logo
Court rules in favor of Korean American that suspicion does not constitute draft dodging

Court rules in favor of Korean American that suspicion does not constitute draft dodging

Korea Herald07-04-2025
A South Korean court recently ruled in favor of a Korean American man, who challenged the state for dismissing his request to reinstate his South Korean nationality based on the suspicion he had illegally refused to do his mandatory military service here, according to court officials on Monday.
Seoul Administrative Court said a simple suspicion is not enough to reject the plaintiff's request to restore his nationality, pointing out that there is no specific evidence to prove the accusation made by the Ministry of Justice.
The plaintiff, born in 1986, had been living primarily outside of Korea since the age of 16 and acquired US citizenship in July 2022 at the age of 35. He filed for the restoration of his South Korean citizenship in December of that year, which the ministry rejected on grounds that his acquiring of US citizenship is believed to have been designed to avoid mandatary military conscription in South Korea.
All able-bodied South Korean men are mandated to serve in the military for at least 18 months, but the Military Service Act in the past had exempted those over 35 of such duties. Those who evaded conscription without justifiable clause, those whose enlistment for noncombat duties had been cancelled, and those who violated the state permit to stay overseas -- such as returning to the country after the permitted period -- are subject to enlistment until age 37.
South Korean men have the freedom of travel, but those who are at least 25 years old and have not yet served their mandatory military duty have to receive government permission to travel overseas. This is to prevent draft-dodging via emigration.
The Military Service Act allows male citizens to postpone enlistment under justifiable causes, which include educational commitment at tertiary educational institutes or higher and residence outside of the country. The plaintiff in question was permitted by the government to stay outside the country until Dec. 31, 2023.
The court pointed out that the plaintiff had been permitted by the state to stay outside the country until Dec. 31, 2023, and that he had been effectively exempted from conscription as of Jan. 1, 2022. This was the year when he turned 36, and Article 2-2 of the Military Service Act states that one is regarded to have become a certain age in Jan. 1 of a given year.
By this logic, the court said the plaintiff had already been exempted from the military duties when he became a US citizen. "It would have been possible for the plaintiff to expect that he would not have to shoulder the military duties even without losing his South Korean citizenship. Thus it cannot be considered that applying for US citizenship was a reasonable or unavoidable means for him to avoid the duties," the court said in its ruling.
"A vague suspicion itself is not sufficient in such case, and there must be probable cause to strongly suspect draft dodging, such as the purpose of stay in another country, reasons for acquiring the foreign nationality and the situation and time of losing the Korean nationality," the court stated.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Lutnick says he could hear 'expletives' out of Korea following trade deal with Japan
Lutnick says he could hear 'expletives' out of Korea following trade deal with Japan

Korea Herald

time4 hours ago

  • Korea Herald

Lutnick says he could hear 'expletives' out of Korea following trade deal with Japan

US Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick said Thursday that he could hear "expletives" out of South Korea after Japan reached a trade deal with US President Donald Trump's administration earlier this week. Lutnick made the remarks, apparently suggesting that the tariff deal between the United States and Japan might have created a sense of urgency for South Korea, which seeks to reach a deal to avoid or lower the Trump administration's 25 percent "reciprocal" tariff set to kick in on Aug. 1. "I could hear the expletives out of Korea when they read the Japanese deal because the Koreans and the Japanese ... they stare at each other," he said in a CNBC interview. "So you can imagine what they were thinking when they saw that Japan made that deal ... They were like, 'Oh man!," he added, underscoring that Koreans "very much" want to make a deal. On Tuesday, Trump announced the deal with Tokyo that would lower the threatened 25 percent reciprocal tariff for Japan to 15 percent in return for Japan's agreement to invest US$550 billion in the US, increase US rice imports by 75 percent and buy 100 Boeing aircraft, to name a few. During the interview, Lutnick said that he will engage in a meeting with South Korean negotiators in Washington on the day, after bilateral high-level trade talks, slated for Friday, were postponed. Korea's Industry Minister Kim Jung-kwan and Trade Minister Yeo Han-koo are currently in Washington amid Seoul's stepped-up efforts to strike a deal with the US "Of course, they are going to be in my office today talking," the secretary said. Seoul and Washington had planned to hold "two-plus-two" trade talks on Friday, where Seoul's Finance Minister Koo Yun-cheol, Trade Minister Yeo, Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent and US Trade Representative Jamieson Greer were set to get together.

Lee seeks stronger ties in calls with German, Uzbek leaders
Lee seeks stronger ties in calls with German, Uzbek leaders

Korea Herald

time16 hours ago

  • Korea Herald

Lee seeks stronger ties in calls with German, Uzbek leaders

President Lee Jae Myung on Thursday held separate phone calls with his counterparts in Germany and Uzbekistan, his office said, to discuss strengthening bilateral cooperation. During his call with German Chancellor Friedrich Merz, Lee highlighted the strong relationship between the two nations. Merz agreed, noting that Germany and South Korea are important partners that share the core values of democracy, human rights and free trade. The two leaders also agreed on the hope of meeting at the earliest opportunity. In his conversation with Uzbek President Shavkat Mirziyoyev, Lee expressed his hope to elevate the "special strategic partnership" between South Korea and Uzbekistan. Mirziyoyev reciprocated by saying he holds a "special affection" for South Korea and wishes to see the relationship continue to grow. The two also acknowledged their countries' successful and practical cooperation in various sectors, including infrastructure and transportation. Lee requested Mirziyoyev pay special attention to the difficulties South Korean companies face while operating in Uzbekistan. (Yonhap)

Seoul, Tokyo top diplomats vow to strengthen ties in 1st phone call
Seoul, Tokyo top diplomats vow to strengthen ties in 1st phone call

Korea Herald

time17 hours ago

  • Korea Herald

Seoul, Tokyo top diplomats vow to strengthen ties in 1st phone call

Foreign Minister Cho Hyun on Thursday held his first phone call with his Japanese counterpart, Takeshi Iwaya, discussing regional issues and bilateral relations, the foreign ministry said. During the conversation, Cho stressed the importance of Seoul-Tokyo relations, describing them as a key axis of the South Korean government's pragmatic diplomacy, alongside trilateral cooperation with Washington. Cho, who took office on Monday, suggested the two countries work to build a more solid, future-oriented relationship based on mutual trust and understanding. The Japanese foreign minister congratulated Cho on his appointment and expressed his desire to continue and strengthen their close cooperation, according to the ministry. The ministry added both ministers agreed on the need to deepen mutual understanding and work closely together across various sectors, especially in light of complex global challenges. (Yonhap)

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store