honours degree for single core discipline programmes, as applicable,' read the notification issued by Registrar. 'The university encourages eligible students to carefully evaluate their academic and career goals before making this decision and recommends consulting with their teachers and mentors to ensure informed decision-making,' it added. The university said that the notification aligned with the NEP's emphasis on multiple entry and exit points in higher education, offering students enhanced autonomy and educational pathways.
Scroll.in
7 days ago
- Scroll.in
‘Nineteen Eighty-Four' might have been inspired by author George Orwell's fear of drowning
George Orwell had a traumatic relationship with the sea. In August 1947, while he was writing Nineteen Eighty-Four (1949) on the island of Jura in the Scottish Hebrides, he went on a fishing trip with his young son, nephew and niece. Having misread the tidal schedules, on the way back Orwell mistakenly piloted the boat into rough swells. He was pulled into the fringe of the Corryvreckan whirlpool off the coasts of Jura and Scarba. The boat capsized and Orwell and his relatives were thrown overboard. It was a close call – a fact recorded with characteristic detachment by Orwell in his diary that same evening: 'On return journey today ran into the whirlpool & were all nearly drowned.' Though he seems to have taken the experience in his stride, this may have been a trauma response: detachment ensures the ability to persist after a near-death experience. We don't know for sure if Nineteen Eighty-Four was influenced by the Corryvreckan incident. But it's clear that the novel was written by a man fixated on water's terrifying power. Nineteen Eighty-Four isn't typically associated with fear of death by water. Yet it's filled with references to sinking ships, drowning people and the dread of oceanic engulfment. Fear of drowning is a torment that social dissidents might face in Room 101, the torture chamber to which all revolutionaries are sent in the appropriately named totalitarian state of Oceania. An early sequence in the novel describes a helicopter attack on a ship full of refugees, who are bombed as they fall into the sea. The novel's protagonist, Winston Smith, has a recurring nightmare in which he dreams of his long-lost mother and sister trapped 'in the saloon of a sinking ship, looking up at him through the darkening water'. The sight of them 'drowning deeper every minute' takes Winston back to a culminating moment in his childhood when he stole chocolate from his mother's hand, possibly condemning his sister to starvation. These watery graves imply that Winston is drowning in guilt. The 'wateriness' of Nineteen Eighty-Four may have another interesting historical source. In his essay My Country Right or Left (1940), Orwell recalls that when he had just become a teenager he read about the 'atrocity stories' of the First World War. Orwell states in this same essay that 'nothing in the whole war moved [him] so deeply as the loss of the Titanic had done a few years earlier', in 1912. What upset Orwell most about the Titanic disaster was that in its final moments it 'suddenly up-ended and sank bow foremost, so that the people clinging to the stern were lifted no less than 300 feet into the air before they plunged into the abyss'. Sinking ships and dying civilisations Orwell never forgot this image. Something similar to it appears in his novel Keep the Aspidistra Flying (1936), where the idea of a sinking passenger liner evokes the collapse of modern civilisation, just as the Titanic disaster evoked the end of Edwardian industrial confidence two decades beforehand. Sinking ships were part of Orwell's descriptive toolkit. In Nineteen Eighty-Four, a novel driven by memories of unsympathetic water, they convey nightmares. Filled with references to water and liquidity, it's one of the most aqueous novels Orwell produced, relying for many of its most shocking episodes on imagery of desperate people drowning or facing imminent death on sinking sea craft. The thought of trapped passengers descending into the depths survives in Winston's traumatic memories of his mother and sister, who, in the logic of his dreams, are alive inside a sinking ship's saloon. There's no way to prove that Nineteen Eighty-Four is 'about' the Titanic disaster, but in the novel, and indeed in Orwell's wider body of work, there are too many tantalising hints to let the matter rest. Thinking about fear of death by water takes us into Orwell's terrors just as it takes us into Winston's, allowing readers to see the frightened boy inside the adult man and, indeed, inside the author who dreamed up one of the 20th century's most famous nightmares.
