Medical association urges MoH to halt Poisons Act amendment
KUCHING (July 27): The Malaysian Medical Association (MMA) has urged the Ministry of Health (MoH) and MPs to halt further readings of the Poisons (Amendment) Bill 2025 until a thorough consultation process has been undertaken.
MMA president Dato Dr Kalwinder Singh Khaira said the association acknowledged the government's intention of strengthening the enforcement, possibly in response to serious cross-border threats such as drug-smuggling, maritime trafficking or other reasons, which had not been made known.
'However, he argued that if this was the objective, then the reasons must be made clear and the scope of the amendment must be clearly and appropriately defined in the legislation.
'The fact that no consultation was held with medical stakeholders, is a major procedural oversight.
'These are not peripheral changes – they affect the daily operations of thousands of practitioners nationwide,' he said in a statement.
According to Dr Kalwinder, the current language in the Bill is 'overly broad-based'.
'Clause 2's inclusion of all police officers as authorised officers and the new Section 31A, which allows the minister to appoint 'any person' without clear qualifications, raises serious concerns about unchecked enforcement power and the potential for disruption to licensed private healthcare facilities including GP (general practitioner's) clinics, mobile services and charity-based health initiatives.'
Dr Kalwinder said the MMA was particularly troubled by the expanded definition of 'premises', which could subject legitimate medical facilities to be clumped together with those deemed criminal or non-healthcare related, and thus, subject to similar inspections or enforcement actions.
He further pointed out that this would risk not only operational disruptions, but also violations of patients' confidentiality and trust.
'The Act must clearly delineate between enforcement aimed at criminal activity, and regulation of clinical practice.
'Private healthcare facilities are already under the ambit of the Private Healthcare Facilities and Services Act 1998 (Act 586) and enforcement by MoH.
'This should remain as it is,' stressed Dr Kalwinder.
Nonetheless, he said MMA remained ready to engage in meaningful dialogue to ensure that public safety and professional integrity would both be protected. amendment lead Malaysian Medical Association Poisons Act
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Star
11 hours ago
- The Star
More incentives in the works to convince medical officers to remain in Borneo States
PETALING JAYA: The Health Ministry will find ways to enhance the incentives and allowances for all personnel posted to Sabah and Sarawak, says Datuk Seri Dr Dzulkefly Ahmad. He also said that about 20% of the medical officers who have applied to be transferred from Sabah and Sarawak to the Peninsula states may have to stay in their current postings. The Health Minister made this statement on Sunday (July 27) after launching the book titled 'Crisis and Community: Covid-19 in Malaysia', a compilation of essays on the Covid-19 crisis by people from all levels of society, edited by Bridget Welsh. He asked the medical officers stationed in the Borneo States to 'give it a chance," even if they are 'reluctant at first." It was reported that approximately 600 medical officers currently stationed in Sabah and Sarawak have applied for transfer to the Peninsula. The Health Ministry said that this has caused difficulties in ensuring that public health services are sufficiently provided to the people in Sabah and Sarawak. On July 24, the former chairman of the Malaysian Medical Association of Sabah branch, Dr Brandon Patrick, called for more doctors to be posted in Sabah and Sarawak, adding that incentives should be given to those posted to both states. He expressed his support for the Sabah government's proposal to provide an additional special allowance to doctors stationed in Sabah and Sarawak.
