Turkey's Brics membership hopes are dashed for now
Despite President Recep Tayyip Erdogan's years of public statements hinting that Ankara was considering joining Brics, few believed Turkey would actually take concrete steps toward membership.
Brics - an acronym of its original members Brazil, Russia, India, China, and South Africa - is seen by some commentators as poised to dominate the global economy in the coming decades.
Often viewed as an alternative to the G7, which is led primarily by western nations, Brics represents a significant shift in global power dynamics, and until now, has not included any Nato members.
One year after Ankara's application, Turkey's prospects for full Brics membership have lost momentum and are likely dead for the foreseeable future.
There were no encouraging signs from the start.
Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov, for example, said last June that Brics was not interested in further expansion after adding five new nations in 2024: Argentina, Egypt, Ethiopia, Iran, and the United Arab Emirates. Instead, Lavrov said Turkey would be offered a special status called "partner country", along with 13 others.
New MEE newsletter: Jerusalem Dispatch
Sign up to get the latest insights and analysis on Israel-Palestine, alongside Turkey Unpacked and other MEE newsletters
Turkish officials, even those with reservations about Brics, were not receptive to the idea of partner status, as it reminded them of Turkey's bid to join the European Union.
Nato or Shanghai Cooperation Organisation? Turkey's Erdogan goes for both Read More »
Several EU leaders in the past tried to persuade Turkey to accept a "special partnership" with Brussels instead of full EU membership.
Ankara has yet to announce its decision regarding the Brics proposal. Erdogan skipped the Brics summit in Brazil last weekend, sending Foreign Minister Hakan Fidan in his place.
While 10 other countries, including Belarus, Bolivia, Kazakhstan, Uzbekistan, and Cuba, joined as partner countries, Turkey kept its silence on the issue.
One side issue could also be US President Donald Trump assuming his second term in January. Last month, Trump made it clear he has no love for Brics and said he would impose 100 percent tariffs if the group attempted to create a new Brics currency.
On Monday, he said the US would impose an additional 10 percent tariff on any countries aligning themselves with the "anti-American policies" of the Brics. Those statements likely concerned Turkish officials who want to maintain the good rapport between Erdogan and Trump.
Adding insult to injury, Indonesia was admitted as a full Brics member in January, despite Lavrov's earlier statements that expansion to integrate new members would be paused. The Brics secretariat explained that Indonesia's membership was decided in 2023 but was delayed until after its presidential election last year, so it was not a new decision.
Although no Turkish officials would say so publicly, sources familiar with the issue told Middle East Eye that China and India had reservations about Turkey's membership last year, effectively blocking Ankara's path to full Brics membership.
"Turkey is Nato," a Brazilian diplomat told MEE in December. "Several countries have concerns about how that would work with the bloc."
The diplomat said India was the chief opponent of Turkey's participation.
Tensions with India
In September, a western diplomat told MEE that Turkey may have been making soft moves to address India's concerns over the Kashmir issue. The diplomat noted that Erdogan did not comment on Kashmir during the UN General Assembly meetings in September, unlike in previous years.
An Indian diplomat, however, told MEE that Erdogan's silence was not a meaningful gesture, as Turkey had signed an Organisation of Islamic Cooperation report in August that assessed the situation in Indian-controlled Kashmir.
'Turkey is Nato. Several countries have concerns about how that would work with the bloc'
- Brazilian diplomat
In its official statements, India did not directly comment on Turkey's membership but reminded the public that Brics admits new members only by unanimous decision.
Matters deteriorated further this year. The issue came to a complete standstill after the India-Pakistan conflict over Kashmir was reignited by an attack in April that killed 27 Indian tourists. As India blamed Pakistan and launched a military response, Turkey soon found itself drawn into the conflict.
Indian media, citing sources, repeatedly accused Ankara of supplying drones, weapons, and ammunition to Pakistan during the latest wave of conflict. Some reports even alleged that two Turkish military operatives were killed by Indian forces during Operation Sindoor, and that Turkey provided Pakistan with over 350 drones.
"Turkish advisors helped Pakistani army officials coordinate drone attacks in India after Operation Sindoor," they claimed.
