Why I'm certain new arrests in Lucy Letby case will finally prove her innocence and blow up in cops' face, claims expert
LETBY PROBE Why I'm certain new arrests in Lucy Letby case will finally prove her innocence and blow up in cops' face, claims expert
AS KILLER nurse Lucy Letby faces more charges over the deaths of babies at the hospitals where she worked, and more arrests are made, the case that shocked a nation continues to unravel.
But an expert who believes Letby, 35, is being used as a scapegoat for possible hospital failings told The Sun that the new developments could help to prove her innocence.
Advertisement
7
Lucy Letby is serving 15 whole-life orders for killing seven babies and attempting to murder seven others
Credit: PA
7
The killer nurse has twice failed to appeal her convictions
Credit: SWNS
7
Police have widened their investigation to look into gross negligence manslaughter for staff at the Countess of Chester Hospital
Credit: Alamy
Yesterday, Cheshire Constabulary confirmed that three people - who were in senior leadership roles at the Countess of Chester Hospital - had been arrested on suspicion of gross negligence manslaughter as part of an investigation into the baby deaths and later bailed.
And now Letby could face even further charges in connection with the deaths and collapses of babies at both the Countess of Chester Hospital and Liverpool Women's Hospital.
Advertisement
The nurse is already serving 15 whole-life orders for murdering seven babies in a year-long reign of terror.
And she was also found guilty of trying to kill seven others - including one baby twice.
But after the latest bombshell developments in the case, Professor Richard Gill, a statistical misrepresentation consultant, told The Sun: "I think this will blow up in the police's face."
The professor has helped free multiple medical professionals wrongfully convicted of killing patients, including Dutch nurse Lucia de Berk and Italian nurse Daniela Poggiali.
He has previously argued that he can also prove Letby's innocence.
Advertisement
Asked if he believes cops are diverting attention away from potential hospital failures or because there is a growing backlash against Letby's convictions, he said: "Both, I think."
He added: "I think this is a move of desperation and a diversionary tactic by police.
"They have been threatening this for a long time. So they have to do it to preserve face. They are doing it now in an attempt to regain control of the narrative."
Lucy Letby cops arrest 3 senior members of leadership team at hospital where killer nurse murdered 7 babies
Talking about how the arrests could help Letby's case, he says: "At least these persons will be able to afford top legal representation.
"I think this will help Lucy a great deal. Those managers can pay top lawyers. They can fight back using the enormous doubts which now exist in the safety of Lucy's convictions."
Advertisement
The findings of the Thirlwall Inquiry - an examination into the events at the hospital at the time of the baby deaths for which Letby was convicted - are due in early 2026.
Prof Gill said: "Police are interfering with the Thirlwall Inquiry. They should have waited until Thirlwall's report was ready."
Asked if cops will be potentially worried about what the inquiry will reveal, he said: "No, just because the inquiry had the job of determining whether managers were to blame.
"It's a legal issue. The police are interrupting a statutory inquiry. One branch of government disturbing what another is doing."
Corporate manslaughter occurs when a company's gross negligence in managing or organising its activities leads to a person or persons' death.
Advertisement
What is the difference between corporate and gross negligence manslaughter?
CORPORATE manslaughter is a criminal offence in England and Wales used to prosecute companies accused of causing a person or persons death.
Corporate manslaughter is a relatively new offence under English law.
The Corporate Manslaughter and Corporate Homicide Act came into force across the UK in April 2008.
Before this companies could be prosecuted for causing death under the offence of gross negligence manslaughter.
But in order for the prosecution to be successful a senior individual in the company would also have to be accountable.
The new act provided that the company itself could be found guilty of the offence.
The Crown Prosecution Service says: "The offence was created to provide a means of accountability for very serious management failings across the organisation."
Meanwhile, gross negligence manslaughter is a common law offence.
It is committed where the death is a result of a grossly negligent (though otherwise lawful) act or omission on the part of the defendant, The Crown Prosecution says.
The circumstances in which this offence may fall to be considered often involve death following medical treatment or care or death in custody.
The ex-bosses have not been named by police, and cops were clear to say that this does not impact any of the killer nurse's convictions.
Cheshire Police say their investigations into corporate and gross negligence manslaughter at the hospitals where the killer nurse worked continue.
The probe, launched in 2023, is examining areas such as senior leadership and decision making to "determine whether any criminality has taken place".
When police first announced hospital staff could face prosecution in March, Prof Gill had said he was convinced the deaths occurred due to changes introduced, which meant greater numbers of "doomed" patients were admitted to the ward where Letby worked.
