logo
Daughter says her mum and sibling pushed her to give 10% of her salary to her estranged dad, who brought her ‘so much trauma' for the sake of filial piety

Daughter says her mum and sibling pushed her to give 10% of her salary to her estranged dad, who brought her ‘so much trauma' for the sake of filial piety

SINGAPORE: A daughter took to social media to share that she has been handing over 10 per cent of her monthly salary to her estranged father because her mother and sibling insisted she do so in the name of 'filial piety.'
Writing on the r/askSingapore subreddit, she explained that her parents only divorced when she was about to graduate from university. However, long before the separation, her father had already distanced himself from the family in more ways than one. She said he struggled with gambling addictions involving 4D and Toto. At the same time, her mother shouldered the financial burden of paying off his debts and supporting both children throughout their university education.
She also shared how deeply her father's actions had affected her emotionally over the years. 'He brought me so much trauma,' she wrote. 'He worked as a private hire driver for a good eight years throughout my schooling days, and while I see my peers having their parents willingly ferrying them to and fro school, the few times my dad did so voluntarily (after CCA at night, say around 8 to 9 p.m.), he would curse me out throughout the entire 40 minutes ride home, complaining about how late my school ended. I begged him to stop picking me up after.'
Despite her father's lack of emotional and financial support over the years, her mother and sibling still felt she had a responsibility to give him a portion of her income once she began working. Feeling obligated, she went along with the arrangement, but in time, she noticed that her father began to expect the money every month, even confronting her if he thought the amount was short.
Two years on, she now finds herself questioning the arrangement. 'I've been thinking if it's really necessary, since he has essentially contributed nothing (financially, emotionally) to my life growing up? I'd rather give the 10% to my mum on top of what I've been giving her.'
Turning to the online community for advice, she asked, 'Those who grew up in dysfunctional families, do you give your parents money? Keen to hear from those in similar divorced family situations.' 'When you get older/wiser, be the bigger person and move on (with) your life…'
Many Singaporeans related to her situation and shared that they too struggled with the idea of financially supporting parents who had been emotionally absent or unsupportive during their childhood.
One person wrote, 'My dad has always been irresponsible with money. He didn't contribute to my education or provide financial support, and he has even borrowed money from my mom and me without ever paying it back, so no, I don't give him any money. I do, however, give my mom a monthly allowance.'
Another commented, 'I didn't give either side money. I don't need to justify to others why I don't give them money. If there's really a need to, I'll just say that I'm reserving my savings to better the next generation, rather than to fix/upkeep the previous generation.'
A third shared, 'Parents divorced, I don't give to either parent. Your money and your life, and since you had a bad parent, you're not in any way wrong to skip giving him money. He can go earn his own money.'
That said, not everyone felt the same way. Some said they continue to give their parents an allowance, even though their upbringing had been far from ideal.
One wrote, 'Yes. As the only child, I'll just play my part as a son. When you get older/wiser, be the bigger person and move on (with) your life. You can't choose your parent.'
In other news, a woman renting a dual-key studio apartment turned to Reddit to express her frustrations about a 'weird and demanding' neighbour who, she says, has repeatedly overstepped boundaries and disrupted her peace at home.
Writing on r/askSingapore, she said the trouble started on the very day her neighbour, a middle-aged Chinese woman with a chihuahua, moved into the adjoining unit.
Read more: 'How do I make her stop?' — Woman says her neighbour is 'weird and demanding,' but she struggles to say no to their demands
Featured image by Depositphotos (for illustration purposes only)
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

2026 school year to start on Jan 2, end on Nov 20
2026 school year to start on Jan 2, end on Nov 20

CNA

time2 hours ago

  • CNA

2026 school year to start on Jan 2, end on Nov 20

SINGAPORE: The 2026 school year for all Ministry of Education (MOE) kindergartens, primary and secondary schools will begin on Jan 2 and end on Nov 20. Students in Kindergarten 2 and from Primary 2 to 6 will report to school on Jan 5, said the ministry on Wednesday (Jul 30). Those entering their first year in junior colleges (JCs) and Millennia Institute (MI) will start on Feb 4, with the rest of the JC and MI students starting earlier, on Jan 12. VACATION PERIODS There are four vacation periods for schools, JCs and MI in 2026. For MOE kindergartens, primary and secondary schools, the first vacation period starts on Mar 14 and ends on Mar 22. The second begins May 30 and ends on Jun 28, the third runs from Sep 5 to Sep 13 and the fourth from Nov 21 to Dec 31. JCs and MI mainly share the first three vacation periods as MOE kindergartens, primary and secondary schools. However, the final vacation period for JC students in Year 1 and MI students in Years 1 and 2 will be from Nov 28 to Dec 31. JC students in Year 2 and MI students in Year 3 will have their vacation period from the end of the GCE A-Level examinations to Dec 31. There will also be three scheduled school holidays in 2026:

'It's embarrassing': Netizens criticise MOM's appreciation coins for migrant workers in sinkhole rescue
'It's embarrassing': Netizens criticise MOM's appreciation coins for migrant workers in sinkhole rescue

New Paper

time2 hours ago

  • New Paper

'It's embarrassing': Netizens criticise MOM's appreciation coins for migrant workers in sinkhole rescue

