Colleges to alter entry requirements for medicine amid concern applicants ‘gaming' aptitude test
Applicants are required to combine their Leaving Certificate results with the
Hpat
(Health Professions Admission Test), which was introduced in 2009 to assess skills deemed important for medicine, such as reasoning, problem-solving and interpersonal skills.
While the 2½-hour test was initially envisaged as one which candidates could not study for, there is now an extensive private tuition industry where students can spend up to €800 over 15 weeks to prepare for the assessment.
[
My daughter wants to study medicine. Are grinds for the Hpat worth it?
Opens in new window
]
The deans of Irish medical schools met recently and agreed to significantly reduce the weighting attached to the test, according to well-placed sources.
READ MORE
The planned changes, which will require sign-off by the academic councils of universities, would likely have a two-year lead-in time before they are implemented, according to informed sources.
The Hpat is marked out of a total of 300 points, which is added to a candidate's Leaving Cert score. For example, a student who gets 500 points in the Leaving Cert and 200 points in the Hpat gets a combined score of 700 points.
Under revised plans, the Hpat would be reduced to 150 points. This, say sources, means the test would carry the equivalent weight of about one extra subject for entry purposes.
About 3,000 students take the test each year, which is required to study undergraduate medicine at University of Galway, the Royal College of Surgeons in Ireland, Trinity College Dublin, UCC and UCD. University of Limerick also requires the Hpat for entry to its master's in occupational therapy and speech and language therapy.
The Hpat was introduced under then minister for education Mary Hanafin, following concern that only those scoring very high Leaving Cert points were guaranteed entry to medicine. She said at the time that students would no longer need a 'perfect Leaving Cert' to enter medicine.
However, university sources say students who are able to afford extra support for their exams and Hpat tests are at a significant advantage when it comes to studying medicine.
Latest Higher Education Authority data, for example, show about 33 per cent of medicine students are from affluent backgrounds, compared with 18 per cent of students overall. Only 3 per cent of medicine students are from disadvantaged backgrounds, compared to 11 per cent overall.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Almost €100m spent on companies that use HSE facilities and staff to cut waiting lists after hours
Close to €100 million has been spent in just over two-and-a-half years on engaging external companies that use HSE -owned facilities and equipment after normal working hours – in many cases employing existing health service staff – to reduce public waiting lists. A report for Minister for Health Jennifer Carroll MacNeill , published on Tuesday night, reveals 83 serving or former health staff are acting as directors in 148 companies providing what are known as insourcing and outsourcing arrangements to reduce waiting lists. It says 23 of these company directors are serving HSE personnel. About 500,000 instances of care were provided from the beginning of 2023 to the first quarter of this year. . READ MORE At the same time more than 13 million instances of care were provided by the HSE during core working days. HSE chief executive Bernard Gloster , who drew up the report, is to tell an Oireachtas committee on Wednesday that the figures suggest that 'in waiting-list management we have developed an over-reliance on insourcing to supplement core activity'. 'Insourcing by its nature carries risks and having assessed these I have agreed with the Minister and the Department [of Health] the need to take a series of steps which firstly reduce those risks and increase safeguards and secondly which removes our dependency on insourcing,' he is expected to say. He is to say that the HSE has carried out a review covering a 27-month period, taking in 2023/2024 and the first quarter of this year, to identify the scale of the dependency the health service has on insourcing and on outsourcing. Mr Gloster will define insourcing as the practice of engaging external companies or third-party providers to deliver services often outside of normal working hours using HSE-owned facilities and equipment. 'In many cases, these providers may employ or subcontract staff who are already directly employed by the HSE, effectively re-engaging internal staff through a separate commercial arrangement, typically at premium rates,' he is expected to say. 'It is not the use of standard overtime within employment contract arrangements of existing staff, which is a different form of insourcing.' [ National Treatment Purchase Fund seeks assurances from all hospitals that rules of waiting-list schemes being followed ] Following a number of controversies over insourcing arrangements, in April the Minister asked the HSE to examine on a national basis the scale and dependency of the health service on the practice. Last September an HSE internal audit revealed that two companies which received more than €1.5 million between them in contracts awarded by University Hospital Limerick without a competitive procurement process were owned or part-owned by employees at the facility. In May an internal report drawn up within a hospital run by Children's Health Ireland said there were 'serious concerns about the prudent and beneficial management' of National Treatment Purchase Fund (NTPF) funding in relation to a series of clinics run by one consultant. Mr Gloster is expected to tell the Oireachtas Committee on Health that overall €1.1 billion was spent over the period between insourcing and outsourcing – which involves buying care from the private sector. Much work in this area is carried out by the NTPF. He will say about €830 million was spent between insourcing and outsourcing over the period in acute settings, with the bulk being spent on outsourcing arrangements. 'Within acute settings €739 million of the spend is outsourcing and this ranges from private hospital care to private ambulances to laboratory products. That is to say not all of the outsourcing is for waiting-list management,' he is to say 'Within acute settings between €71 million and €91 million appears to be insourcing.' The NTPF, which will receive about €230 million in exchequer funding this year, is expected to say about 30 per cent of its focus is on insourcing. It is to say it only makes payments in relation to specific named patients who have been on a public waiting list and then only on receipt of detailed invoices from public hospitals confirming that care is completed and the patient discharged. The NTPF is also expected to say payments are only made to hospitals and never to individual consultants or hospital staff members.
Irish Times
4 hours ago
- Irish Times
Can you really be ‘coached' to pass aptitude tests for entry to medical school?
