American Idol fans outraged over Carrie Underwood weird comments to contestant Jamal Roberts as the Top 3 is revealed
American Idol judge Carrie Underwood is coming under fire from fans after some bizarre comments to singer Jamal Roberts.
The 42-year-old singer joined the judge's panel this season, replacing Katy Perry, 20 years after the Idol win that launched her career.
Only five singers remained - Slater Nalley, John Foster, Thunderstorm Artis, Breanna Nix and Jamal Roberts - after Gabby Samone and Mattie Pruitt were sent home on Sunday.
All five singers performed twice once again, with two singers being sent home via America's vote when it was all said and done - Slater Nalley and Thunderstorm Artis.
While fans were outraged by Sunday night's results, that wasn't necessarily the case on Monday's episode, though many did take Underwood to task.
Many were furious after she told the 27-year-old Roberts, now the last Black singer left in the field, to 'move around and entertain.'
Roberts chose Marvin Gaye and Tammi Terrell's Ain't No Mountain High Enough from the 2000 Disney sports film Remember the Titans, with Luke Bryan and Lionel Richie giving him a standing ovation while Carrie Underwood remained seated.
His performance elicited a huge response from the crowd, with judge Luke Bryan saying, 'You deserve every bit of this.'
Lionel Richie was floored by his ability to transform certain songs, which he called the singer's ability to, 'Jamalerize' a song, adding the performance was, 'amazing' while encouraging fans to vote.
While Carrie Underwood admitted that Jamal's, 'voice is incredible,' she surprised many fans by saying, 'I feel like you missed such an opportunity to move around and entertain.'
She added, 'We are getting close to the end here, it is time to pull out all the stops. And we know you have that in you. So like pull us all in not just with your voice but everything else going on. Put 100% of yourself into it. Let's go.'
After his second performance - a soulful rendition of the title song from Disney's Beauty and the Beast, Carrie was seemingly speechless, telling the other judges to speak.
Lionel said that only Jamal could pull off turning Beauty and the Beast into an R&B song while Luke simply said, 'Let's win this thing, baby! Let's win this thing!'
Jamal was voted through to the Top 3 and will have a chance to win the competition on Sunday night's finale, though many found Carrie's comments quite off-putting.
Roberts chose Marvin Gaye and Tammi Terrell's Ain't No Mountain High Enough from the 2000 Disney sports film Remember the Titans, with Luke Bryan and Lionel Richie giving him a standing ovation while Carrie Underwood remained seated.
Jamal was voted through to the Top 3 and will have a chance to win the competition on Sunday night's finale, though many found Carrie's comments quite off-putting
In fact, some even went so far as to say that they didn't want to see her return to the judge's table for Season 24.
A fan named Brianna (@lakenbriannaxo) said, 'What kills me is Carrie telling Jamal he needs to move around but these others are staying in the same spot and not moving.'
Another fan dubbed @topfloordes said, 'Something about Carrie…….i can't put my finger on it but she's not genuine and doesn't like soulful singers, she doesn't care for runs etc. she thinks country is the only genre out there.'
LaDawna (@LaDawna_writes) said, '#AmericanIdol folks have stood still all season and Carrie decides to tell Jamal to move around and dance. Annoying!'
Lady Kaija (@LadyKaija) insisted, 'Carrie DEFINITELY DOES NOT LIKE JAMAL AT ALL, and she'll do ANYTHING TO SABOTAGE his win! I pray GOD shuts her down once n for all! Jamal is God's Property!'
The same user added, 'It's pretty pathetic that Carrie would criticize Jamal - but to be fair... She gritted on him during his entire performance! She OBVIOUSLY DOES NOT LIKE JAMAL, and she's BLATANTLY OBVIOUS! WATCH.'
Katherine Lind (@katherinelind92), added, 'Carrie have no rights to use that attitude with Jamal.'
Another user dubbed @Gawjussraeee said, 'Carrie can go ahead & sit next season out. Im not feeling her.'
A fan named Brianna (@lakenbriannaxo) said, 'What kills me is Carrie telling Jamal he needs to move around but these others are staying in the same spot and not moving.'
