Criminal Justice season 4: Who killed Roshni? Anju, Raj, Ira or someone else? Netizens claim killer may not be who you suspect
Criminal Justice: A Family Matter
dropping on July 3, 2025, fans aren't just waiting—they're investigating. The
courtroom drama
has turned everyday viewers into full-time Reddit detectives, each armed with screenshots, trailer stills, and timelines. As
Pankaj Tripathi
's Madhav Mishra inches closer to uncovering the truth behind nurse Roshni Saluja's murder, the internet is already racing to deliver its verdict.
Season 4 has kept audiences gripped with its layered storytelling. Dr. Raj Nagpal stands accused of murdering his girlfriend, nurse Roshni, while his estranged wife Anju and daughter Ira are slowly pulled into the shadows of suspicion. Every episode has introduced a new piece of evidence—from surveillance gaps to a suspicious lactose-free milk bottle—blurring the lines between guilt and innocence.
Episode 7 ended with fresh twists, forcing fans to reconsider everything they thought they knew. And now, Reddit is brimming with bold, elaborate theories. (Beware, spoiler alert ahead!)
The most convincing theory? The 'other doctor' did it
One Reddit user suggests the killer is not Dr. Nagpal, but a fellow physician. According to their theory, this doctor suspected Roshni of poisoning Nagpal's daughter and, out of concern (and a possible college connection with Anju), tried to intervene. A confrontation allegedly turned fatal, with Anju helping cover it up. The motive? Protection. The fallout? A frightened daughter withholding the truth. The twist? She might just testify in the finale.
Is the murder weapon a red herring—or the key?
The scalpel, found late in the season, sparked intense speculation. Why did Anju hire Madhav Mishra? Was it guilt, or was it to protect someone else, like herself? As more viewers dig deeper, some argue the real killer might be Kamala, based on a woman's hand shown in the trailer's slitting scene. Others lean towards lesser-known characters like Roshni's ex-boyfriend, citing suspiciously little screen time.
Slow burn or genius build-up? Fans are split
While some viewers have dismissed the season as slow or underwhelming, others argue that the real issue is its weekly release format. 'It's not boring—it's suspenseful,' one fan defended. 'There are over 30 different plausible theories circulating. That means the show is doing its job: no one knows what's coming.' Still, many agree on one thing—if the final twist involves Anju, Raj, or Ira as the killer, it better be backed by airtight logic. Anything less could risk making the tension-filled build-up feel unearned.
The final hearing
With just one episode to go, Criminal Justice: A Family Matter has managed to do what few shows can—get everyone guessing, debating, and playing armchair detective. As July 3 approaches, one question looms large: Will the writers outsmart the internet?
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
4 hours ago
- Time of India
‘Criminal Justice' season 4: Anju, Raj, or Ira, who killed Roshni? Fans share speculations online
Fans of the popular OTT show ' Criminal Justice : A Family Matter' cannot get enough of the new season. With the finale set to drop on July 3, fans have been sharing speculations about the show and how it will end after the events of the last episode. The plot of the web series follows the main character, lawyer Madhav Mishra , as he defends the suspect Raj Nagpal , who has been accused of murder after he was found holding the body of the late nurse Roshni Saluja . Ever since the release of the first episode, fans have been in anticipation of the killer's identity. There have been major pieces of evidence that have been revealed throughout the show. Things like missing CCTV footage, a lactose-free milk bottle, and now, in the latest turn of events, a mysterious and still unexplained medicine bottle. Ever since the 7th episode of the season was released online, fans have been buzzing with theories and speculations, with many turning into detectives to solve the crime before Mishra. Fans of the show took to social media platforms and discussion forums to share their thoughts on the matter. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like They Were So Beautiful Before; Now Look At Them; Number 10 Will Shock You Reportingly Undo The most popular theory behind the murder Many fans of the show have been pointing out that the answer could be someone extremely obvious that most would brush aside as being a simple side character. One of the most popular theories suggested by fans is that it wasn't Raj, butt a fellow physician who was not involved in the murder. Some even suspected that Roshni could have been involved in poisoning Nagpal's daughter, Ira, and to protect his family, this physician decided to end the nurse's life. More theories about less obvious characters: Is the killer a woman? After a scalpel was found as one of the major pieces of evidence in the murder case, fans did a roundabout, and theories about how the killer might be a female came to light. Many fans of the show started sharing clips of the season 4 trailer that showed a slitting scene with a woman's hand involved in it. Using the clip to support their argument, fans of the show claim that one of the characters named Kamala might be behind the murder rather than Raj. Gripping finale Fans of the show have shared divided reactions. While some have labelled the show's one episode per week format as lazy and slow, many others have shared that it adds a level of suspense to the drama. Other than that, some fans also pointed out that Roshni's ex-boyfriend could be the answer, no matter how obvious it seems. As the final episode of the show is set to be released tomorrow, all that is left for the fans to do is wait and watch and put their theory to the test.