Prof Gill said: 'NHS statistics show that the increase in mortality can be fully explained by changes in admissions policy."
Advertisement
Earlier this year, an international panel of neonatologists and paediatric specialists said Letby's convictions were "unsafe" and told reporters bad medical care and natural causes were the reasons for the collapses and deaths.
Their evidence has been passed to the Criminal Cases Review Commission (CCRC), which investigates potential miscarriages of justice, and Letby's legal team hopes her case will be referred back to the Court of Appeal.
7
Prof Richard Gill is convinced Letby is innocent
7
A court sketch of Letby during her trial at Manchester Crown Court last year
Credit: PA
7
A grab from footage of the serial baby killer's arrest
Credit: PA
Advertisement
Between 2015 and 2016, two babies on the neo-natal unit were 'deliberately' poisoned with insulin, which was 'no accident'.
Some of the other babies were killed or harmed when air or milk was injected into their bloodstream or via a tube in their stomachs.
Letby, from Herefordshire, became a prime suspect when the number of baby deaths and catastrophic collapses at the hospital significantly rose.
Consultants grew concerned when they realised the children who died had 'deteriorated unexpectedly'.
Letby was found to be the "common denominator' among the deaths and collapses.
Advertisement
Detective Superintendent Paul Hughes, Senior Investigating Officer for Operation Duet, said today: 'In October 2023, following the lengthy trial and subsequent conviction of Lucy Letby, Cheshire Constabulary launched an investigation into corporate manslaughter at the Countess of Chester Hospital.
'This focuses on senior leadership and their decision making to determine whether any criminality has taken place concerning the response to the increased levels of fatalities.
'In March 2025, the scope of the investigation widened to also include gross negligence manslaughter.
'This is a separate offence to corporate manslaughter and focuses on the grossly negligent action or inaction of individuals.
'It is important to note that this does not impact on the convictions of Lucy Letby for multiple offences of murder and attempted murder.
Advertisement
'As part of our ongoing enquiries, on Monday 30th June three individuals who were part of the senior leadership team at the CoCH in 2015-2016, were arrested on suspicion of gross negligence manslaughter.
'All three have subsequently been bailed pending further enquiries.
'Both the corporate manslaughter and gross negligence manslaughter elements of the investigation are continuing and there are no set timescales for these.
'Our investigation into the deaths and non-fatal collapses of babies at the neo-natal units of both the Countess of Chester Hospital and the Liverpool Women's Hospital between the period of 2012 to 2016 is also ongoing.'
The killer nurse has lost two appeals against her convictions so far.
Advertisement
Last year, The Sun reported that the nurse was allowed to spend £901,817.45 on barristers and £818,497.92 on solicitors.
In March, Letby called for the public inquiry into events surrounding her crimes to be suspended.
Her solicitors wrote to inquiry chairwoman Lady Justice Thirlwall insisting her final report would be "likely unreliable" unless it was paused pending the outcome of the killer nurse's battle to prove her innocence.
With an estimated £10million spent so far on the inquiry, the letter added it would be in the taxpayer's interest to wait for the outcome of the CCRC review before publishing the report.
But the judge refused to pause the inquiry, though the report has been delayed from November to early next year.
Advertisement
Cheshire Police declined to comment.
7
Letby was found to be the 'common denominator' when the number of baby deaths and catastrophic collapses at her hospital significantly rose
Credit: Enterprise
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scottish Sun
44 minutes ago
- Scottish Sun
Footballer-favourite £250k Lamborghini supercar ‘in Diogo Jota crash' had been recalled over terrifying safety issues
Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) THE £250,000 Lamborghini believed to have been driven by Diogo Jota in his tragic car crash has been plagued by recalls and serious safety issues. The horror smash happened just after midnight on Thursday on a Spanish motorway near the northern town of Cerdanilla. 8 Diogo Jota was reportedly driving a Lamborghini that had been plagued by safety issues before his death Credit: EPA 8 The Liverpool and Portugal ace was travelling with his brother in Spain when his car burst into flames Credit: Not known, clear with picture desk 8 Jota is believed to have been behind the wheel of a Lamborghini Huracán Credit: Alamy 8 The luxury car is also in the garage of football stars like Kyle Walker Credit: Cavendish Press The Liverpool star, 28, and his younger brother André Silva, 26, died at the scene. Sources at Lamborghini said the company believes the car is a Huracán - a luxury model often seen in the garages of football's elite. Aces like Kyle Walker have been spotted driving the same iconic supercar. The model is no longer in production but was one of Lamborghini's most successful cars. Authorities