Borneo Post
21 hours ago
- Borneo Post
Medical association urges MoH to halt Poisons Act amendment
According to Dr Kalwinder, the current language in the Bill is 'overly broad-based'. KUCHING (July 27): The Malaysian Medical Association (MMA) has urged the Ministry of Health (MoH) and MPs to halt further readings of the Poisons (Amendment) Bill 2025 until a thorough consultation process has been undertaken. MMA president Dato Dr Kalwinder Singh Khaira said the association acknowledged the government's intention of strengthening the enforcement, possibly in response to serious cross-border threats such as drug-smuggling, maritime trafficking or other reasons, which had not been made known. 'However, he argued that if this was the objective, then the reasons must be made clear and the scope of the amendment must be clearly and appropriately defined in the legislation. 'The fact that no consultation was held with medical stakeholders, is a major procedural oversight. 'These are not peripheral changes – they affect the daily operations of thousands of practitioners nationwide,' he said in a statement. According to Dr Kalwinder, the current language in the Bill is 'overly broad-based'. 'Clause 2's inclusion of all police officers as authorised officers and the new Section 31A, which allows the minister to appoint 'any person' without clear qualifications, raises serious concerns about unchecked enforcement power and the potential for disruption to licensed private healthcare facilities including GP (general practitioner's) clinics, mobile services and charity-based health initiatives.' Dr Kalwinder said the MMA was particularly troubled by the expanded definition of 'premises', which could subject legitimate medical facilities to be clumped together with those deemed criminal or non-healthcare related, and thus, subject to similar inspections or enforcement actions. He further pointed out that this would risk not only operational disruptions, but also violations of patients' confidentiality and trust. 'The Act must clearly delineate between enforcement aimed at criminal activity, and regulation of clinical practice. 'Private healthcare facilities are already under the ambit of the Private Healthcare Facilities and Services Act 1998 (Act 586) and enforcement by MoH. 'This should remain as it is,' stressed Dr Kalwinder. Nonetheless, he said MMA remained ready to engage in meaningful dialogue to ensure that public safety and professional integrity would both be protected. amendment lead Malaysian Medical Association Poisons Act
The Star
21 hours ago
- The Star
Discuss Poisons Bill with stakeholders first, urges MMA
PETALING JAYA: The Malaysian Medical Association (MMA) has voiced strong concern over the Poisons (Amendment) Bill 2025, urging the government to halt its progress in Parliament until proper engagement is held with key players. Its president Datuk Dr Kalwinder Singh Khaira ( pic ) said the association, along with other medical professional bodies, was deeply concerned that the Bill had been tabled without prior consultation with key stakeholders, including the MMA. 'We acknowledge the government's intention to strengthen enforcement, possibly in response to serious cross-border threats such as drug smuggling or maritime trafficking. 'However, if this is indeed the rationale, it must be clearly stated and the scope of the amendments appropriately defined in the legislation,' he said in a statement on Friday. Dr Kalwinder said the language of the Bill was overly broad and raised red flags regarding enforcement powers and possible implications on private healthcare services. He pointed specifically to Clause 2, which designates all police officers as authorised officers under the Act, and the proposed Section 31A, which grants the Health Minister power to appoint 'any person' without specifying qualifications. 'These provisions raise serious concerns about unchecked enforcement authority and the potential disruption to legitimate private healthcare services, such as GP clinics, mobile services and charity-based health initiatives,' Dr Kalwinder said. He added that MMA also took issue with the expanded definition of 'premises' in the Bill, saying it could group licensed medical facilities together with non-healthcare-related or even criminal operations under the same enforcement scope. 'These risks are not only operational disruptions but also potential violations of patient confidentiality and public trust,' Dr Kalwinder said. He added that the absence of engagement with the medical fraternity represented a major procedural lapse, especially since the proposed changes would significantly impact the daily operations of thousands of healthcare practitioners nationwide. 'These are not peripheral changes,' he said, adding that the Health Ministry and MPs must delay any further readings of the Bill until a comprehensive consultation is held with the medical profession. Dr Kalwinder said the Act must make a clear distinction between enforcement aimed at criminal activity and regulation of clinical practice. He noted that private healthcare providers are already regulated under the Private Healthcare Facilities and Services Act 1998 (Act 586), with oversight from the Health Ministry. 'This arrangement should remain as it is,' he said as he warned against any overlap or overreach that could disrupt healthcare delivery, while reiterating MMA's readiness to engage in constructive dialogue on the matter.
