
The Odds of a City-Killing Asteroid Hitting Earth Keep Rising
An asteroid discovered late last year is continuing to stir public interest as its odds of striking planet Earth less than eight years from now continue to increase.
Two weeks ago, when Ars first wrote about the asteroid, designated 2024 YR4, NASA's Center for Near Earth Object Studies estimated a 1.9 percent chance of an impact with Earth in 2032. NASA's most recent estimate has the likelihood of a strike increasing to 3.2 percent. Now that's not particularly high, but it's also not zero.
This story originally appeared on Ars Technica, a trusted source for technology news, tech policy analysis, reviews, and more. Ars is owned by WIRED's parent company, Condé Nast.
Naturally the prospect of a large ball of rock tens of meters across striking the planet is a little worrisome. This is large enough to cause localized devastation near its impact site, likely on the order of the Tunguska event of 1908, which leveled some 500 square miles (1,295 square kilometers) of forest in remote Siberia.
To understand why the odds from NASA are changing and whether we should be concerned about 2024 YR4, Ars connected with Robin George Andrews, author of the recently published book How to Kill an Asteroid . Good timing with the publication date, eh?
Ars: Why are the impact odds increasing?
Robin George Andrews: The asteroid's orbit is not known to a great deal of precision right now, as we only have a limited number of telescopic observations of it. However, even as the rock zips farther away from Earth, certain telescopes are still managing to spy it and extend our knowledge of the asteroid's orbital arc around the sun. The odds have fluctuated in both directions over the last few weeks, but overall, they have risen; that's because the amount of uncertainty astronomers have as to its true orbit has shrunk, but Earth has yet to completely fall out of that zone of uncertainty. As a proportion of the remaining uncertainty, Earth is taking up more space, so for now, its odds are rising.
Think of it like a beam of light coming out of the front of that asteroid. That beam of light shrinks as we get to know its orbit better, but if Earth is yet to fall out of that beam, it takes up proportionally more space. So, for a while, the asteroid's impact odds rise. It's very likely that, with sufficient observations, Earth will fall out of that shrinking beam of light eventually, and the impact odds will suddenly fall to zero. The alternative, of course, is that they'll rise close to 100 percent.
What are we learning about the asteroid's destructive potential?
The damage it could cause would be localized to a roughly city-sized area, so if it hits the middle of the ocean or a vast desert, nothing would happen. But it could trash a city, or completely destroy much of one, with a direct hit.
The key factor here (if you had to pick one) is the asteroid's mass. Each time the asteroid gets twice as long (presuming it's roughly spherical), it brings with it 8 times more kinetic energy. So if the asteroid is on the smaller end of the estimated size range—40 meters—then it will be as if a small nuclear bomb exploded in the sky. At that size, unless it's very iron-rich, it wouldn't survive its atmospheric plunge, so it would explode in mid-air. There would be modest-to-severe structural damage right below the blast, and minor to moderate structural damage over tens of miles. A 90-meter asteroid would, whether it makes it to the ground or not, be more than 10 times more energetic; a large nuclear weapon blast, then. A large city would be severely damaged, and the area below the blast would be annihilated.
Do we have any idea where the asteroid might strike on Earth?
The 'risk corridor' is currently spread over parts of the eastern Pacific Ocean, northern South America, the Atlantic Ocean, parts of Africa, the Arabian Sea, and South Asia. Additional observations will ultimately narrow this down, if an impact remains possible.
What key observations are we still waiting for that might clarify the threat?
Most telescopes will lose sight of this 'small' asteroid in the coming weeks. But the James Webb Space Telescope will be able to track it until May. For the first time, it's been authorized for planetary defense purposes, largely because its infrared eye allows it to track the asteroid further out than optical light telescopes. JWST will not only improve our understanding of its orbit, but also constrain its size. First observations should appear by the end of March.