Hindustan Times
6 hours ago
- Hindustan Times
‘Reels is not patriotism': Woman at Delhi airport slams co-passengers' loud chants
Jul 02, 2025 05:30 AM IST The growing trend of filming 'patriotic' content in public spaces drew fresh criticism after a flyer at Delhi airport posted about a group chanting slogans and shooting reels. She slammed them for being insensitive and lacking civic sense. A woman shared this picture while slamming fellow Indian passengers at Delhi airport. (Reddit/@Upper_Cook8442) 'Why Indians are Like This? the flyer wrote. She continued that while at Delhi airport, travelling from Vietnam to Malaysia, she came across a group of Indian travellers who randomly started chanting and making reels. 'If you are so patriotic then why travel to another country? If you wanna make the reels you make it without shouting and disturbing others,' she continued. The woman completed her post with a picture that showed an individual holding an Indian passport with a ticket kept within. Take a look at the post: Why Indians are Like This? byu/Upper_Cook8442 indelhi 'Facepalm moment': Says social media An individual posted, ''Bharat Mata ki Jai' right before catching a flight out of Bharat is wild.' Another added, 'Ask anything about our country, our history, our struggles they won't be able to tell.' Also Read: IndiGo flight attendant slams passenger's selfish act of leaving staffer drenched after taking umbrella: 'Feel ashamed' A third remarked, 'If you're proud of your country, you should also respect others around you. Being loud and disturbing people at the airport isn't needed. Travelling abroad doesn't mean you're not patriotic.' A fourth wrote, 'This is straight-up insecurity, not fun. Some of us Indians have a mentality of barking about our country and its culture everywhere.'
Time of India
14 hours ago
- Time of India
Criminal Justice season 4: Who killed Roshni? Anju, Raj, Ira or someone else? Netizens claim killer may not be who you suspect
With the finale of Criminal Justice: A Family Matter dropping on July 3, 2025, fans aren't just waiting—they're investigating. The courtroom drama has turned everyday viewers into full-time Reddit detectives, each armed with screenshots, trailer stills, and timelines. As Pankaj Tripathi 's Madhav Mishra inches closer to uncovering the truth behind nurse Roshni Saluja's murder, the internet is already racing to deliver its verdict. Season 4 has kept audiences gripped with its layered storytelling. Dr. Raj Nagpal stands accused of murdering his girlfriend, nurse Roshni, while his estranged wife Anju and daughter Ira are slowly pulled into the shadows of suspicion. Every episode has introduced a new piece of evidence—from surveillance gaps to a suspicious lactose-free milk bottle—blurring the lines between guilt and innocence. Episode 7 ended with fresh twists, forcing fans to reconsider everything they thought they knew. And now, Reddit is brimming with bold, elaborate theories. (Beware, spoiler alert ahead!) The most convincing theory? The 'other doctor' did it One Reddit user suggests the killer is not Dr. Nagpal, but a fellow physician. According to their theory, this doctor suspected Roshni of poisoning Nagpal's daughter and, out of concern (and a possible college connection with Anju), tried to intervene. A confrontation allegedly turned fatal, with Anju helping cover it up. The motive? Protection. The fallout? A frightened daughter withholding the truth. The twist? She might just testify in the finale. Is the murder weapon a red herring—or the key? The scalpel, found late in the season, sparked intense speculation. Why did Anju hire Madhav Mishra? Was it guilt, or was it to protect someone else, like herself? As more viewers dig deeper, some argue the real killer might be Kamala, based on a woman's hand shown in the trailer's slitting scene. Others lean towards lesser-known characters like Roshni's ex-boyfriend, citing suspiciously little screen time. Slow burn or genius build-up? Fans are split While some viewers have dismissed the season as slow or underwhelming, others argue that the real issue is its weekly release format. 'It's not boring—it's suspenseful,' one fan defended. 'There are over 30 different plausible theories circulating. That means the show is doing its job: no one knows what's coming.' Still, many agree on one thing—if the final twist involves Anju, Raj, or Ira as the killer, it better be backed by airtight logic. Anything less could risk making the tension-filled build-up feel unearned. The final hearing With just one episode to go, Criminal Justice: A Family Matter has managed to do what few shows can—get everyone guessing, debating, and playing armchair detective. As July 3 approaches, one question looms large: Will the writers outsmart the internet?