Netizens are questioning why authorities have not done more to reward the efforts of the migrant workers who rescued a woman from the Tanjong Katong Road South sinkhole. A thread posted on the r/Singapore subreddit captioned "That's so sad, wish they were given something more useful", featuring a video of Minister of State (MOS) for Manpower Dinesh Vasu Dash presenting commemorative coins to the workers, has quickly gained traction. Mr Dinsh, who paid a personal visit to the workers' dormitory on the evening of July 27, said the coins are a small token of appreciation that goes a long way in recognising the contributions of migrant workers in Singapore. The coins, presented in red boxes and akin certificates of commendation, are similar to those given to four migrant workers who helped rescue children from a shophouse fire in River Valley in April. 'It's embarrassing': Netizens criticise coins But many commentors on the Reddit thread expressed frustration and disappointment over the gesture. One called it "embarrassing", suggesting that the workers should have been given something more official, such as formal certificates that could support them in future job applications. Others questioned why the workers were not offered something more practical such as cash or vouchers. "Does this coin mean anything to the workers?" one asked, adding that a monetary reward, even if modest, "would mean the world to them". Should good deeds always be rewarded with money? While public sentiment appears to have been largely critical, it also raises a broader question: should good deeds be rewarded with money? Associate Professor Tan Ern Ser, a sociologist at the National University of Singapore (NUS), told The New Paper that he believes it is "inappropriate" for acts of bravery or civic responsibility to be routinely rewarded with cash. Financial incentives and rewards like cash gifts "could undermine the intrinsic rewards of helpfulness," said A/P Tan. Financial support is what workers value: IRR Local charity ItsRainingRaincoats (IRR) recently launched a fundraiser that has since exceeded its target of raising $70,000 for the migrant workers involved in the sinkhole rescue. In an interview with The New Paper, IRR founder Dipa Swaminathan said she believes financial support is what the workers truly value, and is "incredibly proud" of the amount raised. Ms Swaminathan also highlighted the emotional significance of the support: the validation the workers would feel, and the goodwill such gestures could foster. "It would be tremendous for them," she said. MOM had not responded to TNP's queries as of press time.

Man warns SG singles: Don't marry Scorpios! My mum and sis are one; they're masters at holding grudges, so spare yourself and your future kid the drama
Man warns SG singles: Don't marry Scorpios! My mum and sis are one; they're masters at holding grudges, so spare yourself and your future kid the drama

Independent Singapore

timea day ago

  • Independent Singapore

Man warns SG singles: Don't marry Scorpios! My mum and sis are one; they're masters at holding grudges, so spare yourself and your future kid the drama

SINGAPORE: In the ever-entertaining world of astrology-fuelled drama, a Singaporean man has issued a galactic-level warning to humanity: 'Please guys, don't marry Scorpios. Just don't. Help yourself and your future kid be at peace.' This astrological red flag was raised anonymously on the SGWhispers website, which was then flung into the Facebook cosmos, where it promptly went supernova. 'My mum and sister are Scorpios… I have never heard a similar experience amongst my friends. They are experts at holding grudges, which you never knew existed until an argument erupts, and you are like wth since when were you pissed about that?' His post, dripping with exhaustion and celestial trauma, painted a vivid picture of Scorpio-fuelled domestic warfare. He then confessed the pain of living with two memory vaults that never forget or forgive. 'Seriously, they will never forget or forgive. I don't even know why I should be sorry when I was the victim -.-' With that, he launched his public service announcement: Don't marry Scorpios! Ever. Not even with Mercury in retrograde for the sake of your sanity and your hypothetical children's peace of mind. However, the stars weren't done stirring the pot. Enter a second Singaporean, armed with a 30-year friendship and a loving Scorpio partner, who was clearly not having it. 'I read the earlier post with much disagreement. The advice against marrying Scorpios is often based on misunderstandings about their personalities.' In a post so soothing it might as well have been dipped in lavender oil, the respondent launched a heartfelt defence of Scorpio-kind, describing them as passionate, loyal, introspective, and deeply capable of meaningful connection. 'Sure, Scorpios are known for being intense and a little mysterious… but these traits can actually make them really great partners. Their passion and loyalty can bring a lot of depth and commitment to a relationship.' The netizen added that Scorpios aren't cold—they're just emotionally encrypted. Like a human vault with no 'forgot password' option. 'Far from being a 'dangerous' sign to marry, Scorpios are actually protective and caring once they trust you.' The defender then called for common sense over cosmic stereotypes: 'Dismissing Scorpios based solely on their star sign would be an unfair and narrow-minded view of a deeply complex and capable individual.' The battle of the star signs quickly became a masterclass in modern compatibility theory versus Mercury-fuelled mayhem. While the first man found himself traumatised by the long emotional memory and grudge-hoarding tendencies of his Scorpio relationships, the second encouraged readers to look past the horoscope and into the heart. The philosophical divide is whether your relationship should be governed by love languages or lunar alignments. So what can we learn from this? Perhaps it's not the Scorpio moon that's ruining relationships, but how we orbit one another emotionally. After all, whether your partner's a Leo, Libra, or a lunchbox-loving Taurus, it's communication—not constellation—that keeps the peace. As the Scorpio wars rage on in comment sections and coffee shops alike, one truth remains universal: whether it's stars or scars, we all carry a little baggage into our relationships. The question is whether we're willing to unpack it or just blame it on Pluto. In another cosmic chaos and emotional entanglements, a woman took to the internet to vent her fury about another girl who was allegedly 'going after' her boyfriend. See also How to tell if she likes you—or if you're just overthinking it Wonder what star signs these two are, locked in battle… also Scorpio? Or maybe Gemini? Drama-rising Sagittarius? Who knows for sure… and does it even matter? Nevertheless, she's torn between rage and confusion, so she turned to the online hive mind for advice on how to deal with what she calls 'shameless and disgusting' behaviour. You can read her full complaint over here: Woman asks why some girls are 'shameless and disgusting' for going after her boyfriend

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store