are investigating whether the crash was caused by a punctured tyre that blew out. There is no indication that any other safety issues that had been subject to recalls over recent years played a part in Jota's tragic crash. It is also not known what specific Huracán model the footballer was driving when he crashed. The Huracán – a £250k+ Italian supercar beloved by football stars and celebrities – was in production from 2014 to 2024 and became one of Lamborghini's best-selling vehicles, with more than 25,000 units sold globally. The Huracán has faced safety-related recalls over the years, including headlight adjustments that could cause glare and reduce visibility, as well as a seat belt warning failure, reports. A September 2024 recall affected 39 examples of the Huracán EVO Spyder in the US. Lamborghini admitted that a crash protection bracket — essential to the front structural member — may have been installed on the wrong side due to human error at the Sant'Agata Bolognese factory. Diogo Jota's tragic final post revealed just hours before dying in car crash Affected cars were built between November 20, 2023 and July 26, 2024. That defect, reportedly discovered by a factory worker, prompted Lamborghini to block production and inspect affected cars, reports In November 2023, Lamborghini recalled 7,805 Huracán models built between July 30, 2014 and October 30, 2023. The issue was a function in the infotainment system which allowed drivers to adjust headlights horizontally — including into 'tourist mode' for left-hand driving — a feature not allowed under U.S. federal safety rules. This could create glare for oncoming traffic and reduce driver visibility. Lamborghini issued a software update to remove the feature. Certain 2021 and 2023 Huracán Coupé and Spyder models were recalled due to an issue where the door unlatching cable's safety clip might not have been properly secured during assembly. This raised concerns that doors could fail to open properly during an emergency. Lamborghini Huracán's main features LAUNCHED in 2014, the Huracán succeeded the Lamborghini Gallardo and became one of the brand's best-selling models. Production ended in 2024, with over 25,000 units sold globally before it was replaced by the plug-in hybrid Temerario. Here are some of the main features of the supercar: Engine & Performance • 5.2-litre naturally aspirated V10 engine • Power output varies by trim, with up to 640 cv (632 hp) in the Huracán Performante • 0–62 mph in 3.2 seconds (varies by model) • Top speed: over 200 mph Variants • Huracán EVO • Huracán Performante • Huracán STO (Super Trofeo Omologata) • Huracán Spyder (convertible variants available across trims) Dimensions & Weight • Length: Approximately 4,459 - 4,520 mm (175.6 - 178 inches). • Width: Approximately 1,924 - 1,956 mm (75.7 - 77 inches). • Height: Approximately 1,165 - 1,248 mm (45.9 - 49.1 inches). • Curb weight (with fluids): Around 1,553 kg (3,423 lbs). • Dry weight (without fluids): Can be as low as 1,339 kg (2,952 lbs) Lamborghini advised that authorised dealers would inspect and fix the problem at no charge. Some models produced between 2021 and early 2022 were also recalled after it was discovered the seat belt warning chime and dashboard visual indicator might not activate when the vehicle dropped below 20 km/h — a failure to meet minimum safety standards. In a statement, a spokesperson for Lamborghini told The Sun: "We are saddened to learn of the accident that occurred in Spain involving a Lamborghini, in which Diogo and André Jota tragically lost their lives. "In this moment of deep sorrow, we extend our heartfelt condolences to their family. "Automobili Lamborghini awaits further information regarding the circumstances of the incident, in full respect for the people involved." Prem ace gone Diogo Jota's tragic passing has sent shockwaves through the footballing world. The Liverpool and Portugal ace had only just married his long-term partner Rute Cardoso 10 days earlier and leaves behind three children. Pedro Proença, president of the Portuguese Football Federation, said: 'We have lost two champions. 'The passing of Diogo and André Silva is an irreparable loss for Portuguese football, and we will do everything possible to honor their legacy every day.' Liverpool Football Club said it was 'devastated' by the news. Meanwhile, Cristiano Ronaldo paid tribute, writing: 'It doesn't make sense… I know you will always be with them. Rest in Peace, Diogo and André.' 8 Jota's brother André Silva also died at the scene Credit: FC PORTO 8 The Portuguese footballer had just married his long-term partner Rute Cardoso days before his tragic death and leaves behind three children 8 Jota pictured (right) with his wife and brother Andre Credit: Instagram
Daily Mirror
44 minutes ago
- Daily Mirror
Truck driver who murdered his wife with hammer is jailed for life