Another fan dubbed @topfloordes said, 'Something about Carrie…….i can't put my finger on it but she's not genuine and doesn't like soulful singers, she doesn't care for runs etc. she thinks country is the only genre out there'
LaDawna (@LaDawna_writes) said, '#AmericanIdol folks have stood still all season and Carrie decides to tell Jamal to move around and dance. Annoying!'
The same user added, 'It's pretty pathetic that Carrie would criticize Jamal - but to be fair... She gritted on him during his entire performance! She OBVIOUSLY DOES NOT LIKE JAMAL, and she's BLATANTLY OBVIOUS! WATCH.'
The same user added, 'It's pretty pathetic that Carrie would criticize Jamal - but to be fair... She gritted on him during his entire performance! She OBVIOUSLY DOES NOT LIKE JAMAL, and she's BLATANTLY OBVIOUS! WATCH.'
Katherine Lind (@katherinelind92), added, 'Carrie have no rights to use that attitude with Jamal'
Another user dubbed @Gawjussraeee said, 'Carrie can go ahead & sit next season out. Im not feeling her.'
Butta J (@ButtaKupJ) said, 'Dear Carrie, this is flat foot singing! He don't have to do flips! Shiiid you didn't do any when you was on the show. This man is sanging! Vote for Team Jamal Roberts #AmericanIdol.'
ForeverInFantasyLand (@WhittyWhit86) said, 'I feel like Carrie Underwood should have dressed up as the Evil Queen with the mean faces she's making #AmericanIdol.'
Penny Pumpkin (@pennypumpkin33) said, 'Was waiting for Carrie to tell Jamal he should have done a handstand during his performance.'
Butta J (@ButtaKupJ) said, 'Dear Carrie, this is flat foot singing! He don't have to do flips! Shiiid you didn't do any when you was on the show. This man is sanging! Vote for Team Jamal Roberts #AmericanIdol.'
ForeverInFantasyLand (@WhittyWhit86) said, 'I feel like Carrie Underwood should have dressed up as the Evil Queen with the mean faces she's making #AmericanIdol.'
Penny Pumpkin (@pennypumpkin33) said, 'Was waiting for Carrie to tell Jamal he should have done a handstand during his performance.'
American Idol closes out Season 23 with the epic finale Sunday, May 18 at 8 PM ET on ABC.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
30 minutes ago
- The Independent
Farewell, Anna Wintour – the Queen of editors with a nuclear-force superpower
Farewell, Anna Wintour: sphinx-faced, super-enduring doyenne of global fashion. The news that the editor-in-chief of US Vogue has stepped down after 37 years marks the end of an era, but I don't mean her reign over couture and catwalk. What her bow marks is the golden age of magazines, when editors were celebrated as celebs in their own right and whose names were synonymous with their product. Mark Boxer at Tatler, Graydon Carter's Vanity Fair, Nick Logan at The Face, Bill Buford heading Granta, Alan Coren at Punch and Tina Brown presiding over Tatler, Vanity Fair, The New Yorker and the Daily Beast. But 'Nuclear Wintour' outsaw all of them, while the only famed editor still at his desk and outdoing Wintour by two years and still counting is my first boss, Ian Hislop, Private Eye 's Lord Gnome. Magazines shaped my life after my publican parents turned their saloon bar into a comfy sitting room with sofas, log fires and piles of glossies. As my mother put it, 'There's Country Life for the life you want, Hello! to gawp at other people's lives and Private Eye for the truth behind the lives.' Each copy was grey from being thumbed by riveted customers. By 1991, when the cousin of one of our regulars sent me off for an interview with Hislop at the Eye 's Soho offices, I was quivering with nerves at the prospect of meeting a demi-god. But even then, I didn't quite grasp how infinitesimally lucky I was to enter magazine journalism at a time of editorial giants, wide readerships, big ad revenue and significant sway. It was an age when editors decided who was a star in the making – or fading. Front covers rather than TikTok anointed and cemented talent, while media bigwigs, rock stars and actors hung out together at the then newly-founded Groucho Club, feeding on each other's influence. The idea of a 'chief content creator' wasn't even a twinkle in a Californian tech bro's eye – he was still at kindergarten. All the lesser hacks relied on editors and their lavish expense accounts to lubricate the fun. Michael VerMeulen, the American editor of British GQ – where I landed my second job – negotiated an expense account of £40,000 on top of his salary and used to sweep his entire staff out for Groucho jollies. Vermeulen with his flamboyant lingo of 'big swinging dicks' (any man he admired) and 'doesn't blow the wind