Following the US-brokered ceasefire in May, Indian politicians began campaigns against Turkey for its supposed military aid to Pakistan. First, Indian authorities withheld security clearance for Celebi Airport Services India, a unit of Turkey's Celebi that operates ground handling services at nine Indian airports, including Delhi, Mumbai, and Bengaluru.
Why Turkey wants to join Brics Read More »
Then, IndiGo Airlines announced it would terminate its leasing agreement with Turkish Airlines by 31 August after pressure from India's aviation regulator.
As Indian citizens launched boycotts against Turkey, including tourism, Air India CEO Campbell Wilson said the airline would look for alternative maintenance and repair providers to replace Turkish Technic.
In June, Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi visited Cyprus and met with President Nikos Christodoulides, a move widely seen as a signal to Turkey that New Delhi was deepening ties with countries that have disputes with Ankara.
In another sign of India's shifting stance, the Indian military linked Turkey to Pakistan during the latest escalation over Kashmir, dashing any hopes that India might support Ankara's bid to join Brics.
India's Deputy Chief of Army Staff Lt Gen Rahul R Singh said on Friday that Turkey was a component of Pakistan's strategy against India.
"Turkey also played an important role by providing the type of support it did; they supplied Bayraktar and numerous other drones," he said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The National
an hour ago
- The National
Five Israeli soldiers killed in Gaza as ceasefire talks grind on
Five Israeli soldiers died in combat in northern Gaza on Tuesday, as the war in the enclave entered its 22nd month. The soldiers were part of the Netzah Yehuda Battalion, Israel's military said. Two names were released while the identities of the remaining three were withheld. Two soldiers were severely wounded in the same incident. They were 'evacuated to a hospital to receive medical treatment and their families have been notified', the military said. It did not disclose details of the incident in which the five died. The deaths follow an Israeli bombing near the Nuseirat refugee camp in central Gaza on Monday night that killed three people in a tent sheltering displaced people, according to official Palestinian media. The air strike landed close to an aid distribution point west of the camp, the Wafa news agency reported. In the south of Gaza, another person was killed in Rafah when Israeli forces opened fire near an aid distribution point. More than 57,500 Palestinians have been killed in Gaza since the war began in October 2023. The conflict was sparked by a Hamas-led attack on southern Israeli communities that killed about 1,200 people. The assailants also took hostage another 250 people. Trump is 'committed to peace in the region' The latest deaths come as Hamas and Israeli delegations engage in talks in Qatar aimed at reaching an elusive ceasefire, with US special envoy Steve Witkoff set to join them this week. The indirect negotiations have made progress but the two still remain at odds over several issues, sources have told The National. The talks, mediated by the US, Egypt and Qatar, coincided with a meeting between US President Donald Trump and Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu that took place at the White House on Monday. Israel and Hamas appear to be in agreement on the core provisions of a proposed deal, according to the sources. These include a 60-day truce, the release of 10 hostages held by Hamas and the return of the remains of another 18 who died in captivity. Mr Trump has made clear that following the 12-day war between Israel and Iran, he would like to see the Gaza war end soon. The war has displaced most of Gaza's 2.3 million population and laid to waste swathes of built-up areas.
The National
an hour ago
- The National
Second Red Sea ship attacked off Yemen after Houthis claim assault on Greek bulk carrier
Two crew members were injured and two were missing after a commercial vessel was attacked on Monday night off the coast of Yemen's Hodeidah, maritime monitors reported, marking the second Red Sea attack in 24 hours following a period of relative calm. The Houthi rebels in Yemen had earlier claimed responsibility for an attack on Sunday when a Greek-operated bulk carrier was hit by gunfire, drones and missiles in the Red Sea. UK-based security firm Ambrey said on Monday a "Liberia-flagged bulk carrier was approached and attacked by two skiffs and unmanned aerial vehicles while transiting northbound in the Red Sea". "Two crew members were reportedly injured and a further two crew members were missing," it added. The UK Maritime Trade Operations (UKMTO), run by the British navy, said it received reports of an incident 51 nautical miles (approximately 94 kilometres) west of Hodeidah, Yemen. The Houthis have been attacking Israel and commercial vessels in the Red Sea and Gulf of Aden since the Gaza war broke out in October 2023. But the latest incidents mark a rare assault in the strategic waters near Yemen, coming two months after the US announced a truce with the country's Houthis aimed at halting attacks on shipping in the region. In response, Israel has been carrying out strikes on Yemen. The Yemeni port city of Hodeidah was struck along with the ports of Ras Isa and Salif and the Ras Al Khatib power station, according to the Houthi-run Al Masirah television station. The Israeli military said it 'struck and destroyed terror infrastructure belonging to the Houthi terrorist regime'. 'Among the targets were the ports of Hodeidah, Ras Isa, and Salif,' it said. It was the Israeli army's first attack on Yemen in about a month. The army also hit the Galaxy Leader ship docked at Ras Isa port, which was seized by the Iran-backed Houthis in late 2023, it added. Ambrey said early on Tuesday that it observed imagery that confirmed damage to the concrete docks at Yemen's Hodeidah port following Israeli strikes. Additionally, two Barbados-flagged bulk carriers likely suffered blast damage as a result of the attacks, Ambrey said in an advisory note, adding no injuries among the crews had been reported. On Sunday, the Liberian-flagged vessel Magic Seas came under attack in the Red Sea on Sunday, with several small boats opening fire on it, the UKMTO reported. The Houthis said the company's ships were "a legitimate target" because they had done business with Israel and used its ports. A UAE rescue mission brought the 22 crew members to safety.