The deans of medical schools want to change entry requirements for studying medicine in Irish universities following concern that many applicants are being coached for tests aimed at determining their aptitude for working in the sector. Tell me more about these tests Applicants for undergraduate medicine are required to combine their Leaving Certificate results with the Hpat (Health Professions Admission Test), which was introduced in 2009 to assess skills deemed important for medicine, such as reasoning, problem-solving and interpersonal skills. While the 2½-hour test was initially envisaged as one that candidates could not study for, there is now an extensive private tuition industry where students can prepare for the assessment. How much are candidates paying for private tuition? There are lots of 'preparatory courses' available for students, who can spend up to €800 for a 15-week series of classes and mock exams. Typically, they are operated by so-called grind schools such as the Institute of Education in Dublin, Hewitt College in Cork and many others; in addition, there is something of a cottage industry among medical students who have done well in the test offering their services. READ MORE How widely used is the Hpat? About 3,000 students take the test each year, which is required to study undergraduate medicine at University of Galway, the Royal College of Surgeons in Ireland, Trinity College Dublin, UCC and UCD. University of Limerick also requires the Hpat for entry to its master's courses in occupational therapy and speech and language therapy. Can you really be coached to do better in the Hpat? When it was introduced in 2009, the Australian Council for Educational Research (Acer), which devised the Hpat, said it did 'not endorse any training college and actively discourages candidates attending them. They are a waste of the candidates' (or their parents') money.' However, there is evidence that suggests they can pay off. A review by five medical faculties three years after its introduction found 40 per cent of successful applicants each year had improved their Hpat score after resitting it and so got a place in an undergraduate medical school. The report found the greatest improvement was in the non-verbal reasoning section. There have been adjustments to the weighting of components of the test and changes to rules around when candidates can sit the test over the years. Nonetheless, critics say those who can afford expensive preparatory and repeat courses retain a significant advantage. Is the issue of 'coaching' candidates a concern outside Ireland? Yes, it is an issue elsewhere. Studies highlight that in countries such as Germany and the UK, private companies offer expensive preparatory courses for similar medical aptitude tests. They, too, are grappling with ethical questions about equal access, as these courses may improve test results and thus increase the likelihood of admission for wealthier candidates. Interestingly, Australia combines the test with a structured interview process to help identify those suited to the profession. So, what changes are being planned to the Hpat? The Hpat is marked out of a total of 300 points, which is added to a candidate's Leaving Cert score. For example, a student who gets 500 points in the Leaving Cert and 200 points in the Hpat gets a combined score of 700 points. Under revised plans, the Hpat would be reduced to 150 points. This, say sources, means the test would carry the equivalent weight of about one extra subject for entry purposes. When will changes come into effect? The planned changes will require sign-off by the academic councils of universities. In theory, this should be simple, says sources. If implemented, they would probably have a two-year lead-in time from when the changes are announced. Why was the Hpat introduced in the first place? It was introduced following concerns that medical applicants needed to achieve 'a perfect Leaving Cert', while those with an aptitude for medicine were falling through the cracks. The system that came in – which is still in place – says that for school leavers to be eligible to compete for entry to undergraduate medicine they must achieve a minimum of 480 points, meet minimum subject entry requirement and complete the Hpat. Hpat scores are added to Leaving Cert points, although Leaving Cert points above 550 are moderated, with one point awarded for every five scored above that level.
Irish Times
4 hours ago
- Irish Times
Drinking water is safe but problems persist with THMs, lead and other contaminants, says EPA
Almost 500,000 people in the State are served by 'at-risk' water supplies which need to be urgently addressed by Uisce Éireann , the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) has said. While public water is safe to drink for the vast majority of people, the agency's drinking water report for 2024, published on Wednesday, shows there were 45 supplies serving 497,000 people on the at-risk list – down from 57 supplies (serving 561,000 people) in 2023. The quality of Irish drinking water from public supplies remains very high, with more than 99.8 per cent of samples compliant with bacterial and chemical standards, but Uisce Éireann must ensure the supply network is more resilient, the EPA said. It acknowledges progress but warns moves 'to protect public health by removing lead from our supply networks and houses is still far too slow'. READ MORE The legal limit for lead in drinking water will halve in 2036 (from 10 micrograms per litre (ugl) to 5ug/l) – 'so much greater focus is needed by Government Departments and Uisce Éireann to remove lead from the supply network and public buildings'. It also highlights a problem of persistent levels of toxic trihalomethanes (THMs), which has been repeatedly highlighted by the EU. THM limits were exceeded in 31 supplies, compared to 41 in 2023, while pesticide limits were exceeded in 23 supplies – the same as 2023. Complete upgrades of supplies on the at risk list are needed to address issues with THMs and the parasite cryptosporidium, which can make people ill, 'without delay', it says. The report highlights storms in late 2024 and early 2025 resulted in significant disruption to supplies. Boil water notices were required due to the impacts of Storm Bert; Storm Darragh and Storm Eowyn in successive months. They caused power outages at treatment plants, resulting in water treatment processes being compromised, while extreme rainfall caused high turbidity – making water murky – with some plants unable to adequately treat water, the EPA notes. The EPA acknowledges a reduction 'long-term boil water notices' in 2024, down by a third to 33. Uisce Éireann said the report confirms public drinking water supplies meet 'exceptionally high standards'. This reflected sustained investment and operational improvements across the country with more than €1.3 billion invested in 2024 by the utility in upgrading water and wastewater treatment plants and networks, 'enhancing resilience and safety for communities', it said.