up my skirt' (a lacklustre features pitch) made such great copy that the Guardian sent a journalist to report on what it was like to work in his orbit. I have long cherished the memory of him telling me that when a girlfriend congratulated him on his sexual performance, he instantly replied, 'Don't tell me, tell your friends!' His death, one August bank holiday weekend after an excess of cocaine, was front-page news, and all of Mag Land mourned. Even back then, Anna Wintour rose above it all like a phoenix born of ice, who would never be glimpsed in civilian settings. A good friend went off to work at US Vogue and reported back that the maestra had her own work lavatory, forbidden to all others, so worker bees couldn't bear witness to her doing something as human as going to the loo. (This was apparently even the case at her Met Gala balls, where even Hollywood superstars couldn't share her personal facilities.) During my brief stint at Conde Nast, before I was fired for sleeping with the deputy editor – reader, I married him – rumours of impending visits from Wintour took on the aspect of Elizabeth I descending on an earl's country estate to test his coffers and loyalty. Even that friend who went to the Vogue took on some of her boss's grandiosity. When I bumped into her at an intimate London book launch, I was startled to find she affected not to know me, a phase that happily passed. There was real power in the corridors of glossies back then, and this could distort personalities even more than the charlie so many meeja folk snorted. An actress or model who couldn't land a Vogue cover was denied the super-stamp of being in fashion, and so it was for men who couldn't make a splash on GQ or Esquire 's hoardings. Pamela Anderson may have equalled Princess Diana for sheer fame in the 1990s, but Wintour would not yield her the ultimate accolade of a cover: the sex tape that leaked of Anderson and drummer Tommy Lee deemed her trashy beyond redemption. But in 2023, Anderson had a radical image overhaul, ditching the bombshell slap and going makeup-free to Paris Fashion Week, and every event since. It was intellectual, interesting – and it's got her on the list for the last two Met Galas. This year, Anderson went a step further, with a severe bob and sculpted dress that gave her a faint whiff of catwalk Rosa Klebb. She'd have probably worn a straitjacket if it gained her admission to fashion's front row. Because that, in the end, was Anna Wintour's nuclear-force superpower: the quiet devastation of a 'No'. She was not just an editor, she was the ultimate bouncer with Prada gloves.
The Sun
an hour ago
- The Sun
Jake Paul vs Julio Cesar Chavez Jr EXACT fight time – when are the ring-walks for blockbuster bout?
JAKE PAUL is hoping to take another huge boxing scalp when he takes on Mexican mogul Julio Cesar Chavez Jr TONIGHT! The Problem Child hasn't competitively stepped foot in the ring since his controversial points win against legendary heavy-hitter Mike Tyson. 1 Fans feared for 58-year-old Tyson before the fight, and made their voices heard when the decision was followed by unanimous boos around the AT&T Stadium. However, the victory meant that Paul extended his professional boxing career record to 11-1 - only losing a bitter grudge match to Tommy Fury in 2023. And the social media sensation will be determined to build on that when he goes toe-to-toe with Julio Cesar Chavez Jr at the top of a huge Honda Center bill. But for the fans that are only interested in the main event, SunSport can reveal the EXACT time when Paul and Chavez Jr will step into the ring. What time does Jake Paul vs Chavez Jr start and how can I watch it? Ring-walks for the main event is expected to get underway at around 4am BST / 11pm ET meaning that the first bell should go approximately 15 minutes later at 4:15am BST / 11:15pm ET. However, timings could change depending on the length of the undercard bouts. Coverage of the main card will start from 1am BST / 8pm ET. Honda Center in Anaheim, United States is the chosen venue for this huge event and it can host approximately 18,336. The fight will be exclusively shown on DAZN PPV. The pay-per-view costs £24.99 / $59.99 and can be watched on DAZN TV or live streamed on the website / app. Alternatively, SunSport will live blog the full card, including the huge main event. Jake Paul vs Julio Cesar Chavez Jr JAKE PAUL'S controversial boxing career rolls on this weekend with the Problem Child facing boxing royalty in Anaheim, California. Paul will face Julio Cesar Chavez Jr, a highly-decorated former world middleweight champion. The