Zawya
an hour ago
- Zawya
New Development Bank expands to 11 members, raises $16.1bln in 2024
The New Development Bank (NDB) has approved Colombia and Uzbekistan as new members, its president Dilma Rousseff said, as the lender focuses on expanding its membership and increasing financing in local currencies for sustainable development in the Global South. Speaking at the conclusion of the BRICS-led bank's Annual Meeting in Rio de Janeiro, Rousseff confirmed the decision by the Board of Governors, which is composed of the finance ministers of the BRICS countries. The additions bring the bank's total membership to 11 countries, which also includes its founders Brazil, Russia, India, China, and South Africa, as well as the United Arab Emirates, Bangladesh, Egypt, and Algeria. Rousseff said that other countries are under review for membership but did not disclose their names, citing internal confidentiality guidelines. 'Our expansion will follow strategic criteria, always with the goal of strengthening our representativeness within the Global South,' she explained. Rousseff also outlined the bank's governance model, drawing a contrast with institutions like the IMF and the World Bank. 'Our Bank was established by the Global South for the Global South, with a governance structure based on substantive equality among members,' she emphasized, noting that the model does not allow for unilateral veto power and rejects political or economic conditionalities on its loans. 'Our model is demand-driven. It is the member countries that define their development priorities, and we assess projects based on technical—not political—criteria.' The NDB president addressed a challenging 15-month period when the bank was unable to raise funds in international markets. Since taking leadership in March 2023, she said she has led a campaign to resume bond issuances, successfully raising $16.1bn in 2024 at competitive rates. 'Today we have strong credit ratings, including a AAA grade from the Japanese agency JCR, and we are expanding into new markets, such as yen-denominated instruments and the Middle East,' Rousseff said. The bank's approved project portfolio has now reached $40bn across 122 initiatives, with $22.4 billion already disbursed. Its investment strategy focuses on four pillars: logistics infrastructure, digital transformation, social infrastructure, and energy transition. Rousseff highlighted the bank's push to increase financing in local currencies to shield member countries from the risks ofrelying on the U.S. dollar. 'Any business or government that borrows in foreign currency becomes subject to decisions made by the Federal Reserve or other central banks in developed nations,' she cautioned. Technological innovation and cooperation among developing nations is another key theme, Rousseff said, positioning the NDB as a facilitator of knowledge-sharing. She cited a smart hospital project in São Paulo that incorporates Chinese expertise as an example of South-South cooperation. 'Storing wind and sunlight was once mocked as a fantasy, but today it is one of the most strategic areas in the global energy sector,' Rousseff noted. Asked about 'de-dollarization,' Rousseff said she did not see evidence of an imminent decline in the dollar's status but that the rise of local currency trade initiatives was an undeniable and positive development. Looking ahead, Rousseff said the bank's priorities include further strategic membership expansion, mobilising private capital, scaling up partnerships with research institutions, and continuing to increase local-currency operations. Founded in 2014 by BRICS countries as an alternative to traditional financial models, the Shanghai-headquartered NDB operates with a mandate of sustainable development and respect for national sovereignty.