JWST may rule out an impact in 2032. But there's a chance we may be stuck with a few-percentage impact probability until 2028, when the asteroid makes its next Earth flyby. Bit awkward, if so.
NASA's DART mission successfully shifted an asteroid's orbit in 2022. Could this technology be used?
Not necessarily. DART—a type of spacecraft called a kinetic impactor—was a great success. But it still only changed Dimorphos' orbit by a small amount. Ideally, you want many years of advance notice to deflect an asteroid with something like DART to ensure the asteroid has moved out of Earth's way. I've often been told that at least 10 years prior to impact is best if you want to be sure to deflect a city-killing-size asteroid. That's not to say deflection is impossible; it just becomes trickier to pull off. You can't just hit it with a colossal spacecraft, because you may fragment it into several still-dangerously sized pieces. Hit it too softly, and it will still hit Earth, but somewhere that wasn't originally going to be hit. You have to be super careful here.
Some rather clever scientists at the Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory (which has a superb planetary defense contingent) worked out that, for a 90-meter asteroid, you need 10 years to confidently deflect it with a kinetic impactor to prevent an Earth impact. So, to deflect 2024 YR4, if it's 90 meters long and we have just a few years of time, we'd probably need a bigger impactor spacecraft (but don't break it!)—or we'd need several kinetic impactors to deflect it (but each has to work perfectly).
Eight years until impact is a little tight. It's not impossible that the choice would be made to use a nuclear weapon to deflect it; this could be very awkward geopolitically, but a nuke would impart a bigger deflection than an equivalent DART-like spacecraft. Or, maybe, they'd opt to try and vaporize the asteroid with something like a 1-megaton nuke, which LLNL says would work with an asteroid this size.
So it's kind of late in the game to be planning an impact mission?
This isn't an ideal situation. And humanity has never tried to stop an asteroid impact for real. I imagine that if 2024 YR4 does become an agreed-upon emergency, the DART team (JHUAP plus NASA, mostly) would join forces with SpaceX (and other space agencies, particularly ESA but probably others) to quickly build the right-mass kinetic impactor (or impactors) and get ready for a deflection attempt close to 2028, when the asteroid makes its next Earth flyby. But yeah, eight years is not too much time.
A deflection could work! But it won't be as simple as just hitting the asteroid really hard in 2028.
How important is NASA to planetary defense?
Planetary defense is an international security concern. But right now, NASA (and America, by extension) is the vanguard. Its planetary defenders are the watchers on the wall, the people most responsible for not just finding these potentially hazardous asteroids before they find us, but also those most capable of developing and deploying tech to prevent any impacts. America is the only nation with (for now!) a well-funded near-Earth object-hunting program, and is the only nation to have tested out a planetary defense technique. It's a movie cliché that America is the only nation capable of saving the world from cosmic threats. But, for the time being—even with amazing planetary defense mission contributions from ESA and JAXA—that cliché remains absolutely true.