Mexican, 39, has fought just once in the last four years but has the best boxing resume of any fighter to step into a ring with Paul - bar Mike Tyson, who was aged 58 at the time they fought. INFO Everything you need to know about Paul vs Chavez Jr LATEST NEWS & FEATURES Jake Paul buys incredible £29MILLION ranch with 5,700 acres Jake Paul in talks over TWO shock world title fights Chavez Jr is son of boxing great who was arrested on gun charges and robbed by party girls Jake Paul heavyweight days over after getting 'too fat' Who is on the Jake Paul vs Chavez Jr undercard? Jake Paul vs Julio César Chávez Jr. - Cruiserweight Gilberto 'Zurdo' Ramirez vs Yuniel Dorticos - Cruiserweight, for the WBA and WBO titles Holly Holm vs Yolanda Vega - Lightweight Floyd Schofield vs Tevin Farmer - Lightweight Avious Griffin vs Julian Rodriguez - Welterweight Raul 'Cugar' Curiel vs Victor Ezequiel Rodriguez - Welterweight Naomy Valle vs Ashley Felix - Light flyweight Jake Paul's confidence Jake Paul is confident that he will beat Julio Cesar Chavez Jr and believes he could 'whoop' Chavez Jr's legendary father too... at the same time! The Problem Child said: "Put both the Chavezs in there, I'll whoop Sr and Jr in the same night. "Going from Disney Channel to YouTube to world champion in six to seven years? "That's the most relatable and best sports story that any kid can get behind."
The Sun
an hour ago
- The Sun
I'm a ‘former fatty' who lost 12 stone WITHOUT jabs – being slim means I don't have to eat in the car to avoid judgement
A SELF-DESCRIBED 'former fatty' has admitted losing 12 stone means she's no longer forced to eat dinner in her car. Krista has lost 170lbs over the past four years, but hasn't resorted to weight loss injections or surgery to do so - instead sticking to a calorie deficit and exercising more. 6 6 6 6 She regularly shares tips and tricks on her social media pages, and recently posted a video in which she shared two ways her life has changed since she transformed her figure. "Now that I am skinny I can go to a restaurant and I can just eat whatever I want," she said. "It's cute if I order a burger and fries and eat a lot of food but when I was fat that was not okay. "God forbid I would have ordered a burger! "I would not have ordered a burger first of all. "I would not have done that just because the judgment around what you're eating, how much you're eating and what you're drinking... they're just like, 'Well of course she ordered a burger, because she's fat, that's why she looks the way she does.' "Or if you try to order a salad or something healthy like grilled chicken it's 'You're not fooling anybody, that's not how you eat - you're 300 pounds!' "You just can't win, so eating in public when you are overweight is mortifying." Things got so bad when Krista was bigger that she'd even resort to eating her restaurant meals in the car. "What I would do is I would eat a couple bites, take my food to go and I would eat it in the car in private," she sighed. I went from 27 lbs in six weeks with Mounjaro after 15 years of trying to lose weight it has completely changed my life "Or I would eat it when I got home, where nobody was judging me." Another thing that's changed dramatically since she lost the weight is that she's now "allowed to be tired". "When you are fat you are not allowed to come around and be like, 'Oh I had such a long day, I just want to go home and sit on the couch'," Krista continued. "The looks you're gonna get, the judgment that you're immediately gonna get, it's disgusting. "But when you're skinny it's okay - it's okay if I had a long day and I want to come home and sit on the couch. "As soon as you are overweight or fat it is not okay because now you're just lazy." Visit our diet, nutrition and weight loss page for the latest updates Krista concluded that the "constant double standard" for those who are skinny and those who are overweight "blows my mind". People in the comments section were quick to agree with Krista, with one writing: "I go to the gym 4 times a week for the past 3 years (I'm fat) and people say 'good for you' 'keep it up'. "My skinny friend goes once in 6 months and someone asked her for advice." "Now I'm pregnant and so much heavier I really appreciate being thin when I'm not pregnant!" a second admitted. "When you're fat, you better be funny, like mandatory, but once you're skinny, if you're the exact same funny it's a cute, surprising, quirky perk," a third sighed. "You're so right!" Krista replied. "I was not funny when I was fat and tried so hard to be, but it's just not my personality!" 6 6