An Italian truck driver has been handed a life sentence after a court heard he butally murdered his wife before impersonating her in messages to friends to pretend she was alive A truck driver who murdered his wife with a hammer before using her phone for months to pretend she was alive has been jailed for life. Francesca Deidda vanished on May 10, 2024, in Sardinia, Italy, with her friends growing increasingly suspicious in the wake of her shock disapperance. The 42-year-old's husband Igor Sollai, 43, was found to have killed his wife before stuffing her body into a duffel bag and dumping it under a bridge in a remote part of the Italian island, where it lay undiscovered for more than two months. A court in Cagliari heard how Sollai bashed her head with a hammer eight times while she was lying on a sofa at their home. The court was told the truck driver then put up that same sofa for sale online just days after and used Deidda's phone to impersonate her. On WhatsApp, he sent cheery messages to her friends and colleagues and emailed a resignation letter to her boss at the call centre where she worked. He also sold her Toyota Yaris in a bid to gather enough money to flee to his brother's home in the Netherlands, according to investigators. Deidda's body was finally found on July 18 curled up in the foetal position inside the large duffel bag hidden beneath dense brush near a disused bridge in the countryside outside San Priamo, with the help of police sniffer dogs. The remote location was only accessible via a dirt track, reinforcing suspicions that the killer had carefully chosen it to avoid discovery. Beside her body, searchers found personal items including a bathrobe, a dental guard, and the remains of a sweatshirt. Her brother, who had reported her missing weeks earlier, had told investigators Sollai never attempted to search for his missing wife. Although WhatsApp messages continued to arrive from her number, they noticed she had stopped replying with voice notes or answering calls, something highly unusual for her. Sollai initially told police they were on a break and that he thought she was staying with family. But under questioning, investigators soon discovered that he had been posing as Francesca, messaging friends and relatives. An autopsy later confirmed that Francesca had been bludgeoned to death with a hammer, though decomposition made the precise time of death harder to determine. Sollai eventually confessed to the murder in what prosecutors described as an attempt not to show remorse, but to get a more lenient sentence. He was found guilty of aggravated femicide and concealment of a corpse and sentenced to life in prison, with one year in solitary confinement. He was also ordered to pay €1.4 million (£1.2 million) as compensation to the victim's family. After the verdict, Deidda's brother Andrea said: "I'm satisfied. Of course, nothing will change because my sister is no longer here and won't come back. But in terms of justice, I'm very satisfied - I'm pleased with the work done and with the sentence." Sollai's defence said the jail sentence was "expected" but they will try to get a decrease in the sum he was ordered to pay.
Glasgow Times
2 hours ago
- Glasgow Times
Oisin Murphy fined £70,000 and banned from driving for 20 months after admitting drink-driving
The 29-year-old was sentenced at Reading Magistrates' Court on Thursday after he pleaded guilty to one count of driving a motor vehicle while over the prescribed limit of alcohol. He was charged by postal requisition on June 19 after he drove his grey Mercedes A Class off the road and into a tree in Hermitage, Berkshire, at about 12.05am on April 27. He had a passenger with him at the time, who was the owner of the car, the court heard. They were both taken to hospital after the crash. Murphy was later discharged to take a breathalyser test at a police station at about 7am, which showed a reading of 66mg per 100 millilitres of breath. Oisin Murphy seen leaving court on Thursday (Jonathan Brady/PA) This meant he was 'just shy of twice above the drink-driving limit' at the time of driving, prosecutor Richard Atkins told the court. Sporting a dark blue suit, white shirt and tie, Murphy only spoke to confirm his name, date of birth, and address, before entering his guilty plea. Judge Sam Goozee, sentencing, told Murphy: 'You are lucky that neither you, your passenger, or the public were injured by your actions. 'I do balance that with the remorse you have shown for your actions. 'You have also recognised that you have let the public down by virtue of your actions, and your colleagues in the racing world.' Murphy's defence barrister Alex Di Francesco offered the court an apology on behalf of his client. Mr Di Francesco said: 'He wants to apologise, first to his passenger, to the public and other road users… and he wants to apologise to those whom he works alongside.' Oisin Murphy rode five winners at Royal Ascot last month (David Davies/PA) The day he was officially charged was the Thursday of Royal Ascot week, when he rode a double courtesy of Arabian Story and Never So Brave. He ended the showpiece meeting with five winners in total. Murphy is due to be in action at Saratoga on Friday night, where he is booked to partner New Century in the Belmont Derby Invitational Stakes, before jetting back from America in time to team up with 2000 Guineas winner Ruling Court in Saturday's Coral-Eclipse at Sandown. In addition to his fine, Murphy must pay a £2,000 surcharge and £85 in costs. The figures were calculated based on his annual earnings, which the court heard are in the region of £250,000 a year, in addition to a weekly salary of £1,250.