This story originally appeared on Ars Technica.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Launch recap: SpaceX rocket launch from Florida on Starlink mission Tuesday night
Launch recap: Scroll down to read updates from the Starlink 10-29 mission, which launched 11:37 p.m. July 29 from Launch Complex 40 at Cape Canaveral Space Force Station. Original story: Those waiting for a rocket launch do not have to wait much longer − a Falcon 9 rocket is planned to lift off tonight from Florida's Space Coast. SpaceX plans to launch the Starlink 10-29 mission now at 11:37 p.m. July 29. Various factors, such as weather at the launch and booster landing locations could change timing. SpaceX states it has until 3:30 a.m. July 30 to launch during this window. Lift off will be from Launch Complex 40 at Cape Canaveral Space Force Station. The rocket will travel on a northeast trajectory, meaning those north of the Space Coast could get great views of the bright rocket against the night sky. The mission is the latest batch of 27 SpaceX's Starlink internet satellites, which deliver internet to customers in some of the most remote areas in the world. No Space Coast sonic booms will follow the liftoff, as the rocket's first-stage will land on the Just Read the Instructions drone ship stationed in the Atlantic Ocean. When is the next Florida rocket launch? Is there a launch today? Upcoming SpaceX, NASA, ULA rocket launch schedule at Cape Canaveral Countdown Timer SpaceX Falcon 9 booster lands Update 11:45 p.m.: The Falcon 9 first-stage booster just landed aboard SpaceX's drone ship Just Read the Instructions out on the Atlantic Ocean, completing its 26th mission. SpaceX Liftoff! Update 11:37 p.m.: SpaceX has just launched the Falcon 9 rocket carrying 28 Starlink satellites from Cape Canaveral SLC-40! SpaceX launch webcast begins Update 11:32 p.m.: SpaceX's launch webcast hosted on X (formerly Twitter) is now posted above, right below the countdown clock. Liftoff is scheduled in five minutes from Cape Canaveral Space Force Station. We are 10 minutes from tonight's SpaceX Falcon 9 rocket launch! Update 11:27 p.m.: T-10 minutes! Head outside if you plan on catching this launch! If you have clear skies, it will be hard to miss the bright rocket rising into the night sky. Simply look towards the direction South of Kennedy Space Center from your direction. SpaceX launch from Cape Canaveral countdown timeline Update 11:17 p.m.: T- 20 minutes until tonight's launch. Here's a behind-the-scenes rundown of SpaceX's countdown timeline. T-minus: 38 minutes: SpaceX launch director verifies 'go' for propellant load. 35 minutes: Rocket-grade kerosene and first-stage liquid oxygen loading begins. 16 minutes: Second-stage liquid oxygen loading begins. 7 minutes: Falcon 9 begins engine chill prior to launch. 1 minute: Command flight computer begins final prelaunch checks; propellant tank pressurization to flight pressure begins. 45 seconds: SpaceX launch director verifies 'go' for launch. 3 seconds: Engine controller commands engine ignition sequence to start. 0 seconds: Liftoff. SpaceX Falcon 9 fueling now underway Update 11:06 p.m.: Visual cues indicate Falcon 9 fueling procedures are now underway at Launch Complex 40, though SpaceX has yet to make an official announcement. That means tonight's Starlink mission is now locked in to lift off at 11:37 p.m. without any countdown delays, or else the launch must be postponed. SpaceX Falcon 9 booster slated to fly 26th mission Update 10:56 p.m.: Tonight's booster is flying for the 26th time. Previous missions include 21 Starlink missions, CRS-24, Eutelsat HOTBIRD 13F, OneWeb 1, SES-18 and SES-19. Liftoff is scheduled for 11:37 p.m. SpaceX launch prep underway in Brevard Update 10:46 p.m.: Brevard County Emergency Management officials have activated the agency's launch operations support team ahead of SpaceX's upcoming Falcon 9 launch. SpaceX Starship launch upcoming Update 10:36 p.m.: SpaceX has announced the next planned launch of Starship out of Starbase, Texas. This launch comes after the last few missions ended in the loss of the ship before reentry. There is currently no official launch date. The uncrewed missions are aimed at pushing the design limits of Starship. Starship is aimed at becoming SpaceX's next workhorse launch system. SpaceX anticipates to eventually launch from and land at multiple Florida launch pads. Tonight's Falcon 9 launch is in just over an hour from now. SpaceX completes test fire ahead of Crew-11 launch from Florida Update 10:25 p.m.: On July 29, SpaceX completed testing of the Falcon 9 rocket which will launch NASA Crew-11 to the ISS. This test fire comes after an attempted test aborted on Monday, July 28 with less than a minute to the engine fire. SpaceX attributed the issue to the 'transporter erector's cradle arm position indication'. The transporter erector is what transports the rocket and raises it into launch position. Tonight's liftoff is still planned for 11:37 p.m. Weather outlook released for NASA Crew-11 SpaceX launch Update 10:15 p.m.: The 45th Weather Squadron has released the T-2 day weather report ahead of the planned July 31 launch of NASA's Crew-11. It is predicted launch day will see an 85% chance of favorable conditions during the time of the liftoff. The crew of four will launch to the International Space Station from NASA's Kennedy Space Center Pad 39A. Liftoff is planned for 12:09 p.m. July 31. NASA celebrates anniversary Update 10:05 p.m.: On this day in 1958, the National Aeronautics and Space Act was signed and NASA saw its creation. NASA has been solving the mysteries of the solar system and beyond for the last 67 years. SpaceX launch from Cape Canaveral weather Update 9:53 p.m.: The 45th Weather Squadron predicts a 90% chance of favorable conditions for tonight's launch, which is currently set for 11:37 p.m. Brooke Edwards is a Space Reporter for Florida Today. Contact her at bedwards@ or on X: @brookeofstars. This article originally appeared on Florida Today: Launch recap: SpaceX Falcon 9 rocket launch from Florida Tuesday night Solve the daily Crossword
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
See photos: SpaceX rocket launch from Cape Canaveral on Starlink mission Tuesday night
On the night of Tuesday, July 29, a SpaceX Falcon 9 rocket launched 28 Starlink internet satellites to orbit. The liftoff occurred 11:37 p.m. from Launch Complex 40 at Cape Canaveral Space Force Station. The mission was referred to as Starlink 10-29. The next launch is set for no earlier than 12:09 p.m. July 31 from NASA's Kennedy Space Center Pad 39A. The Falcon 9 rocket will send NASA's Crew-11 to the International Space Station. With the booster returning to the Cape Canaveral Landing Zone, a sonic boom will be heard throughout the Space Coast area. When is the next Florida rocket launch? Is there a launch today? Upcoming SpaceX, NASA, ULA rocket launch schedule at Cape Canaveral Brooke Edwards is a Space Reporter for Florida Today. Contact her at bedwards@ or on X: @brookeofstars. This article originally appeared on Florida Today: Photos: SpaceX Falcon 9 rocket launch in Florida Tuesday night Solve the daily Crossword


Digital Trends
2 hours ago
- Digital Trends
SpaceX needs good weather for Thursday's crewed launch. How's it looking?
SpaceX and NASA are now a short time away from launching four more astronauts to the International Space Station (ISS), with all eyes now on the weather to see if it's going to play ball. The mission team is currently targeting 12:09 p.m. ET on Thursday, July 31, for the liftoff from Launch Complex 39A (LC-39A) at NASA's Kennedy Space Center in Florida. Recommended Videos At the moment, it's looking like the four Crew-11 astronauts will be able to get away on time, barring any last-minute technical hitch. According to the 45th Weather Squadron, which gives detailed assessments for air and space operations in the U.S., Thursday's mission from Kennedy has an 85% chance of happening on time. But that means there's also a 15% chance of a delay, which is down to a possible isolated shower or thunderstorm near the launch window, the 45th Weather Squadron said in its report. AccuWeather says it'll be partly cloudy and humid on Thursday. It's not just the mission team watching the weather, as many people are also planning to head to the Space Coast to see the first crewed launch since the Ax-4 flight on June 25. NASA and SpaceX are also livestreaming the launch on their various social channels, including X and YouTube. For full details on how to watch, Digital Trends has all you need to know. Crew-11 comprises NASA astronauts Zena Cardman and Mike Fincke, along with Japan's Kimiya Yui and Russia's Oleg Platonov. They'll spend about six months living and working on the space station as it orbits Earth at a speed of around 17,500 mph. Fincke, the most experienced member of the crew, said earlier this week: 'I'm personally looking forward to going back up to the space station — I helped build it and now I'm getting to see it in its full maturity.' The American astronaut first went to orbit in 2004, with his last mission taking place in 2011. Meanwhile, it'll be the first spaceflight for Cardman and Platonov, and the second for Yui.